3 ms·
Do we really need to entertain throwaway accounts created just for the boring "lang {good,bad}!" interjection? If you want to see it, there are so many places
by hombre_fatal 6y ago
Do we really need to entertain throwaway accounts created just for the boring "lang {good,bad}!" interjection?
If you want to see it, there are so many places we have that discussion. And that discussion can be found so many times online. Look at any Go version release on HN if you want to find more.
Even making a top-level comment like "Can anyone explain some quick pros/cons of $lang?" would go farther than these interjections where we need to prod them with twenty questions just to help them flesh out their own point of view. That's what's annoying about it.
- xcbl 6y ago99.99% of the boring $lang_is_superior "discussions" is by people without throwaway accounts. These people are also often more aggressive and indoctrinated.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThere is no shortage of Go users, like myself, that can admit to the downsides of it. That's why there's always the same debates about things like sum types and generics and interface{} and null pointer errors in every Go thread. And even in the recent submission where Go implements provisional generics, we go on to point out the downsides of it, like how you're still stuck with null pointers to represent sum types (like an imagined Result<T> impl). And it's pretty good discussion. I mean, the throwaway accounts so far aren't exactly raising the bar of discussion here. So far it's extremely elementary. Is this the discussion you think we're missing out on without throwaway accounts? Maybe if we keep prodding you/them for more info, they'll flesh out a novel point? Time to shit or get off the pot.
- akeiHH 6y ago> Time to shit or get off the pot. Thank you for demonstrating how regular users improve the level of discussion.
- dang 6y agoObviously the root comment was lame and should not have been fed, but please don't take the thread further off topic.