9 ms·
Are grains making us fat? If so, we should be much thinner than 1914.
- chipsy 16y agoI'm started speculating that there's another theory for the obesity epidemic, based on this recent study: http://www.ausfoodnews.com.au/2011/04/08/coffee-and-fast-food-a-killer-combination.html http://www.ausfoodnews.com.au/2011/04/08/coffee-and-fast-foo... The key thing here is that we've been putting caffeine alongside saturated fat for quite a while - coffee and chocolate or pastries, burger/fries/soda, etc. Although one of these meals screws up our blood sugar for about 1/4th of the day, apparently that wasn't enough to make us fat by itself. Then in the last 30-40 years we have the trend towards increased use of sweeteners and soft drink consumption, whose effect will be magnified among anyone consuming the sat-fat/caffeine combo. But low-carb diets work because the "sugar drink" of the study, given six hours later, never appears. In fact, low-carb diets will (from the dieter's perspective) reinforce their apparent effectiveness, as going off any fat-heavy diet will have exaggerated effects.
- StavrosK 16y agoI can just imagine the future: "So, kids, in 2020 it was discovered that X was making people fat. Before that, nobody knew that it had any adverse effects. In fact, they used it almost everywhere, from X, Y and Z to J." Basically, they'll be talking about X the same way we talk about X-rays or DDT or whatnot.
- rubashov 16y agoThe obesity epidemic had a start date. It was not a gradual trend, or something that ebbed and flowed over the decades. People first got obese in large numbers in the early 1980s. Whatever is making everybody huge can be traced to a change in the 1980s. That is a useful data point in that it rules out a lot of things. It's not exercise. It's probably not starch. Personally I suspect it's a mix of telling everybody to cut out saturated fat and the increased prevalence of fructose.
- gregwebs 16y agoYou aren't going to find dramatic changes in 1980. The human body is remarkably adaptable and many health problems accumulate over years or possibly even generations (epigenetics). Obesity implies an impaired metabolism, which takes years (used to be decades) to develop. Moreover, health problems have been epidemic in our society pre 1980 (just with less dramatic consequences). I think you are going to really limit yourself with a 1980 cutoff, and that it is more likely that the same factors just got worse around that time.
- tptacek 16y agoThis doesn't ring true. Epigenetics may take a lot of time, but memetics don't. Social changes can produce sharp changes in diet very quickly. Many epidemics predate 1980, but obesity, by the numbers, does not appear to.
- gregwebs 16y agoYes, social changes could produce dramatic changes. But social changes themselves are usually very slow, and I know of few exceptions to this in the context of health. Normally people blame obesity on social aspects (like exercise) which 1) have changed very gradually and 2) don't matter anyways (explaining that would make this a much longer discussion). If someone could come up with an example of just 1 social change that dramatically shifted in 1980 I would be very open to the idea. The only thing I know of is weight-training- the obesity numbers used are normally just based on BMI- they don't take into account that muscle isn't fat. Here are some actual numbers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USObesityRate1960-2004.gif http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USObesityRate1960-2004.gif What we see is a linear increase starting around 1980, where before then rates appeared to be constant. Before 1980, 1/3 of Americans were overweight. Every overweight person has the same metabolic problem as the obese, just to a lesser extent. The fact that 1/3 of Americans are now obese 20 years later is what I would expect due to a gradual decline of American health that hit a tipping point for obesity around 1980.
- jf271 16y agoNot just fructose. In fruit fructose is fine. High fructose corn syrup is different and became prevelent in the 80's because of the sugar tariffs in the late 1970's in the USA.
- toddh 16y agoThe theory is about total carbs, which includes sugar, potatoes, etc, not just grains. Strange to just focus on grains.
- haploid 16y agoYou're obviously not familiar with the paleolithic diet, then.
- pyre 16y agoI thought that the theory was the simple carbs (e.g. sugars, refined grains) were worse offenders than complex carbs (e.g. potatoes).
- haploid 16y agoI'm pretty sure that notion went out the window 3 decades ago, when your grandmother also told you not to go out in the cold or you'll catch a cold. Potato starch is hydrolyzed extremely easily directly into glucose. In fact it has a far more rapid effect on blood sugar than regular sucrose does.
- tomp 16y agoIn terms of GI, the Glycemic Index, sure they are. However, the more important measure it GL, the Glycemic Load, which is basically the GI multiplied with the average amount. For example, even though a cherry has much higher GI than a potato, you eat more sugar/carbohydrates in one potato than in one cherry, so a potato has higher GL and thus higher insulin response.
- pyre 16y agoHow many people would think to compare a single cherry to a single potato though? Most people would think in terms of roughly equal mass (x grams of cherries vs. y grams of potatoes where x is approx. y).
