5 ms·
Chernobyl is like terrorism - pretty much everything is more damaging if a risk adjusted data-driven comparison is done. It is hard to describe a major disaste
by roenxi 6y ago
Chernobyl is like terrorism - pretty much everything is more damaging if a risk adjusted data-driven comparison is done.
It is hard to describe a major disaster that is less damaging then Chernobyl. There are train wrecks that are comparable to Chernobyl by deaths [0]. On that note; wow, what a horrific rain wreck that must have been.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_disasters_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_disaster...
- mhh__ 6y agoAnd if you take the value of land into account? Chernobyl displaced a lot of people and cost a lot of money In direct deaths, Chernobyl didn't cause that many but I have seen estimates of the cancer toll that are a lot higher than most accidents
- roenxi 6y agoI'd rather have 50,000 displaced than 5,000 dead. Being dead is pretty bad vs displaced. I move around a lot; although I can see the argument it is bad it is not a fate worse than death. If Oroville Dam had given way back in 2017 that could easily have been America's Chernobyl. It made for exciting news.
- xg15 6y ago> I move around a lot Others don't. Also, did you into account all the indirect effects of radiation?
- wukerplank 6y agoI found your comment quite cynical and hand wavy. The nuclear fallout affected a huge area and still impacted parts of central Europe. This goes hand in hand with increased cancer rates. Yes, better than dying immediately, but still not a fate you would wish upon anybody.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoMost of those estimates haven't held up, after this many years those deaths should be noticeable. The only cancer they can observe Chernobyl having an effect is thyroid cancer, which kills very few people.
- agumonkey 6y agoWhat about child birth defects ?
- Ygg2 6y agoWhat childbirth defects?
- acidburnNSA 6y agoI don't think the UN team was able to attribute any child birth defects to increased radiation. The horror books with pictures of them are shock collections of deformed children. It's possible that the rampant alcoholism of the latter Soviet era was the likely cause.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAlcoholism causes birth defects? How?
- minkzilla 6y agoA simple google search will bring up hundreds of articles linking alcohol consumption during pregnancy to birth defects. It is a well established relationship. In the US we even have warnings on all alcoholic beverages that say pregnant women should not drink alcohol.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI looked at the CDC's page (https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/fasd/alcohol-use.html https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/fasd/alcohol-use.html). It contains a number of very negative effects from drinking alcohol while pregnant. But because the context was birth defects caused by radiation, I was thinking more in terms of visible deformities - which can be caused by radiation, but which are much less significant from alcohol. Perhaps I was being too limited in my concept of "birth defects" - including for radiation. If the radiation while pregnant (or before) gives the child cancer at five, is that a "birth defect"? Maybe not, in the way I was thinking, but I can see how it might be thought of that way.
- pvaldes 6y agoThis is like saying than Kalashnikovs clubbing people to death are rare events, so they are very safe. Having cancer death after ten years, because radiation was released, is a direct death. Direct origin, direct cause, Wouldn't be happening without the event. This child would had born normal. This woman would not die in an hospital at 52 years old. We have registered increases in thyroid cankers, we have plenty of healthcare centers data showing that something abnormal is still happening with this population. Is embarrassing to see nuclear related people claiming after all this years that, if you can't trace it, is not their problem, specially when half of Europe was about to be seriously poisoned forever.
- walkingolof 6y agoNaive way of looking at it, Chernobyl caused huge changes to the way of life for many people, not only in the vicinity, I live in Sweden and I remember that day when it rained and how we decades afterwards sent meat, berries and other food stuff for testing ....
- arethuza 6y agoI still remember standing under an arch in the Grassmarket Edinburgh on my way back from University classes on the day that the Chernobyl cloud passed over the UK and looking at the heavy rain and wondering whether it was a wise thing to walk home in it. Edit: Of course I knew there was a tiny tiny risk - but still something I remember thinking about.
- roenxi 6y ago> ...decades afterwards sent meat, berries and other food stuff for testing .... What did they find? How bad was the impact?
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>What did they find? They found that keeping testing going this century serves the valuable function of keeping the public at ease and the cost isn't that high (testing is pretty small scale now) so why not keep it. The primary source of radiation was airborne dust (and therefore precipitation as well). Crops and farm raised animals have been clean for a long time. The primary risk is shooting a buck that ate a berry that had something nasty on it back in 1995 but between the half lives of the radioactive compounds in question and the pattern of events required to get those components to one's dinner plate the risk is beyond minimal at this point.
- walkingolof 6y agoThere has been about a 1000 deaths attributed to it in Sweden. And you could argue that its "low", but its in the very sense "Russian roulette", you never know if it is you, maybe you where unlucky and ate a side of that wild boar that contained 39706 becquerel per kilo...
