2 ms·
A short summary to clarify the "inclusionist" term, in case people don't check your link: > The terms reflect differing opinions on the appropriate scope of th
by dgellow 6y ago
A short summary to clarify the "inclusionist" term, in case people don't check your link:
> The terms reflect differing opinions on the appropriate scope of the encyclopedia and corresponding tendencies either to delete or to include a given encyclopedia article
> "Deletionists" are proponents of selective coverage and removal of articles seen as poorly defended. Deletionist viewpoints are commonly motivated by a desire that Wikipedia be focused on and cover significant topic
> "Inclusionists" are proponents of broad retention, including retention of "harmless" articles and articles otherwise deemed substandard to allow for future improvement.
- JdeBP 6y agoAn even better summary is that inclusionism and deletionism never existed as actual genuine philosophies. They began because a person early in the project who was a source of several odd ideas, and who was having arguments on the English Wikipedia's mailing list, invented "deletionism" from whole cloth, and someone else invented "inclusionism" as a joke to mock that. And then people who came along years later believed the pages on Meta to be authoritative without really researching what people actually did, or how those pages came about. The earliest version of the "inclusionism" page even pointed out that this was just name-calling. * https://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Inclusionism&oldid=16972 https://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Inclusionism&ol...