5 ms·
Assuming the last digit is a checksum and the first six are taken by the routing information, that leaves them 9 digits or a billion possible numbers per credit
by jandrese 6y ago
Assuming the last digit is a checksum and the first six are taken by the routing information, that leaves them 9 digits or a billion possible numbers per credit card issuer. Japan has a population of about 125 million. Are Japanese people cycling their numbers so frequently? Or are they big on ephemeral card numbers?
Is it not possible for an issuer to get a second prefix if they run out of digits?
I also wonder if credit card numbers aren't living on borrowed time anyway. Instead of adding more digits it might make sense to remove the digits entirely and only allow token based transactions. This does assume we figure out a way to do online purchases not using the digits.
- chrischen 6y agoCards can have nfc, and most people already have nfc readers in the form of phones. I think this is the easiest way to support cryptographic payments.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI’m honestly surprised the move to contactless hasn’t occurred faster, as the costs for hardware seem lower for nfc versus chip.
- hinkley 6y agoFor consumer commerce, between the contactless and the smart chips this should be solved. Someone else said the number is 'hidden' from the users but it's not hiding versus not hiding that's the problem. It's that for e-commerce the human has to transcribe the number by hand. You can't hide it, except via another system.
- GoblinSlayer 6y ago>except via another system AFAIK, that's how the first version of 3D secure worked: you were redirected to your bank site and authenticated the payment there.
- xxpor 6y agoIn the US retailers don't want to lose customer tracking they can do with fixed card numbers. This is why you see nonsense like "Kroger Pay" and other store specific payment apps. The hardware exists in nearly every terminal that supports EMV (Chip and pin/signature), the retailers just haven't turned it on. Meanwhile, with my Samsung phone and its mag strip emulation, I can use my phone nearly everywhere anyway even if the store doesn't want to support NFC.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoTracking is traditionally done with discount cards, and they are compatible with all payment methods. And there are applications that aggregate those discount cards in software: a discount card is just a short ID, nothing fancy.
- xxpor 6y agoThat's true in grocery stores but not other retailers.
- rswail 6y agoIt only hasn't moved in the US. In Australia, nearly all CC transactions are contactless, with the floor limit at AUD100 (USD70). During the pandemic, I haven't used cash for the last 6 months.
- tedd-the-tiger 6y agoIt's more of a no-pin limit. Payments above AUD100 can still be contactless, the POS terminal asks for the card's pin. I'm not sure if there's a hard limit at all to NFC payments. I've done some >$1000 transactions contactless.
- mjlee 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luhn_algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luhn_algorithm describes the way the check digit is calculated.
- bausano_michael 6y agoISBN also uses last digit as a check digit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Standard_Book_Number#Check https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Standard_Book_...
- michannne 6y agoI don't see how token based transactions would improve the situation. You still require a unique identifier per issuer per client per account.
- jandrese 6y agoThe identifier is hidden from the user so if it's huge and complex that is no problem. My point is that we're talking about putting a lot of effort into overhauling the system to support a scheme that is arguably already obsolete. If we're putting in the effort we should just remove the old insecure digits entirely and focus on a cleaner modern solution.
- michannne 6y agoThe problem with that is the purpose of a credit card system is convenience, especially the convenience involved in being able to represent the identifier in an easily compact manner. When it's a few groups of digits, I can print it onto a card or piece of paper, and just plug the digits in whenever I need to validate the number and run a transaction. You can't do that with a token. What happens when I want to use my friend's computer to pay for something on Amazon but I haven't saved my card number? Or when I get a new card? I get that the current credit card system is monolithic and outdated, but it's purpose isn't to be modern, it's to be reliable, convenient, and adaptable, and it does a swell job at those things. There's absolutely no need to spend astronomical amounts of money to replace this system with something more modern.
- ghayes 6y agoMany of those use cases probably shouldn’t be supported. It would cut down on fraud if we disallowed card not present transactions on unknown devices.
- kenniskrag 6y agoWith the EMV skimmer fraud is dropping. With 2FA on big transactions other frauds can be decreased. Some provider have a mobile app to accept the transaction and/or send a message after a transaction.
- lmm 6y ago> Assuming the last digit is a checksum and the first six are taken by the routing information, that leaves them 9 digits or a billion possible numbers per credit card issuer. Japan has a population of about 125 million. Are Japanese people cycling their numbers so frequently? Or are they big on ephemeral card numbers? Credit cards - and payment methods generally - are in their Cambrian explosion phase right now in Japan, particularly given the pandemic. Every company, big or small, is pushing their own. I recently had to open a new credit card because the gym I wanted to join only accepts payment via their partnered credit cards. It came with a linked electronic money card (as well as having native integration for a different electronic money format) that has what looks like its own 16 digit credit card number, presumably for internal payment infrastructure reasons, and an offer to apply for a separate linked credit card for shopping in China, three other kinds of linked electronic money cards (one for a supermarket chain, one for a local transport network)... Every shopping mall is pushing their card. My phone provider offered two olympic tie-in cards and a regular version (that would actually save me money if I could face going through the application). A theatre troupe I follow has a deep partnership with a card issuer and has their own branded cards. Bands have their own cards. Virtually any outfit with a loyalty/membership card is trying to turn it into a credit card. And so people can easily have multiple cards that they never use, because their loyalty card became a credit card but they're still only using it as a loyalty card.
- owenversteeg 6y agoAh, here's the real explanation! Interesting. I wonder how big the incentive is, and if anything changed to enable this. As for the incentive, I'd guess they get transaction fees cut from some ~2.75% to 0.5%ish with their own card, and then some kind of additional cash (maybe $50-$300?) from the issuing bank for gaining a customer?
- spiznnx 6y agoI don't know why it's exploding, but it also appears poised to explode here in the US too. I recently got a recruiter in my inbox for a startup "Guild Credit" that makes loyalty CC cards easy to issue for small businesses. Not sure what has changed recently.
- avianlyric 6y ago> that leaves them 9 digits or a billion possible numbers per credit card issuer. Issuers won’t issue every number, because that would make it trivial to enumerate valid card numbers. I know that PANs are printed in plain view, but they’re considered sensitive. > I also wonder if credit card numbers aren't living on borrowed time anyway. Instead of adding more digits it might make sense to remove the digits entirely and only allow token based transactions. It’s already happening! The tokenisation tech that powers Apple/Google pay can now be used by merchants. Buts it’s currently got very low uptake.