18 ms·
Unity Software Inc S-1
- minimaxir 6y agoInteresting given the current issues with their primary competitor Unreal Engine/Epic, although the timing of this IPO is 100% coincidental.
- adamnemecek 6y agoI wish them the best, they have transformed the landscape of indie game development really drastically and forced others (Unreal) to follow suit.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoI'm surprised by this perspective. I see Unreal as leading the charge for indies and Unity struggling to follow suit. * Vastly better free content to throw in your games * Source available engine * No fees on the first million dollars of gross revenue * Clear communication on roadmap for engine development and what's going to stay vs. change
- kaesar14 6y ago"We have experienced rapid growth. Our revenue grew from $380.8 million to $541.8 million for the years ended December 31, 2018 and 2019, respectively, representing year-over-year growth of 42%, and from $252.8 million to $351.3 million for the six months ended June 30, 2019 and 2020, respectively, representing period-over-period growth of 39%. We generated net losses for the years ended December 31, 2018 and 2019, and six months ended June 30, 2019 and 2020, of $131.6 million, $163.2 million, $67.1 million and $54.1 million, respectively, which included $20.9 million, $44.5 million, $14.8 million and $21.7 million, respectively, of stock-based compensation expense. We reduced our net cash used in operating activities from $81.1 million to $67.9 million for the years ended December 31, 2018 and 2019, respectively, and from $19.8 million to $15.4 million for the six months ended June 30, 2019 and 2020, respectively." Promising financials!
- tempsy 6y agoBut growth is already slowing from 2018-2019 vs 2019-2020 period. 40% YoY growth for SaaS is par for the course, and the revenue figure is a bit light. Not necessarily a home run in the public markets though if there's a time to do a tech IPO it's now given the frothiness of the market.
- hunterloftis 6y agoI've heard this term used a few times now - a "frothy market," or a "frothy startup," but I'm not familiar with it. What does frothiness mean in terms of markets?
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoSounds kind of mixed to me. What's going to enable them to turn an annual loss of ~$150M into a profit?
- nabla9 6y agoUnity turns into profit in the instant they stop seeking growth. Their annual losses are growing in line of their annual sales and marketing. Unity has year-over-year growth of 42%.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoThat's not a particularly realistic way to read financial statements. It's not like they can just turn off sales and marketing and keep their existing revenue streams.
- nabla9 6y agoRapid growth software company with most of the sales coming product should have price/sales to be abowe 10-20 at least. Should we expect $5 -10 billion market cap?
- flexie 6y agoVery, very few Danish tech startups are listed. There are literally years in between, unless you count NASDAQ First North. I guess this is the way to do it :-)
- whoisjuan 6y agoIs Unity Danish anymore? I mean, it got started in Copenhagen and its founder is Danish but that's the extent of it. I don't think people say Basecamp is a Danish company just because DHH is Danish. Not trying to poke holes at your statement. Just genuinely curious on what determines where a company is from. In my book, headquarters location is the baseline.
- ppaattrriicckk 6y agoAccording to the Danish Companies House they haven't been very Danish since 2015. They've moved ownership 100% to Singapore (and from there, who knows). Still 300 FTEs in Denmark, though. https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=virksomhed&id=30719913&soeg=unity%20technologies&type=undefined&language=uk https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=virksomhed&... (the original company with David Helgason etc) https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=virksomhed&id=30719883&language=uk https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=virksomhed&... (IP company) https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=person&id=4006112978&soeg=unity%20technologies&type=undefined&language=uk https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/visenhed?enhedstype=person&id=4... (reference to the Singaporean company)
- tick_tock_tick 6y agoHow attached to Denmark are they still? I know they moved head quarters to SF a while ago but do any of the C levels still work/live in Denmark?
- ingenieros 6y agoAre they even still Danish though? They moved their HQ to San Francisco years ago and the filing clearly shows they are incorporated in Delaware.
