4 ms·
I'm a big fan of ML-like type systems, but I never understand why Go gets so much more grief than Python, JS, etc for having nil. At least in Go, only reference
by throwaway894345 6y ago
I'm a big fan of ML-like type systems, but I never understand why Go gets so much more grief than Python, JS, etc for having nil. At least in Go, only reference types can be nil as opposed to literally any variable. Same with conversation about generics: "How can anyone write software in a language without [type-safe] generics?" of course lots of profitable software is written in languages with no type safety whatsoever and that doesn't seem to bother people.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI think that it doesn't bother people when a non-type-safe language isn't type safe. If you reach for Python, you know what you're getting. But when a type-safe language is type-safe-except-for-X, that bothers people who wanted a type-safe language. And it's one thing if the except-for-X is "except for conversions", like casts in C, C++, and Java. Non-type-safe generics aren't usually a place where you are deliberately bypassing the type safety; they're a place where you'd like to have the type safety you have everywhere else in the language.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don’t buy this at all. No one finds out that Go lacks generics when they’re neck deep in a project, it’s widely known ahead of time. If you need something that is type-safe >95% of the time, Go isn’t the answer (yet, anyway) and you rule it out before the first line of code is written and move on to other languages (of course, lots of life-or-death applications are written in C which has a weaker type system than Go, so I would also be skeptical about applications that need >95% type safety).