- wittyreference 6y agoThat is assuming you trust Soviet stats on Chernobyl deaths. I’m acquainted with one of Russia’s chief oncologists, who was one of the primary physicians that dealt with the consequences of Chernobyl. She’s been quite clear that the number of people affected is both large and well-suppressed. Of course, the very nature of “the state makes sure not to collect damaging statistics” means I can’t actually quantify the real harm done. For all I know, maybe it’s just equal to ‘two’ bad train wrecks.
- arethuza 6y agoUnder Stalin, statisticians who collected the "wrong" values were likely to come to a very nasty end - I imagine something like that leaves a lingering fear in any society/profession: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Census_(1937) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Census_(1937)
- teye 6y agoHow is viewing Chernobyl from that angle useful in this context? The Houston Ship Channel has the potential to become an environmental disaster similar to Chernobyl, but affecting the fourth-largest population and economic center in the US. It's not hyperbole -- if you drive down 225 and 146 from Houston to Galveston, it feels like you're in the Sonic the Hedgehog Chemical Plant Zone... it just goes on and on at an unbelievable scale. It self-perpetuates partially because expanding existing petrochemical complexes seems to meet less opposition than building new ones. https://www.google.com/search?q=houston+ship+channel+plants&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=houston+ship+channel+plants&... https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7348066,-95.1345542,13223m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7348066,-95.1345542,13223m/d...
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoChernobyl is a lesson not because what it was, but what it could have been. Only miracle (Legasov ans Sherbina being honest and persistent people) saved the damn thing from polluting whole Europe. Train wreck is a train wreck, it is limited in terms of destruction it can produce.
- mad182 6y agoNot really. In hindsight, many of the efforts like digging under the reactor and dropping lead from air were of questionable usefulness at best. In their defense, they acted according to the information and resources they had, but all in all the mitigation efforts gave unnecessary radiation exposure to many people and many of them were completely useless. If the reactor were left alone for a while, it wouldn't have changed much.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoYes exactly. The next accident might be different. You will never know if it will have contaminated the ground water or not, what are the necessary steps to prevent spread of the radiation. So yeah, it is not what it was, but what it might have been.
- andruby 6y agoHold on. The number of deaths due to Chernobyl is grossly underreported. And deaths don't cover the full "cost" of Chernobyl. Displacing thousands of people lead to poverty, depression and suicide. The economic and social damage was huge. The Soviet Union doesn't have statistics on this because they didn't want those numbers to exist. I'd be willing to argue that the Chernobyl accident caused (or at least precipitated) the fall of the Soviet union. This case was also made by the Netflix "Chernobyl" series. If you look at it from that perspective: No, I don't think that a hurricane hitting Houston would be as damaging as Chernobyl and cause the United States to collapse.
- simias 6y ago>I'd be willing to argue that the Chernobyl accident caused (or at least precipitated) the fall of the Soviet union. This case was also made by the Netflix "Chernobyl" series. You're not helping your argument when you make it sound like a bold new theory and use (good) TV fiction to bolster it up. I propose a quote from a certain Mikhail Gorbachev instead: > He states flatly that the Chernobyl explosion was “perhaps the real cause of the collapse of the Soviet Union.” According to Gorbachev, the Chernobyl explosion was a “turning point” that “opened the possibility of much greater freedom of expression, to the point that the system as we knew it could no longer continue.” https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/chernobyl-and-the-fall-of-the-soviet-union-gorbachevs-glasnost-allowed-the-nuclear-catastrophe-to-undermine-the-ussr.html https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/chernobyl-and-the-fall-... But note that here it's more about how Chernobyl exposed deep dysfunctions within the Soviet system and how it might have contributed to precipitate its collapse. I don't really know if that counts as "damage".
- sukilot 6y ago"Here's more evidence to support your idea" is perhaps the pettiest possible retort. Is agreeing with someone so hard?
- dandellion 6y agoHis comment is actually a very good reply to the grandparent, which was making a poor job of supporting the argument. Also, your accusation of his comment being petty is pretty ironic.
- phant0mas 6y agoMy mother was a child in Poland during the Chernobyl disaster. In her family nobody has a history of cancer but she had breast cancer. And a lot of other health issues. Coincidence? Maybe.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoI'm sorry for your family's health problems. I'm also sorry if this comes off a bit crass considering, but this mysterious thought process of radiation is exactly why we need to focus harder on epidemiological studies of radiation effects. By your exact same argument it could easily have been the successful reactor safety test in Idaho that happened 2 weeks before Chernobyl that caused your mother's health issues. It's far to easy for any of us to magically attribute something with another without looking at the big picture. The scientific method offers us a way to tease out which hunches like this are real and which are fantasy. Fact is, we use epidemiology to understand these things, and the jury is in [1]. [1] https://www.unscear.org/unscear/en/chernobyl.html https://www.unscear.org/unscear/en/chernobyl.html Anecdotally, my college girlfriend was a child in Gomel Belarus during Chernobyl. Her father had a Geiger counter and took readings around here. There was lots of elevated dose rates. She is perfectly healthy to this day though!