3 ms·
It's sad that even a brilliant person like Bryan can get opensource so horribly wrong at a fundamental level. Right at the beginning, he says F/OSS established
by toyg 6y ago
It's sad that even a brilliant person like Bryan can get opensource so horribly wrong at a fundamental level. Right at the beginning, he says F/OSS established itself because it leapt ahead technologically, not because "all that freedom / user rights stuff"; he totally fails to see how that "user rights stuff" is what allowed the jump to happen - because even developers are users when they first encounter a piece of software. Without the rights of users to read source, tweak it to their liking, and republish it, there is no right for developers to enable the technological leap. I hope Bryan simply chose a poor turn of phrase.
He makes another poor turn when he says that the CDDL kept stuff out of Linux, but "not because of the CDDL but because of perceptions of the GPL" (i.e. IHVs didn't want to deal with the GPL). The license and the choice of using it are two different things. Sun could have written a license that was not GPL (to satisfy IHVs) but was compatible with GPL. They did not. Danese Cooper, who was part of that effort, says this was on purpose, and stated it on record ( http://caesar.ftp.acc.umu.se/pub/debian-meetings/2006/debconf6/theora-small/2006-05-14/tower/OpenSolaris_Java_and_Debian-Simon_Phipps__Alvaro_Lopez_Ortega.ogg http://caesar.ftp.acc.umu.se/pub/debian-meetings/2006/debcon... from 27:30). I guess Bryan was one of those engineers Danese mentions as "having some biases" back then. It was certainly obvious, at the time, what a careful avoidance of a license compatible with the biggest Solaris competitor would have resulted in, from a practical and commercial standpoint.
- nix23 6y ago>Sun could have written a license that was not GPL (to satisfy IHVs) but was compatible with GPL Why? Why even care about GPL? It's 100% compatible to MIT/BSD/ISC and that's enough, even Linus said that he probably would choose the ISC today, he chose mainly the GPL because GCC had it...and now they have GPLv3 (an absolute shit decision if you ask me).
- toyg 6y ago(ISC is a troublesome license, but that's beyond the point) Licenses are not adopted in a vacuum. The license is what made GCC what it was when Linus had to pick a license, and arguably what made Linux what it is today. A "BSD Linux" would have likely ended up the same way BSD systems have: a largely academic project routinely cannibalized by behemoth closed-source companies. The question, yesterday and today, is really "why not care about the GPL?". The rights it grants are what made the F/OSS ecosystem what it is today. If you want to grant more rights to your users and developers, by all means use a less restrictive but compatible license like modified BSD, or MPL 2. It's easier to do that without fear of withering, now that opensource is the de-facto default choice in a lot of fields. It definitely was not as easy back in the '90s or early '00s, which is when the GPL effectively fought the war for the whole field. If you choose to stick with pre-MPL2 derivatives, though, you are clearly not interested in granting users and developers the same basic rights as the GPL.
- nix23 6y agoLook the problem is, you CAN make Linux as proprietary as you want if you DON'T redistribute it, like google, so google cannibalizes Linux too. It's just a different vision, if you want real freedom and want to work with a community go with BSD/MIT. >ended up the same way BSD systems have: a largely academic project routinely cannibalized by behemoth closed-source companies. That's BS, just look at how Netflix and Dell EMC work with FreeBSD. And for example Juniper, they learned a lesson not working with the community and fell far behind because of that. https://www.freebsd.org/releases/12.0R/relnotes.html https://www.freebsd.org/releases/12.0R/relnotes.html
- toyg 6y agoI am not going to argue beliefs, MIT/BSD and GPL are compatible. My point on cannibalization was in the historical context. Today the situation is different (thanks largely to what the GPL did in the past). And of course Linux is GPL2, not 3 - which would address some of the issues you raise. All of these licenses would have avoided the problems we see with ZFS' adoption of CDDL or other MPL1 derivatives.
- trasz 6y agoThe historical context is that Linux had a proper community support at the time when everyone was looking for Unix on x86, to migrate off RISC workstations, and BSDs at the time were either a bunch of jerks, or had unclear status due to ATT vs UCB lawsuit. You could try to argue that licensing had played a role at this, but experience with other projects suggests otherwise.
- toyg 6y agoYou know what enabled that "proper community"? A license that provided a sort of moral compass, fostering collaboration and goodwill towards shared improvement, safe in the knowledge that efforts wouldn't be abused. Something that other licenses still fail to provide, to this day.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Danese Cooper, who was part of that effort, says this was on purpose, and stated it on record ( http://caesar.ftp.acc.umu.se/pub/debian-meetings/2006/debcon.. http://caesar.ftp.acc.umu.se/pub/debian-meetings/2006/debcon.... from 27:30). In the same talk, Simon Phipps disagrees with her assessment and later said he was furious at her spiteful comment. Now, almost fifteen years later, nobody else had corroborated her claim despite there being no reason to protect Sun anymore.
- toyg 6y ago> there being no reason to protect Sun anymore There is still a reason to protect themselves, of course, from a historical judgement that wouldn't appear particularly kind.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoI haven't seen people give any unkind judgment towards Danese Cooper for helping write the CDDL and stating it was done to block tools from Linux. And so many people already blame them for the incompatibility, it's hard to think a confirmation would make it worse for them.
- toyg 6y ago> I haven't seen people give any unkind judgment towards Danese Cooper for helping write the CDDL We haven't read the same flames, then...
- boomboomsubban 6y agoI've seen a ton of flak thrown at Sun for the license, but Cooper's name only seems to come up as a source that it was intentional. I've never gotten the impression people blame her. Of course I haven't read every discussion about it, but I have read quite a few. I think someone would have to both confirm that the incompatibility was intentional and argue it was the correct choice to to get much hate about it.
- znpy 6y agoI wouldn't know, mr Cantrill knows his stuff. It seems to me that Mr Cantrill is more aware of the business side, while you're more keen on the philosophical side. Yeah twiddling the source and everything, but if you didn't choose it in the first place that wouldn't happen.