4 ms·
And that scientists also are rarely supported by programmers, or if they are it's an unstable and unappreciated position.
by detaro 6y ago
And that scientists also are rarely supported by programmers, or if they are it's an unstable and unappreciated position.
- non-entity 6y agoIve seen job listings for "scientific programmers" where what they're asking for is a scientist who happens to know a little programming.
- detaro 6y agoYeah - who then likely doesn't have that much software experience, and worse, if they want to stay a scientist such a role is often a bad career move, because they help others get ahead with their research instead of publishing their own work. Even if they build some really great domain-specific software tool in that role, it often doesn't count as much. Or it's an informal thing done by some student as a side-gig. Which can be cool, but is not a stable long-term thing. I hope there's exceptions. EDIT: weirdest example I've seen was a lab looking for sysadmins with PhD preferred. I wonder if they had some funding source that only paid for "scientists" or what was going on there...
- mnw21cam 6y agoSimple answer for that. University pay scales tend to be fairly inflexible in terms of which grades you are eligible for without a PhD, if you are counted as academic staff. If you're non-academic staff (like the cleaner, the receptionist, and the central IT sysadmin) then you can be paid a fair wage based upon your experience, but if you are academic staff, then you have a hard ceiling without a PhD. An individual research group with a grant may only be able to hire academic staff, but they want a sysadmin, so in order to be able to pay them more than a pittance they would have to have a PhD.
- throwanem 6y agoHaving had that exact experience - yeah, that can be a big problem too. Researchers and engineers can work really well together, because the strengths of each role complement the weaknesses of the other, and I think it would be very nice to see that actually happen some day.
- detaro 6y agoIt doesn't help with the issue of hard-to-reproduce work, but apparently working for a company making products aimed at scientists can be a place to see this happen (if the company is good about talking to customers).
- throwanem 6y agoInteresting, thanks! I'll keep that in mind for when I'm next looking for a new client.
- mnw21cam 6y agoBeing in such a position, I can say that I am appreciated, but not in a manner that results in job stability and promotion. It's a massive problem in academia, and there's an attempt to get the position recognised and call it "Research Software Engineer", with comparable opportunities for promotion and job stability as a researcher. However, it's not going massively well. Academic job progression is still almost completely purely based on the ability to get first or last author papers in top journals. I have lots of papers where I am a middle author, because I wrote the software that did the analysis that was vital for the paper to even exist, but it largely doesn't count. And I'm lucky - many software engineers don't even get put in as a middle author on the paper they contributed to.