3 ms·
I wish Hacker News would remove that rule and replace it with two: 1) Please read the article before you comment. 2) If you haven't read the article, please r
by krapp 6y ago
I wish Hacker News would remove that rule and replace it with two:
1) Please read the article before you comment.
2) If you haven't read the article, please refrain from commenting.
It wouldn't accomplish much, but it will at least prioritize engagement over politeness, as the current rule does. And yes, both of those are the same thing but I feel it's worth mentioning twice.
- mrfredward 6y agoI believe the reason for that rule is to avoid polluting the thread with "did you even read" type remarks. Starting an argument won't help the thread recover from an uninformed comment. Nothing in the rules discourages downvoting people who didn't read.