- VonGuard 6y agoThis should be a monster. We have no direct game development tools exposure on the stock market, unless you count Autodesk, but their tools are usable by other industries. That means it's gonna be shouldering a burden for an entire industry, and one that the stock market doesn't understand or appreciate. Potential for going either way, really. Development tools have traditionally been a poor investment long term, but that's not been the case since about 2010, especially since Atlassian went public. Unity is also gonna be a proxy for Unreal. Since these two competitors are not directly competing on the stock market, Unity should be a bit of a mirror for what the market thinks Unreal would be worth on its own.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> That means it's gonna be shouldering a burden for an entire industry > Unity is also gonna be a proxy for Unreal Why do you think it has to do all these things? Why can't it just be a stock on its own?
- wastedhours 6y agoThere's always a sector influence on the valuation of stocks - if an analyst writes a report saying the gaming sector as a whole is going to grow 1000x in the next 10 years, you can bet people will be looking for stocks to ride that wave. If Unity is the only buyable stock in the sector, then they'll feel the impact.
- Trasmatta 6y agoThere are lots of existing stocks in the gaming sector though, so it would need to be more like "game engines are going to grow 1000x".
- MaximumMadness 6y agoNot 100% sure I agree with analysis, for two reasons: 1. While the primary use case of Unity originally may have been game dev, the ubiquity of the software for other use cases (primarily VR/AR and other forms of online media) has been what's propelled it to this level. 2. Epic Games is much much more than the Unreal Engine. Highly recommend looking into Matthew Balls' Epic Primer [1], but Unreal is one corner of the Epic flywheel. Which is probably why they opted to raise a billion [2] in funding recently instead of IPO-ing post-Fortnite [1]https://www.matthewball.vc/all/epicgamesprimermaster https://www.matthewball.vc/all/epicgamesprimermaster [2] https://venturebeat.com/2020/08/06/epic-games-unveils-1-78-billion-funding-round-at-17-3-billion-valuation/ https://venturebeat.com/2020/08/06/epic-games-unveils-1-78-b...
- silicon2401 6y agoCan someone explain what this means to a finance noob? Does this mean it will be possible to purchase stock in Unity soon?
- KerrickStaley 6y agoYes, it means that they are going through the paperwork required to do an IPO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Form_S-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Form_S-1
- formalsystem 6y agoHow long does this process usually take?
- ystad 6y ago~ 2+ months
- silicon2401 6y agoThanks
- mijoharas 6y agoEssentially yes.
- silicon2401 6y agoThanks
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoThey are disclosing information that must be disclosed before conducting the initial public offering (e.g. making their stock available for purchase to you and others in the public). You can assume an IPO is coming up in the not too distant future, but there are reasons it might not happen, such as lower than expected desire for the stock they'd like to offer.
- ordinaryradical 6y agoHaving followed this space for some time, Unity made huge strides at the beginning but has become notorious for punishing shiny features while leaving things broken or half-supported, which makes the developer’s life hard if you happen to run into one of those bugs. Closed source means you’re stuck writing ugly workarounds. My impression was that you can bootstrap some incredible stuff in Unity, but demanding kinds of games will push you into its uglier corners and leave you at the mercy of its updating schedule. This is very different from Unreal, or even Godot, which have their own trade offs. But it seems to me like there is enough of a “mid market” for all of them to coexist.
- oblio 6y agoHearthstone is built with Unity. I don't know if it's on Blizzard or on Unity (though, comparing things to other Blizzard games, I'd suspect Unity), but Hearthstone uses an awful lot of resources and is quite laggy on mobile, despite it presenting a pretty bare-bones 3D scene with barely any special effects.
- jayd16 6y agoCard games use a lot of high res art. They take a surprising amount of textures.
- oblio 6y agoHave you played Hearthstone? It was released in 2013 and I wouldn't call their graphics "high end" by any stretch of the imagination. If racing games or FIFA run fluently on a Galaxy Tab S4, so should Hearthstone... Even their PC version is laggy, check out streamers restarting the game (!) before important and action packed battlegrounds turns.
