5 ms·
Could someone explain what was Apple trying to do? I really don't get their position in this story. It seemed obvious that trying to completely block Epic's Unr
by dgellow 6y ago
Could someone explain what was Apple trying to do? I really don't get their position in this story. It seemed obvious that trying to completely block Epic's Unreal Engine would be causing more legal issues. What is their strategy here? It feels that they actually wanted things to escalate, though I cannot see why they would do this.
- IvanK_net 6y agoEach app or game, which runs on iOS devices, should pay Apple 30% of their revenue. These are billions of dollars each year. The Fortnite game wanted to avoid this fee of 30% by making the game free to download, but the users could pay directly inside the game (the payment mechanism did not go through Apple). If more apps or games do that, Apple would lose a lot of money. Also, Apple App store is the only way to get apps and games into iOS devices. So if I make a game and I want you to play it, and you know me and my game and you want to play it too, Apple is a "third person", who can stop us from doing so.
- dgellow 6y agoYou're talking about the reason Apple had to remove Fortnite following Epic Game's decision to add their own payment option. That doesn't explain why they reacted so aggressively towards Epic's Unreal Engine by threatening to block it.
- summerlight 6y agoI'm pretty sure that Apple wanted to send an obvious signal to its developers. After Spotify, apparently Apple has decided not to like this kind of antitrust challenges from third party developers, which might be harder than those from users. The simplest option would be threatening developers with retaliation, something like "If you piss me off, I'll make your life miserable". I don't have a gut to fight against such thing, and I guess the same thing may apply to more than 99.9% of other developers as well. This also happened to their internal employees (lawsuit against Gerard Williams III), so I'm not very surprised.
- dkonofalski 6y agoThey did not threaten to block Unreal Engine. Read it again.
- cwhiz 6y agoApple threatened to revoke Epic’s “Apple Developer” account due to repeated violations of the developer policy and agreement. I am sure Apple did it to try and bully Epic into settling.
- electriclove 6y ago"Play by the rules or don't play"
- dkonofalski 6y agoOr, you know, they did it because that's exactly what it says will happen when someone violates the terms of Apple's developer agreement...
- kayodelycaon 6y agoBoth Apple and Google will pull people’s developer accounts for this kind of misbehavior. Epic isn’t special in this regard.
- Dahoon 6y agoExcept the developer Apple wanted to ban was Epic and their Unreal engine. That is an entirely different legal entity and developer than Fortnite the game developers on the app store. It also says so in the ruling. So what Apply did was punish X for what Y did. They might as well have banned Microsoft for siding with Epic.
- invalidusernam3 6y agoAs far as I understand, Apple has blocked Epic's developer account which prevents them from developing for iOS. They haven't directly blocked Unreal engine
- dgellow 6y agoThat's only half of the story. Apple threatened Epic to block the Unreal Engine completely, that's what the article discussed here is about.
- slipheen 6y agoI don't think that's correct. They were threatening to block Epic's developer account, which would make future engine releases difficult.
- dgellow 6y agoFrom a comment by onion2k in another thread: > This is a quote from the letter that Apple sent to Epic; >> If your membership is terminated, you may no longer submit apps to the App Store, and your apps still available for distribution will be removed. You will also lose access to the following programs, technologies, and capabilities:" >> [...] >> - Engineering efforts to improve hardware and software performance of Unreal Engine on Mac and iOS hardware; optimize Unreal Engine on the Mac for creative workflows, virtual sets and their CI/Build Systems; and adoption and support of ARKit features and future VR features into Unreal Engine by their XR team > That is a statement that Apple made saying they will stop all help they give to Epic getting UE running on all Apple hardware. With the other stuff in the letter it makes it very clear that the problem is not just one for Epic Games, but all of Epic. > You can read it yourself - https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327... https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327.... (Apple's letter starts on page 51 of the PDF) Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24269719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24269719 So they seem to be very specific and specifically call out work on the Unreal Engine.
- 6y ago
- bananaface 6y agoI think Apple thinks they're going to lose, so they tried to apply as much pressure as possible to get Epic to settle prematurely. I can't see why else they would have done it, it just strengthens Epic's case.
- parasubvert 6y agoI think you may be misunderstanding the fundamentals of the case. This was a moonshot by Epic, mostly about the court of public opinion than the actual law.
- bananaface 6y agoOh, don't be patronising. We'll see how the case pans out. I think Apple is in enough danger that aggravating the situation is a bad idea. https://twitter.com/EskilSteenberg/status/1297520275790139394 https://twitter.com/EskilSteenberg/status/129752027579013939...
- parasubvert 6y agoPer that analysis, there are massive differences vs the Microsoft case. - safari is a minority marketshare browser and already existed when iOS was created; Windows already had its marketshare dominance before the browser was invented - Portable music also pre-existed before iOS. iPhone and Android were laughing stocks in 2008. To say these points are anticompetitive would require proving they achieved their marketshare by parlaying their existing dominance into a new market, and it’s not clear that happened, especially given the thriving of alternatives like Chrome, Spotify, Tidal, etc. There is also a bunch of not-actually-anticompetitive points - charging developers for use of the platform - disallowing competitive tools - controlling platform access altogether All of the above would imply the game console makers like Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft have been anticompetitive for decades. It’s not likely. The crux to me is if there is a “right to a market“ for otherwise vertically integrated components. Just beside their was a market in he past for those things, doesn’t mean they need to be enshrined in laws. It would be akin to declaring game platforms or mobile platforms as public utilities so that ISVs in other adjacent platform markets can legally force the extension of their business model on other ecosystems. It’s been done with power generation/distribution, alcohol brewing/distribution/sales, and car manufacturing/sales/service. But those had massive unintended consequences. There is one area where there may be a clear legitimate issue: Abuse of private APIs. But it would have to be proven.
- LexGray 6y agoApple seems to have the position that if a company is going to start publishing apps with non allowed systems once that they will probably do it again with other apps. Epic has had the choice to conform to terms (they were not even losing money on in-app unlike the content streaming folks), even if that means removing all mention of in-app and have yet to do so. More or less Apple did the same thing to Facebook in the past for the profile abuse. Facebook just hadn’t prewarned their marketing team they were violating terms of service on purpose. Edit: not that Epic isn’t right to sue to see if they can get their way, just that they should have sued without violating current terms. My personal belief is that much of the 30% goes to gift card promotions and markup which brings in funds for all developers.
- Dahoon 6y ago>Epic has had the choice to conform The developer you are talking about didn't break the rules of the app store. Epic -the one with the development of Unreal Engine- is an entirely different legal entity than the one that broke Apple's rules - the forthnite developer. X broke a rule, Apple got pissy and punished both X and Y because both have the same owners. As the judge also acknowledged in the ruling.
- jayd16 6y agoI think Apple was outplayed here, at least for now. Apple uses a single developer account system for both iOS and MacOS. Revoking violating dev accounts is somewhat understandable but because Epic is a large tool vendor on MacOS as well, disabling that account has massive downstream consequences. Due to the particular implementation I don't think its possible for Apple to revoke only the iOS assets. By being forced to reinstate the entire account under anticompetitive scrutiny, its a PR loss for Apple. If Epic had separate dev accounts for its MacOS and iOS presence it would have played out differently.
- saurik 6y agoEpic actually does have separate accounts; in fact, they not only had separate accounts, but they have entirely separate corporate entities! Apple decided to cancel every account they could find that was even remotely associated with Epic, which the judge thought might be retaliatory and might be "piercing the corporate veil". Apple argues that Epic is essentially trying to use the moral equivalent of sock puppets to let them avoid consequences.