- rubashov 16y agoA potato is basically sugar, as far as digestion is concerned. The "complex carb" and glycemic index thing is pretty well nonsense. A carb is a carb. The only question is whether you have a properly functioning metabolism and insulin sensitivity. They call a screwed up insulin sensitivity "metabolic syndrome". If you've developed one, typically through many years of poor eating, you need to cut out starch, because your fat cells and pancreas can't handle it properly. If you're thin, well then the glycemic index thing is useless. Your pancreas and fat cells work fine.
- AJ007 16y agoIllogical question, obviously everyone was way more active in 1914.
- fuzzmeister 16y agoThe quote at the beginning of the article implies that this was compensated for, to an extent: "Historically people worked a lot more than they do now. They also ate a lot more than they do now."
- tsotha 16y agoThat is absolutely true, at least in my family. My grandfather ate more calories for breakfast than I do all day. He was thin as a rail, and I'm... not.
- sandman223 16y agoPerhaps the focus should be on the 140-150 pounds of annual per capita sugar consumption in the US.
- shawndrost 16y agoSource? That's over 6 ounces of sugar per day, or 611 kcal. Are you including general carbohydrates?
- shpxnvz 16y agoFAO data shows US per capita consumption of sugar (raw equivalent) at 67 kg (approx. 148 lbs) as of 2007. I can't speak to the accuracy of the data, though, or how much of that consumption directly corresponds to diet. http://faostat.fao.org/site/609/DesktopDefault.aspx http://faostat.fao.org/site/609/DesktopDefault.aspx
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIn 1914 far more jobs involved physical labor, even house work. Also, there wasn't as much opportunity to consume excess calories in 1914. The killer combination today is sedentary lifestyles PLUS too much food PLUS the wrong sorts of foods.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- rubashov 16y agoManual laborers then, as now, were more likely to be fat. Physical labor is not related to obesity.
- nano81 16y agoThat seems counter-intuitive to me. Do you have a source?
- windsurfer 16y agoI don't have a source, but when I worked construction during the summers, I would get fatter while also gaining muscle mass. I always felt hungry after working during the day and would consume massive amounts of calories.
- electromagnetic 16y agoI work in construction, my weight is currently balanced at around 260lbs and I'm around 5'9". By body mass index I'm way beyond morbidly obese. By waist-to-hip ratio for a man I'm way past what's recommended for men - I'm way past on the healthy side. Here's the funniest thing, and the prime reason why the BMI is totally useless for measuring obesity. I immigrated to Canada, and passed a full physical. My pulse is 60bpm (I actually hit full-blown bradycardic of <50bpm when I lived in the UK), my blood pressure was 125/80. But I'm allegedly morbidly obese. I can lift 200+ lbs, I can climb a 20' ladder without getting out of breath when most skinny people I know get out of breath going up a flight of stairs (incidentally I live on the 11th floor of an apartment building and I started running out of breath at the 7th floor racing with my dog). I can eat a double bigmac, large fries, large drink and two burgers off the dollar menu. I can do it regularly and it doesn't effect my weight. I've gone on diets eating mostly salad and calorie restricting myself, and it doesn't effect my weight. The only diet that genuinely works to make me lose weight has been the Atkins, and even coming off of the diet, my weight remains stable at that point like I reset my weight slider or something. I get told by doctors who are flabbier than myself that I need to lose weight and all I can think is "I can Hulk-throw your fat ass out of your office window and you're struggling walking around the exam table with a coffee". The obesity epidemic is a product of medical organizations adopting the BMI as a weight reference when it was deemed too inaccurate to study the weight changes in soldiers and was dropped. That was a height and age restricted group, and the BMI couldn't produce usable results to demonstrate fitness. So why medical organizations around the world have adopted it as a holy grail just clearly demonstrates their incompetence. The other factor is increased sedation, but this isn't necessarily causing obesity. This is causing a general and whole shift in our society to being fat. I'm not talking obesity as a contagious disease, I'm talking that people are probably on average 30-40lbs heavier than what they should be. Although, it should be noted that most western societies are facing a much more frightening anorexia and bulimia epidemic. Why is it more frightening? Because I'm 80lbs over the male long held 'average' of 180lbs, and likely 120+lbs past what my ideal is allegedly for my height. I can't go 80lbs below my ideal weight, and I certainly can't go 120lbs below my ideal. However I can quite easily go 200, 300, 400lbs above my ideal and have virtually no long term health complications for staying there for a decade and losing the weight. If I was at 60lbs, I would likely be dead or do serious permanent damage to my heart and organs even if I was only there for months and regained the weight. We wholly don't understand weight in humans. We've got 7 year olds who are anorexic and 7 year olds who are morbidly obese, and no one is doing anything but blaming society when it's happening throughout dozens of cultures.
