3 ms·
A lot of this has always confused me. In times of peace you should invest more in civilian research. In times of war or near war, more military. They complement
by godelski 6y ago
A lot of this has always confused me. In times of peace you should invest more in civilian research. In times of war or near war, more military. They complement one another too. Civilian research will always be used by military, from basic understanding of how people act, to lasers, to economic theory. One helps the other. The reverse direction is slower though because it is often held close to the vest for a bit of time.
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoGovernment science investment frequently comes from fear. ARPA was the US government's big "give money to research" program. It was started in response to Sputnik because we feared we were falling behind the Soviets. Then in 1969-73, Senate majority leader Mansfield decided that this research might be being misused to fund science in ways that wasn't directly useful to fighting Soviets, so ARPA became DARPA (the D is for Defense!) and now researchers needed to explain why their science might help build missiles.
- 75675446875444 6y agoPeace time is the best time to invest in military research because you'll be more prepared to secure an advantageous position when a conflict emerges. If you only invest during an in-progress conflict then what you're really doing is playing catch up.
- godelski 6y agoRead past my first few sentences. I'm arguing that civilian research IS military research. I'm also not arguing 100% in one vs 100% in another, such a scheme would be absurdly idiotic.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "I'm arguing that civilian research IS military research." Which is prima facie untrue. While there are benefits to basic research over the long term, it took roughly 60 years from the discovery of the laser to the beginnings of deployable laser weaponry today. Those sorts of timeframes aren't that useful for a military expecting a conflict in the next few years.
- godelski 6y ago> Which is prima facie untrue. Only if you have little knowledge of military. > it took roughly 60 years from the discovery of the laser to the beginnings of deployable laser weaponry today. But it took less than a year for it to be used by the CIA and FBI for spying (an interferometer was one of the first applications) and not much longer for it to be used for range finding and targeting for the military and not much longer than that to be used to determine mass of objects. The directed energy weapon you are referring to isn't the only application that the military, CIA, FBI, and other agencies have for lasers. There are hundreds more than what I mentioned and a dozen of which were in practical use within the first 5 years of its discovery. Just because you aren't aware of the uses of such technology doesn't mean that they aren't used and doesn't mean they aren't __HIGHLY__ valuable assets. We could go on and include things like nightvision, underwater communications (other types of communications as well), guidance, or defensive applications but I think it is pretty clear that the laser is one of the _best_ examples of technology being used (and quickly adopted) by military/government, not worst.
- Voliokis 6y agoIf war breaks out, it's too late. Especially nowadays, where technology is crazy complex and it takes absurd amounts of time, effort and coordination to get something like a new fighter plane all the way from the drawing board into production. And then trying to iron out all the bugs while fighting a shooting war? That might have worked out back in WW1 or 2, but modern wars would be over in a flash (comparatively). Either you have the technology and you win, or you don't and you lose. Our modern capabilities of blowing each other into oblivion are too effective to only start research when war breaks out (or is "near" to breaking out). That said, DARPA has always been one of the biggest funders of research in the US, whether it's basic research or applied. Just think of the DARPA Grand Challenge (self-driving cars in an off-road setting). While, yes, ultimately their goal is military application, this cultivation of research into self-driving cars is something that will benefit everybody, not just the military.
- godelski 6y agoI think you're misunderstanding me. You seem to imply it is 100% of funding into one vs 100% into another. I'd argue such a swing is absurd. The other part is that I'm arguing that civilian research is also military research (the reverse is also true, but not as strong of a connection). The reason to invest in civilian research while in times of peace is that you want products to go into the public domain and be mass produced. This means that the new fighters you can make are much cheaper to produce and can have much more advanced weapon capabilities. The only real difference between civilian and military research is if the knowledge gets into the public domain or not (with the exception for weapons, which is more niche than you'd expect). This is why DARPA does that funding, but it isn't just DARPA. The entire SBIR/STTR program exists to get companies to bootstrap themselves and mass produce things the government needs (yes, it is abused quite a bit). Many contracts exist for this reason too. The last aspect is economic and cultural. If your country is doing well economically it is often able to avoid war in the first place. Rich countries often don't fight with soldiers and jets, they fight with computers and resources. Why invade a country when you can put economic shackles on it? China and the US are both doing this. The other part is cultural exportation. If your country is producing all the widgets that another country likes and enjoys then their people are not eager to fight you (as long as you're not being aggressive towards them). All these, and more matter. War is much more than bullets and fighter jets.
- qppo 6y ago> Civilian research will always be used by military It goes both ways, and military applications create market pressures and timescales that wouldn't normally exist. Take for example, sustained fission, computing, or the semiconductor industry as a whole (which was subsidized by the government in its early years for aerospace applications, some civilian and some not). But that said it's more about industrial capacity than research. We build planes and tanks not because we need them today, but because we might need the ability to build them tomorrow. Continued research on military applications prevents institutional knowledge from dying and tools from rotting.
- godelski 6y ago> It goes both ways, >> They complement one another too. >> One helps the other. The reverse direction is slower though because it is often held close to the vest for a bit of time. Glad we agree > We build planes and tanks not because we need them today, but because we might need the ability to build them tomorrow. I also agree. I'm not sure why people think I am saying to not build tanks and planes during peace time. I just think we should be funding civilian science more and that the military benefits from such research. I haven't really disagreed with all these people "disagreeing" with me.