- jayd16 6y agoRacing games and FIFA can reuse a lot of texture data. Same rock. Same uniform. Repeating crowd. That said, HS just runs on mobile. It's not optimized for it. It's obvious when you can only look at a chunk of your collection at a time instead of smoothly scrolling that the cards take up a lot of ram. Users also have a lot more control over what is shown on screen. For a FIFA game everything is loaded beforehand. In a card game that has to hide information, it has to load as the game progresses.
- MrLeap 6y agoI use Unity every day at work. This is a mixed bag for me. Unity gives google a run for their money when it comes to abandoning old features / letting them rot. The editor is kind of crashy, launch times get unwieldy fast. Sometimes there's subtle differences between build version and running in the editor, and solving the disparity is a death march. All that said, it's still one of my favorite environments to work in. I wonder if I have Stockholm syndrome. Hopefully all this public money will get them to make a saner serialization format for their scene files. Unity's relationship with version control is... tense.
- Pfhreak 6y agoI use it a lot for hobby projects, and have used it and Lumberyard in a serious capacity. Whew boy does Unity absolutely put Lumberyard to shame. Unity, for me, is absolutely busted but also extremely approachable and generally good to use.
- drawkbox 6y agoLumberyard is essentially the CryEngine Engine that Amazon bought. It is more complex but it also shipped excellent games on it. I think game engines should always be built around games shipped. Unreal is quite nice in that aspect. Yes the engine becomes more tuned to the game types that you ship, but many of the pain points are smoothed. I'd love a game engine platform that would come along and promise API/library stability for 5 years. Any game you built on that engine will be able to run 5 years later if you need to update it. There isn't a ton that changes with game development surface level, the subsystems change quite a bit, that is fine. That is what the engine is for, to simplify the subsystems and create a stable platform on top to speed up development, not have a bunch of leaky abstractions and new unstable platforms on top of that. I wish that game engines had more standards that were industry respected and you could bounce between engines more easily as well, like other frameworks do with standards. We are in a "move fast and break things" age and I can't wait until it gets back to "let's move fast but not break things if we can help it unless it makes massive improvements that make it worth the cost/time and most importantly, maintenance tax on updates that aren't needed or break things for no reason. And when we do break things we will do it in a way that is parallel and if possible just swaps out the subsystem not requiring massive surface level changes that just get you back to baseline functionality".
- mlacks 6y ago> Industries Beyond Gaming: In industries beyond gaming, we estimate the market opportunity for our Create Solutions and Operate Solutions to be approximately $17 billion today, based on the number of software developers, architects and designers our solutions could potentially serve. There is a graphic I stumbled upon years ago - I haven't been able to find it recently - that described Facebook's gameplan - 10-20 years out. It basically described how the focus of the platform would evolve with how effectively users would be able to share their lives with their network, in progression with technology, or - more specifically - the price of bandwidth. Let me explain: FB early years was very text-centric. I recall not "getting it" because it was effectively a tricked-out twitter. Kinda like Asana vs Clickup today - more features doesn't directly translate to "better". I of course didn't factor in the "network effect". I digress. Early years was text-centric. When internet speeds picked up (without much of an increase in price to the end user), photos became more of a focus. The Instagram acquisition happened around this timeframe At the time I found this graphic, The same price/data speed phenomenon was in effect and FB was transitioning to video as its core sharing focus. Facebook acquires Occulus, which leads into the last part of the graphic - VR. I remember MZ's Mark Zuckerberg's virtual Puerto Rico jaunt. New tech is often akward, but knowing Facebook a player in an industry typically "beyond gaming" is in line to blur that line, is one good example of the viability of Unity as a real revenue producing entity. This is getting a little long winded, but I think this next part drives the point home. I'm a real estate agent, and I used to work at a brokerage called Exp (NASDAQ: EXPI). Their pitch (to agents) is that they are a "cloud-based brokerage". While not required - there is a Club Penguin-esque "world" you log into, make an avatar, walk around and an attend meetings in auditoriums. Its very cheesy, but as mentioned above, all new tech is cheesy. Check out Exp stock performance this year. Unity is in a prime position to work with companies in "non-gaming industries" looking to keep current and move with the pace of tech
