35 ms·
> It surprises me that 5 of 200 that do so well actually enlist. Can't be that surprising that intelligent people value the experience of being in the military
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> It surprises me that 5 of 200 that do so well actually enlist.
Can't be that surprising that intelligent people value the experience of being in the military?
- tyingq 6y agoIn the military as bottom of the rung enlisted people, yes. I feel okay saying that, since I was there, and I was one. I had, er, blown some earlier opportunities. It's not an easy life for the first couple of years, and the pay is terrible at first.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> In the military as bottom of the rung enlisted people, yes. Some people just want to get stuck into the work and tactics rather than all the fuss of being an officer! Being a private soldier in many units can be an extremely challenging and rewarding experience. Yes the pay isn't great for people with other opportunities, but money isn't everything in life. I know many people who could easily commission but want to stay operators because that's what they enjoy.
- tyingq 6y agoI mean bottom of the rung, E1. You can do 2 years of community college and enter a couple of ranks higher.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut again, some people want to be doing not leading! And not everyone wants or is suited to go to college!
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I mean bottom of the rung, E1. You can do 2 years of community college and enter a couple of ranks higher. But...you can't. At least, not that would show up at Basic. The higher grade you get for sufficient vo/tech or collegiate study prior to enlistment is applied after graduating from Basic. AFAIK,that's true even for the programs where you enlist with guaranteed OCS after Basic, you still are an E-1 when you go to Basic though you are administratively promoted to E-5 at OCS.
- bumby 6y agoSure you can if what is meant by “a couple ranks higher” means a couple enlisted ranks. This can occur before leaving for basic. You can be guaranteed E3 out of boot camp with enlistment incentives and each platoon generally has at least one merit promotion E3 (aka ‘honor grad’)
- dragonwriter 6y agoRight, and all the programs I referred to are also guaranteed promotion after Basic as well. But you'll still be an E-1 in Basic and so if you are looking at some outstanding scores on something posted for E-1s in Basic, well, it's possible those E-1s are people who enlisted with a guarantee of higher grade on successful completion of Basic, not starting at the bottom except insofar as everyone enlisting starts at the bottom in Basic.
- bumby 6y agoIt's potentially different for each branch, but the Navy advertises higher rank prior to completion of basic: "The Navy provides opportunities for you to advance to pay-grades E-2 or E-3 while you wait to leave for boot camp."[1] My limited understanding is you are paid the higher rank salary while in training but cannot wear the rank until graduation. [1]https://www.navycs.com/navy-advanced-paygrade.html https://www.navycs.com/navy-advanced-paygrade.html
- StillBored 6y agoTIL: Apparently the navy considers scouting to be roughly equivalent to an AA. "Scouting Provide evidence of successful completion of Eagle Scout or the Girl Scout Gold Award requirements and you are entitled to be enlisted in pay-grade E-3."
- bumby 6y agoIf rank was the only factor, that’s a bad choice considering you can fairly easily make that same rank in less time by simply enlisting.
- sukilot 6y agoCommunity college is a lot more pleasant than military sevice.
- bumby 6y agoSure, but the statement seemed to allude that the incentive was gaining rank, not taking the easiest route. >You can do 2 years of community college and enter a couple of ranks higher. Point being, if your goal is to maximize rank the fastest, it doesn't make sense to go to community college for two years. If two people consider enlisting at the same time but one defers to community college, that deferment will likely mean they are lower rank/seniority than the person who joined without any additional school.[1] Both will still have the same enlistment term, but the non-deferring person would be considered senior because they also have more time in service and time in grade. If the intent is to go to school to qualify for a commission, that's a different matter. [1] e.g., Person1 joins immediately, Person2 joins two years after community college. Person1 is at least an E3 in most cases and likely and E4 (rare cases E5) plus two years time in service and more time in grade when Person2 joins. Person2 comes in at an E3 with zero days time in service/time in grade. (Time in service/grade are applicable to gaining the next rank on a scoring system). Meaning Person1 is more competitive for the next rank, with all other things equal
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoThe most 'pleasant' option is sitting at home and doing nothing. Most people aren't optimising for 'pleasant'.