4 ms·
If the F22 turns around and aborts mission that's mission accomplished for the drone operator. The question is how many drones you need to deny figher aircraft
by wongarsu 6y ago
If the F22 turns around and aborts mission that's mission accomplished for the drone operator. The question is how many drones you need to deny figher aircraft from any given area, and how that cost compares to operating your own airforce
- baybal2 6y agoIt is 1 if you just need to destroy its airfield. Airwar is not about who shoots more planes, it's about who will blow up enemy's airbases first.
- jessaustin 6y agoIf planes are conceptually vulnerable to a fog of drones, then so are missiles. Anyway the fog drones are unlikely to require full-fledged airfields.
- dmix 6y agoLaser systems will handle that eventually. Bases will be hardened. Animated example of a convoy getting hit by lasers: https://youtu.be/-miBH10bdCs https://youtu.be/-miBH10bdCs Live example: https://youtu.be/XH6NIazR5pA https://youtu.be/XH6NIazR5pA
- hcurtiss 6y agoIt sure seems like those would take a boatload of energy. I wonder how that's stored.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoIndeed. Right now laser systems are feasible as weapons on ships... who have their own gigantic diesel engines (and/or nuclear reactors). Energy dissipation of a laser in atmo is going to require crazy amounts of energy to go even a moderate distance, so either those lasers are being fired from something really close to the airfield, or else you've got some S.H.I.E.L.D style flying aircraft carrier thing.
- a012 6y agoIt's like from the Red Alert game https://i.imgur.com/UJZOfPc.jpg https://i.imgur.com/UJZOfPc.jpg
- IgorPartola 6y agoHow do these handle chaff, fog, rain? I know drones don’t handle those too well either but I can’t imagine guided missiles care all that much, while I can see heavy rain severely limiting the effectiveness of that laser.
- SpelingBeeChamp 6y agoDon't current laser systems require a pre-marked target and a stationary laser to be effective?
- onepointsixC 6y agoF-35B's are capable of taking off in less than 150 m. Good luck trying to destroy every single airport and highway.
- baybal2 6y agoAn airvase, vs a road based, ad-hoc field, without even minimal infrastructure, and probably no defences too. A weapon without munitions, is a useless weapon, even if it costs $300M a pop. A war is won by a soldier, and lost by a logistics officer. The maximum what a few fit men can load very slowly, unassisted is 250kg, and usually only 100kg by a single man. Gravity fed refueling is also quite time consuming.
- greedo 6y agoSo how are you going to get "hundreds" of drones up to 50K feet where the F-22 operates? And then when he flies around this swarm at Mach 2, your drones are left in the dust?
- nostrademons 6y agoOne option: just let the F-22 fly around at Mach 2 at 50K feet. Meanwhile your drones are strafing, bombing, and otherwise destroying everything on the ground within their area of control. Why do we have air-superiority fighters? It's to shoot down any aircraft that might be harassing our ground units, and to ensure that our own CAS/attack aircraft can freely harass their ground units without opposition. An F-22 with an air-superiority loadout is pretty much useless in the ground war. So just let it fly around, and if it shoots down 8 drones with its 8 missiles, big deal. There's hundreds more where those came from. Meanwhile any aircraft that are actively strafing, cluster-bombing, etc. the ground forces have to fly straight through the drone swarm, with likely pretty cataclysmic results.
- greedo 6y agoThe primary air support plane during the conflict in Afghanistan was the B-1B. This could easily operate above any drone swarm and just lob JDAMS. Strafing is not really that common a mission due to the risk already faced by A2A and SAMs.
- nostrademons 6y agoThe risk goes away if you don't care if you lose the drone. Shoot down a manned CAS aircraft and you lose a $20M aircraft plus two priceless pilots. Shoot down a drone and you lose a $1000 drone. Now which of these mission profiles can destroy an infantry company more cost-effectively? The JDAM may blow up a vehicle plus any infantrymen around it at the cost of $20K. The drone can individually target each infantryman with a bullet from a range of ~50-100 ft, for perhaps 100 kills for a $1000 drone, and it can be tactically controlled by other infantrymen on the ground, with instantaneous communication, to respond exactly where it's needed and avoid friendly fire.