3 ms·
I agree, but that’s similar to saying the data is what matters, not the methodology. In the research germane to this conversation, software is the means by whi
by bumby 6y ago
I agree, but that’s similar to saying the data is what matters, not the methodology.
In the research germane to this conversation, software is the means by which the scientific data is generated. If the software is flawed, it undermines the confidence in the data and thus the conclusions.
- freeone3000 6y agoMost researchers would agree with the first statement without significant qualification. Methods are at the end for a reason.
- bumby 6y agoNot disagreeing with your assertion on the opinion of “most researchers” but you’ll often find quite a few people advocating for using the methodology sans data as a means to determine publication worthiness to try and avoid the perverse incentives for novel or meaningful data. I think it’s too easy to game the data (whether knowingly or not) with poor methodology. I advocate process before product, in other words.