- formalsystem 6y agoOut of any software tools I use frequently, Unity is the one that brings me the most joy. Any reasonably complex interface is essentially a game whether it's a music composition app, simulator, MMO or even a basic form. The basic abstractions of entities and components sometimes feel like they could apply to any software project. It's seamless to animate something, add physics, style in ways that would seem mind boggling in other environments I've worked in like Python or Javascript. You can learn so much going over basic Unity tutorials on Youtube and disassembling Unity games on Steam. The asset store has many people aggressively experimenting with better user experiences for doing certain tasks whether its character skinning or node based programming, many of the best assets end up added to Unity by default. Unity is not mostly used for mobile games, some insanely complex games are made in Unity. You can check out this list on Steam https://store.steampowered.com/curator/31285130-Unity-Engine-Games/ https://store.steampowered.com/curator/31285130-Unity-Engine... Unity ML agents is the single most exciting ML project out today which helps you create the most complex Reinforcement Learning environments you can dream of. Unity ate the indie game market but I think they will also eat Robotic simulations, Animation, interior design, VR, Web apps and Desktop apps. Can't wait to buy shares.
- kevando 6y agoLove this positive attitude. Have you tried using Lens Studio? I never thought I'd say a tool brings me joy, but Lens Studio brings me joy.
- akersten 6y ago> Any reasonably complex interface is essentially a game whether it's a music composition app, simulator, MMO or even a basic form. I've been out of the game development arena for a while, but I can't help but pause here. Are people really writing DAWs and big desktop app interfaces in Unity? The last time I played with a game engine, I would have said UI was its weakest aspect. Clunky, slow controls, visually unappealing, and certainly lacking in accessibility. Without researching more, I would feel pretty confident placing a bet that if I pointed JAWS at a Unity Window, it would say "Game Window" and that's about it. Windows accessibility hooks and tab navigation certainly didn't work out of the box, and I would say that is bare minimum for a UI toolkit. So while it's valid that Unity is a beast and game engines will eat the world for games, I have a really hard time taking them seriously for UI-driven application development.
- vmception 6y agoreading most of these comments, its clear and odd that people view "going public" or filing an S-1 as a coveted position, something that someone "deserves" or "doesn't deserve" and to me that is a very odd side effect of companies not going public often
- nv-vn 6y agoI think it has to do with the fact that HN has many users who are employed at startups. When you get paid in what is essentially monopoly money, you're going to be envious of startups which are able to turn that into cash. It seems to me like it's just the side effect of people having 90% of their net worth tied into a private company's equity and wanting the golden ticket to actually redeem it.
- vmception 6y agoTragic, but not really, either way I would like to see more nuanced discussions just about its under or overpricing, or something more overt like its "pumpability". Or maybe a discussion about how to get price discovery at lower valuations instead of just dumping on everyone's 401ks at high valuations.
- johnfn 6y agoI'm quite bearish on Unity in the long run. Unity to me seems like a team with a fantastic marketing department to contrast with a much weaker engineering department. I've tried to use Unity off and on for years and every time I spend time learning it, I regret it. I'm a full-time React developer, and the difference in engineering culture and best engineering practices between Unity and React is massive. The Unity experience is riddled with bugs, poorly-thought-out workflows, and half-finished or obsolete features. Simple tasks, more often than not, become an exercise in frustration. I've written a blog post about this[1], though it's incomplete (mostly because somewhere after writing the 2000th word I wondered why I was even using Unity at all) so I've never published it anywhere. I've honestly wondered a lot why Unity is successful at all, and the only answer I can really come to is that their direct competition - Unreal Engine, and a few other studio-made engines like CryEngine - are even worse. (Which leads to another question: why is it so hard to make a good game engine? But that would be another thousand words, so let's not stray too far from the point...) Godot is a glimmer on the horizon, but it looks like it still needs a few years to catch up. I also have a sneaking suspicion that Unity is successful because it is used by a lot of people as their introduction into programming, and they simply don't know that anything better is possible. Still, I suspect that most developers who use Unity will eventually reach the same conclusion and move on, and this seems to be confirmed by the google trends graph, which has been sloping steadily downwards over the last 5 years or so[2]. [1]: https://www.notion.so/UnityIsFundamentallyBroken-e3b1474e7afb42bdb05cadcd3c2dbd77 https://www.notion.so/UnityIsFundamentallyBroken-e3b1474e7af... [2]: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%2Fm%2F0dmyvh https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%...
