5 ms·
It seems to me that a big problem with the discussions surrounding Uber and Lyft is that so many people claim they know what drivers want, but it's usually base
by skybrian 6y ago
It seems to me that a big problem with the discussions surrounding Uber and Lyft is that so many people claim they know what drivers want, but it's usually based on little or no evidence.
Who should represent drivers' interests? Uber and Lyft? California lawmakers? California voters? Opinion writers? A union?
Even someone who is a driver doesn't necessarily know what other drivers want, since they might not be typical. Different drivers may want different things.
It gets even worse when we talk about potential drivers. Drivers aren't a fixed set of people. There are people who aren't driving now, but might, under the right conditions.
All of these have flaws. I'm pretty sure I don't know what drivers want, and the average person talking confidently about the issue on the Internet probably doesn't know either. As a result, very little commentary has any credibility.
- panic 6y agoNewspapers could solicit writing from the drivers and let them speak for themselves.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iso1631 6y agoWhat's a newspaper?
- adamlett 6y agoWho should represent drivers' interests? […] A union? Yes.
- ramraj07 6y agoThis gets brought up often, and the other comment said is that most drivers say they like their uber gig and the freedom it gives. I too have asked the question often and similarly gotten positive responses most of the time. But I have also learned that when you question a person's career choice they will almost never belittle it, presumably because that's an affront to their decision making abilities - it's a tacit acknowledgment that they have done goof'd with their lives. I've noticed it in other places too, where arguably similar bad permanent career decisions are made, viz academia. The only question is if the government needs to be involved here to protect the people from themselves or not; my gut says no. Arguably the porn industry is far more predatory towards women (if documentaries are to be believed) yet no one's vehemently protesting to ban that industry, so I see no reason the government should bother with excessive regulation here (though some basic rules might not hurt, even the porn industry has some rules).
- mgbmtl 6y agoThis could be said of most topics. At the end of the day, lawmakers need to weigh studies, polls and legal precedents, to build a vision of what kind of society we want.
- skybrian 6y agoYes, you could say that representation in general is a problem with governance. In corporate governance, this is talked about as the principle-agent problem - does management represent shareholder interests, or their own? Also, how should other stakeholder interests be represented, like customers and employees? Note that formal and informal power can be very different. But it is also true of representative democracy, the courts, and every alternative you might think of. Governance is a tough problem and you should be suspicious of arguments that ignore the hard problem of representation. I would like to see more arguments that at least talk about polls of drivers' interests, even though they are flawed too.
- mgbmtl 6y agoYep, I agree. Drivers seem very unrepresented, except for a few lawsuits, which some could argue may not represent the majority (there is little data).
- malandrew 6y agoSadly, politicians do use studies, polls and legal precedents, but they start with the vision of the kind of society they want and pick and choose which studies, polls and legal precedents give them cover for the policies they are pushing. Partisanship has made this far worse since politicians aren't even forced to reckon with contradicting studies, polls and legal precedents because they can just dismiss those that contradict their vision as the work of competing partisans.
- thebradbain 6y agoI think it's fair to assume that driver's want to be paid at least fair wages – or at least that they don't wish, all other things being equal, to be underpaid. Now, whether or not Uber/Lyft can actually provide that to a degree that the CA legislature finds acceptable while still being a sustainable business is the question. If drivers are required to comply with Uber's policies or choose not to drive for Uber, then it's not unexpected to require Uber comply with US / State labor laws or choose not to operate in the US / state. Legal specifics of what "comply" means in this case is up for debate, which is ultimately the court's jurisdiction – or in the case of Prop 22, the people at large – to decide on behalf on all parties, not Uber's and not even the drivers themselves.
- foogazi 6y ago> I think it's fair to assume that driver's want to be paid at least fair wages – or at least that they don't wish, all other things being equal, to be underpaid. That is very subjective. Who’s to say what is a fair wage? There are many people that are willing to drive for Uber/Lyft at current benefits. And there are others who don’t drive for Uber/Lyft because they make more somewhere else. Whose problem is it that some people want to drive for Uber and others don’t?
- cbmuser 6y ago> It seems to me that a big problem with the discussions surrounding Uber and Lyft is that so many people claim they know what drivers want, but it's usually based on little or no evidence. The thing is: The requirements that legislators are setting for employers are fundamental social security services. Whether a worker gets paid sick leave and vacation, health insurance and unemployment insurance is therefore not up for the debate in most Western countries. Some people may claim that they don’t need or want these services, but the reality is that everyone needs them as everyone needs vacation at some point, will get sick or fired. And because of that it’s good that the law requires them to be mandatory. This is also why so many people from low-income households in the US have trouble to afford a visit to the doctor or vacation. Those things aren’t a problem for most workers in European countries.
- skybrian 6y agoIt's up for debate in the US, and I don't see why we shouldn't debate it. Is there no room for innovation in work relationships? In particular, health insurance being tied to employment seems US-specific and has a lot of drawbacks.
- Waterfall 6y agoThe whole system is broken. You are not rewarded for living well and eating healthy or exercising, you're penalized for other people's preventable diseases, obesity being a primary preventable illness that causes other problems. Universal healthcare doesn't care about the causes of illness, it just cares about paying it's working for treating the illness. If there is no requirements for keeping health to receive health insurance, and everyone who destroys their body gets healthcare at the cost of those who don't use it because they're healthy, why would a healthy person with no illnesses want it? I'd love to see prevention before it goes to healthcare, but try even mandating soda sizes in the US... The only way is to make it unpopular like supersize me (although he was shady and never showed the food logs). Healthcare should be paternalistic by definition but American culture cares so much about freedoms they won't wear masks during a global pandemic so it's incompatible.
- Waterfall 6y ago
- michaelbuckbee 6y agoIt's even larger than that as the other types of jobs available to people who would potentially be gig drivers have gotten worse as technologically driven "improvements" in scheduling have more split shifts (work the lunch rush from 11-1, take 3 hours "off" and come back at 5-9 for dinner rush) and near term (find out the morning of) scheduling happening. It's impossible to plan for childcare, education, or whatever else with those sorts of setups.