9 ms·
It's such a pity how politicised hydroxychloroquine has become. It's stupid to believe in miracle cures. But it's also stupid to discard out of hand things for
by nl 6y ago
It's such a pity how politicised hydroxychloroquine has become.
It's stupid to believe in miracle cures. But it's also stupid to discard out of hand things for which evidence is unclear just because your opponent is irrationally keen on it.
- chromedev 6y agoWhat makes you think that is the case? You're politicizing it right now.
- dx87 6y agoI was watching the Joe Rogan podcast, and one of his friends who had covid was asked by the doctor what his political leanings are, because some patients refuse to take HCQ because Trump said it was helpful.
- chromedev 6y agoJoe Rogan isn't the best example to base your political opinions. There are also serious safety issues: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-safety-and-availability/fda-cautions-against-use-hydroxychloroquine-or-chloroquine-covid-19-outside-hospital-setting-or https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-safety-and-availability/fda-c...
- giardini 6y agoFewer votes against Trump unless, like good Democrats, they mail in all their ballots before they die!8-))
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bena 6y agoYes, it would be stupid. But is that what's happening here? You have a ton of studies that says "no" and a few that say "maybe". But you want us to what? Keep studying until it finally says "yes"? "Check this out, it shows promise" "Ok." "Oh, it's not as effective as initially thought" "Ok, but this study says it might be" "Ok, but we just did a full study that says it's not" "Ok, but this study" And on and on. At what point do you say, "Ok, I guess we should move on". It was never discarded out of hand.
- esyir 6y agoIt was. Long before the bulk of the studies even processed, the media had flipped right over to "hcq is the devil and a hoax". This, from what I observed, was essentially independent of any actual scientific research or result.
- IvyMike 6y agoThe initial "hcq works" was also independent of any actual scientific research or result. If someone says "Take this magical cure, maybe it could work... but I don't have any evidence of it yet", it's not so terrible to start from a position of skepticism. Could hcq work? Maybe, although with every randomized trial it seems less likely. But the people who initially pushed it did so from a position of wishful thinking, not actual science. This might have been a hoax of ignorance not evil, but in the end, I say it's still a hoax.
- esyir 6y agoThe issue here isn't that one side was correct, or one side was wrong. The issue here is that both sides talking points were barely even touched the actual results. You're right, "hcq works" was independent of the scientific work done then. However, "HCQ doesn't work" was the same. The reason we had those studies in the first place is because preliminary work showed some promise, and researchers decided to dig in to confirm this. What many people don't know is that the biomedical scientific process is fraught with false starts and failures to replicate. The results are subsequently slow. At that time, the only responsible answer, and the answer that any biomedical scientist with integrity would give is: "Early results show X, though further follow up studies would be needed to replicate these results to confirm their validity" But that's not what we got. What we got was a binary split between miracle cure and worse than homeopathy, depending on which side of the political divide you were on.
- lucd 6y agoBoth-sidism: in evidence-based medecine, a treatment is ineffective until it is proven effective. Now that some monthes have passed, at least five peer-reviewed RCTs were conducted. In each of them hydroxychloroquine is ineffective.
- vernie 6y agoIn this case discard out of hand meant study far more than was necessary.
- arghwhat 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7leWXMr3ayk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7leWXMr3ayk
- refurb 6y agoIndeed. Look at the convalescent plasma news. Numerous article pumping it up, then Trump makes his announcement and suddenly it's questionable. All from the same MSM newspaper.[1] [1]https://twitter.com/SpoxHHS/status/1298001649798197248?s=20 https://twitter.com/SpoxHHS/status/1298001649798197248?s=20
- lucd 6y ago"scientists express doubts about coronavirus treatment touted as breakthough by Trump " What is the problem with this Washington Post headlines? Didn't scientists express doubts about this treatment? Didn't Trump didn't tout is as breakthrough? Also see.. FDA Walks Back Claim of Dramatic Benefit From Covid Therapy https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-08-24/fda-trump-officials-misrepresent-key-statistic-on-covid-therapy?sref=yYYRek8e https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-08-24/fda-trump...
- refurb 6y agoDid you look at the Tweet? 4 articles a few months back touting plasma as a promising therapy. All positive. Trump mentions it and suddenly it’s the worst idea in the world. I have zero problems with calling out Trump on his hyperbole. It's not helpful at all. But it would be nice if the MSM didn't bash things these previously praised just because Trump said something.
- aNoob7000 6y agohttps://arstechnica.com/science/2020/08/fda-commissioner-botched-risk-numbers-when-talking-about-post-covid-plasma/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/08/fda-commissioner-bot...
- hhw 6y agoDoubts about the efficacy of convalescent plasma already started popping up before Trump started advocating for it, with many papers being published in June and July.