- volkk 6y agoAlternatively, I found Unity super intuitive and straightforward when learning game dev. I was doing some random 2D platformer tutorials on udemy, along with a bunch of others and I always thought it was almost..easy to build that kind of game. I'm sure 3D is a different beast. Full time I'm an SWE, and I realized the way you structure your code depends on you. Disclaimer: I didn't get VERY far and didn't make huge games so maybe things become extremely painful later on. But for learning, it's a really great tool
- scott31 6y agoHow can I short this?
- DudeInBasement 6y agoUsually, there is a 'no short' window after IPO. It is better to buy put options as it limits your downside risk. Unless you are a big dog (can actually effect the market). Then shorting is better because you can force the price in your favor.
- scott31 6y agoput options are fine too, do you know where I can buy them?
- synaesthesisx 6y agoI'm bullish on Unity (especially with how it's positioned to take advantage of the AR/VR boom). I know Facebook tried to buy them at some point, and am glad that didn't pan out after watching what they've done with Oculus. As someone who has invested heavily in SaaS stocks, I know the current market is likely going to want to send this thing to space. There has arguably never been a better time to IPO.
- BoysenberryPi 6y agoUnity filing for an IPO is very interesting. I use both Unity and Tableau and they have always seemed very similar to me in terms of marketing. They have massive communities and excel at getting people up to speed and making you feel powerful. However, once you get passed the "beginner-intermediate" phase you realize this isn't really all its cracked up to be but at that point you invested time into learning them and they technically get the job done so you stick with it.
- DizzyDoo 6y agoLike some others who are commenting, I use Unity for my job every day, and it's not been a great experience these last few years, each 'part' (graphics pipelines, documentation, Editor and tooling, and so on) has been steadily deteriorating over the versions. This article from Garry (from Garry's Mod, Rust and so on) from earlier in the year is still all accurate: https://garry.tv/unity-2020 https://garry.tv/unity-2020 Sadly, I wonder how much the last few years of very obviously aiming at Going Public has led the company and Unity as a software to this state. When the forums are full of "what is going on with Unity" threads and the company blog is full of "we've bought this cloud company" and "we're investing in AR for automative engineering", something isn't matching up.
- brundolf 6y agoWhat I've heard is that many of the problems are growing-pains; Unity has some really deep technical debt and they're (perhaps too hastily) ripping it out and updating things, which is causing angst for devs when a) their existing projects break, and b) in some cases the old system actually gets deprecated before the new one reaches parity. But it also sounds like all of the completely new stuff that doesn't involve scorched-earth deprecation is generally well-received (and in some cases, a long time coming). Does that line up with your experience?
- DizzyDoo 6y agoI really, really wish it did. Here's just one concrete example: real-time point-light shadows in the Universal Render Pipeline. URP is the new 'default' way of rendering, the old renderer is being phased out, this is the new way of doing things - as you say; technical debt as they re-engineer. But how horrid has this process of eliminating technical debt been? You've got Unity proudly announcing that URP was 'production ready' in February 2019, but you still can't have a point-light cast real-time shadows. Currently that (let's face it, really basic) feature is planned for Unity 2020.2, which is still in alpha, but even if you download the alpha you can't access that feature yet, and they've announced they're not going to backport it, so bad luck if you're using 2019 or even 2020.1 for your game. It's actually making me a bit sad to go into detail on what watching the URP fiasco, so I'll spare any other examples involving post-processing stacks, or 'camera stacking', or Ambient Occlusion, or...
