6 ms·
> If it is so unpopular, how come Firefox hasn’t axed it? Because I don't think it's quite unpopular. I'm a Pocket subscriber and use it very heavily, even befo
by bayindirh 6y ago
> If it is so unpopular, how come Firefox hasn’t axed it?
Because I don't think it's quite unpopular. I'm a Pocket subscriber and use it very heavily, even before it joined Mozilla and got integrated into FF).
It provides some revenue stream into Mozilla and it's a genuinely useful service.
> How come only popular things like advanced extension support gets axed?
There was a very detailed blog post about it recently. It boils down the architecture being a roadblock and being very open to operational abuse in terms of security and privacy of the users.
Sometimes, the most elegant and useful code gets the axe because, it genuinely blocks something further down the road. It's painful but, it sometimes needs to happen like this. Firefox is a very old code base. It's every part has been changed over time but, these changes were always gradual and connected to previous iterations so, the evolution kinda had a forced path out from some states.
> Why are they spending time and resources on horrific products like Pocket when they could be literally improving their browser. Why is it pushed so aggressively and shamelessly?
You might be thinking some service/product to be horrific but, I personally like to be able to read some stuff distraction free and being able store its permanent copies with my annotations on it very convenient from a knowledge base perspective. Looks like I'm not the only one so, the service's still alive.
- verroq 6y agoI just think it is very seedy to bundle it with the browser and it rubs a lot of people the wrong way.
- bayindirh 6y agoGoogle bundles a complete platform and a lot of proprietary features for Google products with Chrome, most people don't bat an eye. Opera bundles some features more than a browser (VPN, et al.) with the browser, similarly people don't get rubbed by it. Mozilla puts a button which is just a scriptlet to the UI and people got tipped off. It just sits there and can be turned off [1]. I've never experienced any aggressive marketing for Pocket by Firefox (in app or out of band). I only get a weekly articles digest which, I subscribed and, that's all. I wish we were living in an era where free and high quality software just survive without any revenue stream and web is not a mess of standards, bombardment of adverts and analytics frameworks and other sinister stuff but, that ship has unfortunately sailed and, I personally still angry about it. [1]: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/disable-or-re-enable-pocket-for-firefox https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/disable-or-re-enable-po...
- verroq 6y agoThis is whataboutism. Whenever someone criticises China, some guy comes out and says oh America does Y but worse. Not an argument.
- seppel 6y ago> It provides some revenue stream into Mozilla and it's a genuinely useful service. FF itself provides a massive revenue stream.
- bayindirh 6y agoAFAIK that revenue stream is search provider agreements and it's no revenue stream. In current conjecture, it's Google giving them some money to keep Mozilla afloat so, they don't become a monopoly per se. Please correct me, if I'm wrong.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoHow can you have a revenue stream from a search engine if you don't have a browser to view said stream? Therefore firefox is critical to that agreement. Google absolutely gives them cashola for being the default search engine. Most people never change that so it is about a 90% sure thing for google to make money from firefox users. The other things is they can point and say "see we have competition and we're friendly with them even!"