28 ms·

> Honestly comment sections on the internet are a cesspool A bit offtopic, but when YouTube first added comments, they quickly got into cesspool territory, exa

> Honestly comment sections on the internet are a cesspool A bit offtopic, but when YouTube first added comments, they quickly got into cesspool territory, exactly like you describe. However, these days, I find myself really enjoying YouTube comments quite often. Is this just me? Am I just watching more happy happy joy joy videos these days or did YT comments go from "the internet's awfulest" to "pretty neat" somehow? I feel like it's chock full of witty jokes, positive vibes, light entertainment, and the occasional weirdo just to balance things out.

thinkloop 6y ago
It might have to do with there being real identities linked to them now from Google+, which many say was the main purpose of the project; not to mention the improved recommendation engine and upvotes, etc.
- webmaven 6y ago
  > It might have to do with there being real identities linked to them now from Google+, which many say was the main purpose of the project; not to mention the improved recommendation engine and upvotes, etc. But the migration of YouTube channels and comments to G+ linked identities was reversed[0], wasn't it? Not to mention that G+ has since been shut down. Shouldn't that make the abortive effort irrelevant for the quality of YouTube comments today? [0] https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/07/everything-in-its-right-place.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/07/everything-in-its-ri...
- freeflight 6y ago
  Looking at Facebook I would be willing to say that has literally nothing to do with it. Facebook insists even more on having "real people" using their real names, often forcing them to vet themselves, yet at times it easily steals the crown in terms of "really bad user interactions" from YouTube comments. Very likely much more related to the topic under which people are commenting: Non-political feel good fluff does not allow for much friction to be inserted, thus the tone of comments will be much more civilized and friendly. But anything that goes into controversial, and particularly political, territory is bound to quickly escalate into a complete shit show, on YouTube and Facebook alike. Which fits neatly into common communication strategies like focusing on similarities rather than on differences.
52-6F-62 6y ago
I’ve noticed this in the comments under music more than elsewhere. Anything politics is still awful. Music is nice and largely even positive—if repetitive (“anyone here listening to [90s band] in 2020??”)
strogonoff 6y ago
Don’t forget countless horrific things content moderators have to read and see so that you can enjoy your experience.
- skrebbel 6y ago
  We couldn't do without the epsilons.
TT3351 6y ago
I think Google works really hard to surface comments that they know a user will interact with.
- skrebbel 6y ago
  That would work best if they'd surface all the vitriol, right? People love to interact with vitriol.

thinkloop 6y ago

It might have to do with there being real identities linked to them now from Google+, which many say was the main purpose of the project; not to mention the improved recommendation engine and upvotes, etc.

webmaven 6y ago
> It might have to do with there being real identities linked to them now from Google+, which many say was the main purpose of the project; not to mention the improved recommendation engine and upvotes, etc. But the migration of YouTube channels and comments to G+ linked identities was reversed[0], wasn't it? Not to mention that G+ has since been shut down. Shouldn't that make the abortive effort irrelevant for the quality of YouTube comments today? [0] https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/07/everything-in-its-right-place.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/07/everything-in-its-ri...
freeflight 6y ago
Looking at Facebook I would be willing to say that has literally nothing to do with it. Facebook insists even more on having "real people" using their real names, often forcing them to vet themselves, yet at times it easily steals the crown in terms of "really bad user interactions" from YouTube comments. Very likely much more related to the topic under which people are commenting: Non-political feel good fluff does not allow for much friction to be inserted, thus the tone of comments will be much more civilized and friendly. But anything that goes into controversial, and particularly political, territory is bound to quickly escalate into a complete shit show, on YouTube and Facebook alike. Which fits neatly into common communication strategies like focusing on similarities rather than on differences.

52-6F-62 6y ago

I’ve noticed this in the comments under music more than elsewhere. Anything politics is still awful. Music is nice and largely even positive—if repetitive (“anyone here listening to [90s band] in 2020??”)

strogonoff 6y ago

Don’t forget countless horrific things content moderators have to read and see so that you can enjoy your experience.

skrebbel 6y ago
We couldn't do without the epsilons.

TT3351 6y ago

I think Google works really hard to surface comments that they know a user will interact with.

skrebbel 6y ago
That would work best if they'd surface all the vitriol, right? People love to interact with vitriol.