- caymanjim 6y agoThere's no mention of Apple here, but I suspect the timing of this is directly related to Apple threatening to cut off Epic's SDK access due to the fight over app purchase fees. This was almost certainly in the works already, but now they need to accelerate it.
- JamesSwift 6y agoThats what I assumed as well, and anecdotally I personally researched if Unity was publicly traded after the Epic v. Apple news so I could buy some shares.
- reaperhulk 6y agoIn my experience it is exceedingly difficult to meaningfully accelerate the timelines on publishing an S-1. There are too many lawyers, financial audits, investor roadshow schedules, et cetera. This is likely pure coincidence.
- staysaasy 6y ago100%. It's typically a multi-month endeavor that has been planned on a multi-year time horizon.
- caymanjim 6y agoI was confused and mixed up a story about Apple blocking Unreal Engine, thinking that Epic owned Unity. I figured they had been playing the long game, preparing a Unity IPO to launch in case Apple tried to block it.
- echelon 6y agoIt seems like Epic is going to trounce Unity when they go public. They've got a more powerful engine, megahit game, and distribution platform.
- swalsh 6y agoI'm bull Epic too, but honestly, I don't care about the quality differences. The main thing Epic has going for them that Unity does not is it's diverse marketing channels. They are becoming huge in the cinematic, and broadcast markets, huge markets Unity doesn't even have a presence in.
- jayd16 6y agoI would switch to UE but first class C# support is just so nice.
- _mkef 6y agoEhh. I really hope Unity raises tons of money , and inspires some decent competition here. Unity is the worst game engine, aside from all others. UE4 is a convoluted mess. I've tired several times , but even getting it setup with the C++ build chain is a pain. Godot ( which epic funded recently ) isn't done yet. I'm going to stick with Unity until someone else can build an easy to use game engine. Ultimately Unity does tons of very difficult things, like I wouldn't want to write build systems for a half dozen platforms solo. The asset store is easily Unity's greatest advantage. With about 1000$ and a month you can make a full playable games. I also owe Unity my career. I work far from game design , but Unity taught me how to program. In my dream Valve releases Source 2 , it's just as easy to use as Unity and then game developers have a real choice. Or I get a spare 600k to build something in UE4. I'm a fairly experienced programer and I still can't make heads or tails of it
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoIsn't UE4 free for all use cases under a million dollar of revenue ?
- _mkef 6y agoMy joke was it takes a much larger team to get anything done in UE4 . I couldn't imagine solo dev on an Unreal Project .
- tiborsaas 6y agoWe tried it for a hackathon and after a day or so we got some stuff going. Of course it's a monster engine, but you can learn it as a side project, then after a month you can start building something. I don't see why a solo dev couldn't handle it.
- _mkef 6y agoC++ is hard. The available learning resources for Unity are much better than they are for UE4. I want to add X to my game, I Google it and find ether an asset or open source project within minutes . For my current project I found a half dozen templates to start from. Everything in UDK was ether half done or abandoned. Of course both , or even rolling your own , are fine.
- supernova87a 6y agoIt is clear from the financials that in the coming months/years, they will be pressured (or simply need to) cut back massively on R&D, marketing, etc. They have a gross profit margin of 78% in the last 2 years (revenue - direct operating costs), but then if you subtract R&D, sales + marketing, admin, it drops to -30% net profit. Not even knowing that much about them, you can see what's about to happen.
- swyx 6y agothis is the story of almost every tech company at ipo, whats the big deal?
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoIn 5 years Unity will completely dominate the creative space, even outside of games you're going to be finding this tech everywhere and there is no double in my mind you'll be seeing the unity logo at the end of summer blockbuster credit sequences.
- delfinom 6y agoUnreal Engine is already very far ahead into the cinema space and already being used in numerous works being produced. Epic has been investing money into supporting toolchains and devices built to support Unreal Engine in cinema to boot. I simply don't see Unity catching up.
