3 ms·

Obviously the police deal with crime and disorder every day, this would attract people who are more on the right of the political spectrum. This is exacerbated

Obviously the police deal with crime and disorder every day, this would attract people who are more on the right of the political spectrum. This is exacerbated by deep-seated structural factors in the US, policing by consent is unknown, there is high income inequality and segregation, the level of training is pitiful, it's no surprise that Amber Guyger's instagram feed looked the way it did. Of course those types would use any tool they are handed to have fun at the people's expense. The system selects for them.

teddyh 6y ago
This is still just othering police, and thereby avoiding solving any problem. I.e. if the problem is caused by some inherent factor in the people who choose to become police officers, then we can simply blame them and move on; easy hate clicks galore! But I think police are molded by their experiences, and made by various vicious cycles to become the stereotypical bad police. I described one such cycle above; here is another: http://tailsteak.com/archive.php?num=545 http://tailsteak.com/archive.php?num=545 If this is correct, then anybody, even the most well-meaning angelic people, would, over time, become bad police, but anyone could still merely claim that all police are bad because they are “right-wing” (as if that automatically is a bad thing) or racist, and nothing could ever be solved.
- HarryHirsch 6y ago
  Police are also moulded by politics, they answer to someone, which usually isn't the locals. Consider Louisville, KY, where there have been demonstrations for 3 months now against the Breonna Taylor shooting, with no visible results. Such an environment attracts a certain kind of person, with a predictable outcome.
  - teddyh 6y ago
    I would assume that the cycle of police recruitment and retirement is too slow to have this big of an effect. To affect police behavior, the iteration cycle must be fast (which I assume it isn’t), or the pressure must be huge (which we should have seen evidence of, I would think, since the large disparity between boss and subordinate would create some leaks).

teddyh 6y ago

This is still just othering police, and thereby avoiding solving any problem. I.e. if the problem is caused by some inherent factor in the people who choose to become police officers, then we can simply blame them and move on; easy hate clicks galore! But I think police are molded by their experiences, and made by various vicious cycles to become the stereotypical bad police. I described one such cycle above; here is another: http://tailsteak.com/archive.php?num=545 http://tailsteak.com/archive.php?num=545 If this is correct, then anybody, even the most well-meaning angelic people, would, over time, become bad police, but anyone could still merely claim that all police are bad because they are “right-wing” (as if that automatically is a bad thing) or racist, and nothing could ever be solved.

HarryHirsch 6y ago
Police are also moulded by politics, they answer to someone, which usually isn't the locals. Consider Louisville, KY, where there have been demonstrations for 3 months now against the Breonna Taylor shooting, with no visible results. Such an environment attracts a certain kind of person, with a predictable outcome.
- teddyh 6y ago
  I would assume that the cycle of police recruitment and retirement is too slow to have this big of an effect. To affect police behavior, the iteration cycle must be fast (which I assume it isn’t), or the pressure must be huge (which we should have seen evidence of, I would think, since the large disparity between boss and subordinate would create some leaks).