5 ms·
>If we provide the ability for people to select partners with some precision about what genes they carry and what might be passed to their offspring, this is w
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
>If we provide the ability for people to select partners with some precision about what genes they carry and what might be passed to their offspring,
this is what's potentially wrong with eugenics, in the abstract there is nothing wrong with being able to choose genetic traits, but it will be left to the prejudices and ill-informed opinions of people not to mention fashion. Many traits that do not have anything to do with smarter, healthier and stronger humans would be selected for or selected against skewing the population unnaturally.
Would this have any deleterious effect - not sure. After all if it doesn't directly effect having smarter, healthier, or stronger humans what is the harm in - let's have an example - having red hair and freckles suddenly cut from the gene pool by 3/4ths? Probably no harm, maybe the redheads out there will be upset that there is sort of genetic vote to eliminate them, but they'll get over it or just get old and die so what's the harm?
on edit: to clarify - verged into sarcasm with my ending example as obviously I do think it would be harmful, although I can't really show with any certainty that I am correct, and just as obviously don't know that my scenario would happen - if it did I expect it would not be because most people chose against having redheaded children but rather for having other types of characteristics.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoEugenics is tricky. It is a complex field with legitimate and valuable data that can be used to help people, but can also be used for harm. Nobody would wish cystic fibrosis, huntington's disease, or downs syndrome on their children, but that doesn't mean carriers don't deserve respect and dignity. The tricky part is how to promote healthier, happier, and smarter children without denigrating others.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The tricky part is how to promote healthier, happier, and smarter children without denigrating others. That's not tricky. It can't be done. If you want to admit that smarter children are desirable, you have to also admit that dumber children are undesirable. You can hope nobody notices, but they will notice.
- Alkhwarizmi 6y agoThat’s another fallacy...If one likes apples, it doesn’t automatically imply they hate oranges.
- xwdv 6y agoThe generations of the future should not have to suffer just because some people's feelings might be hurt.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI don't know a person that doesn't want smart children more than dumb children. Is this taboo?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoWell, there's all this is intelligence equivalent to doing well on IQ tests and different kinds of intelligence debate going on in the culture for the last decade or two, and then there does seem to be a history in the U.S at least of undervaluing some sorts of intelligence in some regions and so on and so forth so I'm thinking - yeah, there kind of are a lot of taboos around this subject! Ask yourself this - is there anyone you have ever met that would be willing to let their kids be a little bit dumber if that meant they would have the genes to be a little bit better at being a quarterback? Because I have met a lot of those people.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThere is a question of how Intelligence is measured and what the tests optimize, but certainly no prospective parent would want dumber children when speaking of intelligence in general. The parent post seemed hold that even this position is amoral. You raise a good point of potential tradeoffs, and intelligence is not the only factor to optimize for. I imagine most parents would optimize for health and happiness above it. That said, it is unclear to what degree tradeoffs are required. For example, smart quarterbacks certainly exist. To me, this is an argument for further research into the genetic basis of health, happiness, and intelligence. I find it interesting that the subject sparks such visceral reactions in people, and how these reactions differ across countries and cultures. I think the subject of Steve HSU is a great an example of this which will be interesting to watch play out.[1] US critics were very quick to assume his research had racial motivations, while in China the subject research receives a $1.5B grant. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2013/05/29/wake-controversy-over-harvard-dissertation-race-and-iq-scrutiny-michigan-state https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2013/05/29/wake-controve...
- JamesBarney 6y agoI'm pale. I think it's neat that paleness exist in the world. Would I run of the risk of people not liking some phenotypic trait that I identify with like paleness and choose to remove it, in order to greatly reduce the amount of anxiety, depression, cancer, heart disease, obesity, diabetes, schizophrenia, parkinsons, and alzheimers in the world? You betcha.