- gregwebs 16y agoIf I recall correctly, Taubes discusses that ~1914 was a historic low point of meat consumption because the supply could not keep up with all of the demand from the increased immigration. So 1914 is certainly not a good baseline either. I don't think it is at all fair to say "they were already using white flour..". Much bread had very different qualities back then- more likely to be slow fermented instead of quick rise, much more likely to be local, etc. I think this misses the point anyways- the quality of food was different- you see a large increase in sweeteners in the graph, oils transitioned away from natural animal fats to industrial processed seed oils- and in general food became much more processed.
- bluekeybox 16y agoIf you look at the chart and treat the blue (sweeteners) and purple (fats and oils) streaks as a single one, together they increase 1.6 times from around 25% in 1914 to 40% in 2004. That's a huge increase! In fact, these two calorie sources are the only ones that consistently increased over the given period. I am surprised anyone is even talking about grains and meat.
- sliverstorm 16y agoNobody wants to give up their sweeteners or fats & oils. So they try to find a problem elsewhere.
- elptacek 16y agoTake a cup of flour from 1914 and a cup of AP flour from 2011. Place them side by side on the counter top. Tell me how they are different from each other. Take a cup of oatmeal from 1914 and a cup of Quaker Oats from 2011. Place them side by side on the counter top. Tell me how they are different from each other. Take a slice from loaf of bread baked in the home from 1914 and place it next to a slice of bread from the grocery store bought in 2011. Tell me how they are different. So no, it's not just grains that are making us fat. It's how grains are typically available to us. Highly refined, protein and fiber reduced, extended with fillers and soaked in sweeteners. It's a fact. People won't eat things that taste bad. If I gave you my great-grandmother's breakfast from 1914 (the Scottish one, you get oatmeal), you just might not eat it. I've heard she liked it with ham. And, as other commenters point out, it doesn't hurt that people walked pretty much everywhere 100 years ago. And swept their floors, washed their laundry by hand, walked up lots of stairs as elevators were not in wide adoption.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Gaussian 16y agoExactly. The average American's day starts in the kitchen. It then migrates to the seat of a car, then to a comfy chair at a desk, then back to the steering wheel, which, of course, gives way to the kitchen and the dinner table. Then to the sofa and to bed. Rather than what comprises our diets, I'd prefer to see a chart of obesity plotted against the average square feet of an American home during the same period. (The creeping size of homes being a indicator, in many cases, of sprawl and its related side-effects).
- kragen 16y ago> Take a cup of flour from 1914 and a cup of AP flour from 2011. Place them side by side on the counter top. Tell me how they are different from each other. Have you actually done this? Do you really expect someone else to be able to do it? You've managed to come across as really patronizing but I can't tell if you actually have a point. I'm no expert on milling technology, but I imagine today's flour is finer (just from the numbering system: 0, 00, 000, 0000 — I assume the finest flour in the system originally was 1!) but do you expect any other differences? > Highly refined, protein and fiber reduced, extended with fillers and soaked in sweeteners. Extending flour with fillers is illegal now in the US, and it wasn't illegal in 1914. That's probably one big difference. It's just as "protein and fiber reduced" now as it was then (as the original article points out!) and it's not "soaked in sweeteners". Likewise with the oats. What was oatmeal like in 1914? How do you know?
- georgieporgie 16y agoWe spend enormous amounts of mental energy thinking about types and combinations of calories, but not much time burning them. We pay huge signup and monthly fees to gyms that we never find the time to visit, meanwhile we never walk our streets.
- robchez 16y agoDiet >> Gym You burn a lot of calories in a day, the extra little you burn from exercise is moot if you are scoffing down the wrong food.
- georgieporgie 16y agoSo we agree, then, that a person should dramatically increase his or her activity level throughout the day (e.g. walk the streets). However, I'm going to nitpick and say that you're wrong about the gym. Currently, I burn about 1,000 calories on each trip to the gym, every other day. That's a 500 calorie deficit that I'm adding each day. In addition, my body is using additional calories to rebuild muscle, and the additional muscle is consuming calories to maintain itself. It's kind of like compounding interest.
- vlisivka 16y ago"We"?
- burke 16y agoCollectively, as a society, compared to that of, say, 1914.
- thebooktocome 16y agoThe gyms have an economic incentive to make people sign up, but not go to them. It's hardly a failure of people to want to go to the gym but stop, if the gym is purposely designed to be as boring as possible.
