3 ms·
First of all, I can buy Xbox games in many stores - GameStop, MediaMarkt, etc. etc. iOS devices (especially iPads) are marketed as general purpose computers an
by izacus 6y ago
First of all, I can buy Xbox games in many stores - GameStop, MediaMarkt, etc. etc.
iOS devices (especially iPads) are marketed as general purpose computers and as such should be compared with Windows and Linux where software authors can:
- Distribute their app without approval of the platform owner.
- Can freely communicate about pricing and availability of their software.
Apple forbids even talking about lower prices or other platforms, essentially forcing us developers to mislead and misinform customers of their platforms. It's deeply against the principles of a free market competition.
- robertlagrant 6y agoSigh. Various comments already pointing out console vendors also take a cut from physical game sales. I don't know where the "especially iPads" comes from - they are the only ones that could come even close to not being called a watch or a phone. What else apart from iPads are you talking about?
- chongli 6y agoThey only take a cut from original sales, not the used game market. You can't resell your iOS apps because they're tied to your account.
- basch 6y agoHow many unsigned, unlicensed, un-xbox branded printed discs end up at game markets? I'm not sure ive ever seen an "xbox-compatible" disc at a store. Microsoft is still largely controlling distribution.
- Jtsummers 6y agoYou can't resell them because you're purchasing a digitally licensed product. You have the same issue with most digital content. You can't resell your Amazon Kindle, Amazon Music, or Amazon Video purchases. You can't resell anything bought from Steam. You can't resell anything bought in the Windows app store. You can't resell anything bought through Google Play. You can't resell digitally purchased Switch games. You can't resell anything bought through, I'd wager, the majority of current digital market places. Nothing about this situation is unique to Apple.
- chongli 6y agoThe comment I replied to was talking about physical Xbox games, which you can buy and sell to your heart's content. The fact that all of those other digital stores don't allow reselling is irrelevant.
- threeseed 6y agoIf you walk into a retail store to buy a game do you see a flyer on the game advertising to buy it cheaper at a different store ? Do you actually think they would tolerate this sort of behaviour ? Because they absolutely do not.
- izacus 6y agoIf the game itself advertises a cheap DLC available on some other store, it will continue to be sold in brick and mortar store for sure. This censorship of in-software messaging is something Apple has normalized and is new at this scale.
- threeseed 6y agoYou are moving the goalposts. For most apps e.g. Netflix we are talking about the core revenue stream not some cheap DLC. In which case no distribution channel today, Apple or otherwise, allows you to use your product to advertise to buy the product cheaper elsewhere. And using the term censorship is ridiculous. It's simply the rules of using the channel. And every channel has their own unique rules.