3 ms·
Automotive grade Linux is not controlling the car. AGL targets infotainment systems and other aspects. It can have access to more important data but it's not c
by nabla9 6y ago
Automotive grade Linux is not controlling the car.
AGL targets infotainment systems and other aspects. It can have access to more important data but it's not controlling the car.
- lmilcin 6y agoThere was a bunch of attempts at this and I even have passing experience working with Intel guys on their IVI project which was integrated into AGL (https://wiki.tizen.org/IVI https://wiki.tizen.org/IVI). I don't know what makes the people think this will work this time when it did not previously. I just know that it previously was restricted to infotainment even in its name and mission statement and now that does not seem to be true any longer. "Automotive Grade Linux is a collaborative open source project that is bringing together automakers, suppliers and technology companies to accelerate the development and adoption of a fully open software stack for the connected car. With Linux at its core, AGL is developing an open platform from the ground up that can serve as the de facto industry standard to enable rapid development of new features and technologies." See, nowhere it mentions this is for infotainment only.
- tyingq 6y agoAt a high level that seems true for now, but the site does say this: "Although initially focused on In-Vehicle-Infotainment (IVI), AGL is the only organization planning to address all software in the vehicle, including instrument cluster, heads up display, telematics, advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) and autonomous driving." [1] That's getting pretty damn far into controlling the car. [1] https://www.automotivelinux.org/subaru-outback/ https://www.automotivelinux.org/subaru-outback/
- giancarlostoro 6y agoIf they add everything other than the last part I think its fine. I think something used for self driving should be on its own separate hardware unrelated to any other hardware used for any other purpose within a car in order to fully isolate itself at the hardware level so your infotaiment system doesnt crash the whole system rendering your car undrivable for a moment.
- tyingq 6y agoTelematics can be dangerous also. Things downstream might be using that data for things they shouldn't...safety systems, etc. Also, couldn't ADAS be an issue? Sending the driver lagged lane encroachment info, for example.
- craftinator 6y ago> Also, couldn't ADAS be an issue? Sending the driver lagged lane encroachment info, for example. "Lagged by how much?" is the qualifier that determines if that is a problem. 100ms wouldn't be a problem, 200 could cause issues but likely wouldn't result in crashes.
- mastax 6y agoThat's orthogonal to the OS, no? You can (and should) have separate hardware for separate functions while running AGL on the lot.
- blub 6y agoADAS can break, accelerate and steer the car.
- wongarsu 6y agoOf those only ADAS and autonomous driving sound particularly worrisome to me. Sure, a frozen instrument cluster would be inconvenient, but I'm more worried about the microcontrollers that control my breaks.
- kanox 6y agoAren't all self-driving systems complex enough to require a full OS like linux? And those systems are very much "controlling the car". Of course it makes sense to have a special-purpose microcontroller that handles real-time tasks related to engine and brake control. But those devices lack mmus or even caches so running linux on them is not terribly interesting.
- bluGill 6y agosort of. like linux is tricky because linux implies a set of compromise and automouse requires a different set
- jacoblambda 6y agoWhat specifically does linux compromise that prevents its use in automotive control? Obviously specific components should be implemented using PLCs, FPGAs, or baremetal/FreeRTOS based microcontrollers but for an overall control system for an automotive vehicle, nothing specific stands out to me as preventing it from functioning properly. Please feel free to point out all the many ways I am wrong as I imagine I am missing something here.
- bluGill 6y agoAll the things that you would choose a rtos or bare metal for.