- 16y ago
- rubashov 16y agoThis article repeats the lie that wild meat is lean, lacking fat. The white and yellow stuff in in the pictures below is loads of fat in free range grass fed bison. http://www.tribeoffive.com/2011/04/hunting-for-good-food-and-roaming-bison.html http://www.tribeoffive.com/2011/04/hunting-for-good-food-and... Kurt Harris has lately been addressing this misconception that the ancestral diet was low fat. http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/2011/4/5/wild-vs-grass-vs-grain-fed-ruminants.html http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/2011/4/5/wild-vs-grass-... http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/2011/4/4/imagining-head-smashed-in.html http://www.archevore.com/panu-weblog/2011/4/4/imagining-head...
- leoc 16y agoThere's a long back-and-forth between Kurt Harris and McArdle http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/04/are-grains-making-us-fat/237030/#comment-181051094 http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/04/are-grai... in the comments.
- malkia 16y agoWasn't the average life expectancy lower back then? People were retiring earlier...
- saveriomiroddi 16y agoSeems like to me that almost (probably) all nutrition articles try to find a silver bullet to beat obesity/overweight. My theory is that modern culture keeps searching such illusory silver bullets because acknowledging the working solution, which is practising sports and stop eating junk food (fast food, fat food, sweets) would be much more challenging. =of course clinical cases must be dealt separately =given a certain cultural context. in a more healthy cultural context, eating cleanly is much easier.
- saveriomiroddi 16y agoThe star characters corrupted the text. The first '=' is a note after "working solution", the second after "more challenging".
- Groxx 16y agoLeave a space after the * characters.
- mdemare 16y agoThe trouble with this subject is that everybody, including commenters in this thread, thinks they already know what the solution is, even before they have a good grasp of the problem. I recommend reading Gary Taubes ("Good Calories, Bad Calories", "Why We Get Fat"), not because of what he thinks that the solution is, but to understand the range of facts that a theory of obesity must explain. When Taubes starts to promote his own theory (carbs are bad, fats aren't, exercise is fairly useless, insulin is very important), he may or may not be right. Nevertheless his book is invaluable for learning about the extremely counter-intuitive facts of obesity. To name a few: - obese 6-month old babies - morbidly obese mice starving to death - obesity epidemics among native americans in 19th century - lack of obesity among all animals - prisoners on a forced 10K calorie diet barely gaining weight We won't conquer the obesity problem until we start treating it as a huge, extremely complicated mystery to be solved, instead of as a problem of persuasion, where the solution is to convince other people that you have the obvious answer.
- desigooner 16y agoI haven't read anything recent from Taubes but is he still peddling the Atkins diet or has he moved on to the Paleo diet?! I find it irritating that Taubes ends up cherry picking data to support his hypothesis. But then I subscribe to the Lyle McDonald-Mark Rippetoe line of thought when it comes to nutrition-fitness ideology. . Edit:If it interests anyone, here's a transcript from a Larry King Live episode hosted by Joy Behar with Gary Taubes on to talk about his book and Dr. Mehmet Oz + Gillian Michaels and Dr. Andrew Weil (an "integrative" medicine evangelist) http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0710/19/lkl.01.html http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0710/19/lkl.01.html My main problem with Taubes is that he dismisses exercise and portion control/moderation in favor of his Atkinsian approach
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mdemare 16y agoYou cannot explain obese babies by saying they don't get enough exercise. Also, you're recommending solutions before you understand the problem. Did Americans suddenly lose all self-control in 1980? And if they did, why? Getting more exercise, and eating more green vegetables and less sugar is clearly a good idea, but the central mystery - why do people get fat - remains unexplained. We should unravel it.
- Ratufa 16y agoI think that the overall causes of obesity are fairly complex --- there's not some simple cause one can point to that is "the problem". But, threads like this one and the recent HN thread about Western diets remind me of this set of photos on "what the world eats": http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_1373664,00.html http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_137366... Which provides some evidence that how Americans get their carbs in 2011 is likely very different from how they got their carbs in 1914. For example: http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_1373695,00.html http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_137369... and http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_1373740,00.html http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519_137374...
- warmfuzzykitten 16y agoFor this kind of article we need a new word like Steven Colbert's "truthiness". Scienciness? It has a lot of that. This is the reason we don't let MBAs and economists do medical research. The tonnage of grains consumed says nothing about the form in which the grains were eaten. If you want to maintain that a slice of bread and a chunk of beef is equivalent to the same wheat- and meat-equivalent in Hot Pockets, this article will be food for thought.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFrom the article: Was it that all the grain consumed before 1950 was healthier whole grain? No. As flour became an industrial product in the late 19th century, mills began processing out the germ and other "whole wheat" elements because the fats in the germ caused the flour to go rancid. By 1914, your great grandmothers were mostly baking with white flour. Polished ("white") rice was similarly well established, and for some of the same reasons. And of course corn, the other major American grain, does not have a healthier "whole" alternative. The author doesn't address meat since she is focusing on the hypothesis that carbs are making us fat.