- DonHopkins 6y agoOh great, with all that money maybe they can get symlinks to work in Windows.
- serverholic 6y agoUnity has completely destroyed my faith in their ability to deliver on anything other than marketing. - It took them YEARS to deliver their new input system. Think about that. A company with Unity's resources took YEARS to develop a system that takes inputs from keyboards, mice, and gamepads and routes them to C# callbacks. YEARS. - They completely abandoned their networking system (UNET) without a replacement system... This was YEARS ago and we STILL don't have a production-ready replacement. - They wrote a new render pipeline called the Universal Render Pipeline (URP) and marketed it as a production-ready replacement for the old built-in renderer. However, the new pipeline isn't even close to feature-parity and the remaining features are still in development. How in the world is that a "production-ready replacement"???
- jayd16 6y agoIts not that they can't build anything. URP is ok. It cuts out features that made it slower so its not going to ever hit feature parity. The problem is indeed that the marketing oversold it. They should have never suggested devs "move" to URP. For new games its alright.
- zlsa 6y agoURP doesn't support casting dynamic shadows from point lights[0], something which many games use and should really be a feature in a production-ready game engine. [0]: https://forum.unity.com/threads/urp-point-light-shadows.881902/ https://forum.unity.com/threads/urp-point-light-shadows.8819...
- ffhhj 6y agoI really like making games and apps in Unity, and I don't like Unreal's workflow, but this is the hard truth. Unity's strategy is adding as many features as possible to cover as many cases, a tool to make anything, an asset market to find anything, but you know one more half-baked feature will replace another broken feature soon, or you'll need to buy an asset to make it right. Being messy is their strategy, unless they make a new engine with a unified plan and solid features, Unity won't be the best engine.
- nshm 6y agoAudio recording API in Unity is awful, you can only record a short clip on button press and thats it. No continuous listening, no sample rate configuration, no realtime. And processing thread changes from version to version. We had big trouble implementing speech recognition with Vosk in Unity.
- jshaqaw 6y agoWhat’s their plan to someday turn a profit?
- ffggvv 6y agoas a counterpoint to all the complaints, i still think unity is by far the easiest game engine to pickup even for people who’ve never coded before. and there’s so many resources out there to pick it up that there isn’t really a strong competitor imo despite any potential misteps
- barbecue_sauce 6y agoHopefully this will allow them to start a grant program in the same vein as Epic MegaGrants.
- ptrmthv1 6y agoWeb developers are learning it’s all pointer math on arrays. Which game engines happen to be heavily optimized for. SRE tools could be VR based. Omg lookit me pretending to manage a real server. Meanwhile its just sending something that conforms to an API spec. There’s your singularity
- madrox 6y agoUnity's done great things in its space. I worry about its long term prospects against the likes of Epic, who are going to be able to vertically integrate Unreal Engine with the epic games store and thus compete in ways Unity can't. I think a better business strategy would've been acquisition that could've given them that synergy, but I can also understand that, for the owners, the biggest cash out may not be what they're going for.
- taken_username 6y ago> Our common stock is currently not listed on any securities exchange. We have applied to have our common stock listed on the NYSE under the symbol “U”. U like Unity, not Uber or Unreal.
- ourcat 6y agoHaving only just installed Unity over the weekend and starting to go through tutorials and starting to understand how I can build AR/VR/XR 'things', I've started to see the light and wished I'd started on this a while ago. I also see they acquired 'Bolt' and made that part of the free toolset. I think 'visual programming' tools like that could be a great help in adoption by young developers. I also like that visual aides like that can help the understanding of underlying code. This S-1 is a surprise, yet not. If you know what I mean. Out of the various IPOs I've seen crop up recently, this is the one I'd go for, due to the changes in the way people are to going to have to learn and work, since the pandemic. Right technology. Right time.
- iwi885123jdkak 6y agoThere revenue strategy is bad. They really should've had a cut from sales after a certain threshold, similar to UE4. Now they make peanuts from people who make millions using unity.