10 ms·
Airbus pilot tries Microsoft Flight Simulator [video]
- fakwandi_priv 6y agoDoes anyone have any insights regarding licensing? Is MS opening a big wallet or is it the other way around where these companies want their newest planes in these type of games? In the video you see "unbeatable fuel efficieny" and I remember seeing Iberia on one of the boeings in the launch trailer, seems like adverts to me.
- dylan604 6y agoWaiting for Boeing 737MAX to show up without the optional equipment.
- prennert 6y agoHis voice is unbelievably recognizable a pilot voice. Is this something (commercial?) British pilots learn during their training?
- bartvk 6y agoAuthoritative and soothing at the same time.
- thom 6y agoI assume it's not so much that, and more that it's another industry with a sub-optimal diversity record.
- thom 6y agoI appreciate the downvotes, but there is a reason that most people in this job (that costs tens if not hundreds of thousands of pounds to train for) sound reassuringly like a middle class man. I am not trying to make anyone feel bad for noticing the pattern, and certainly not for enjoying planes or computer games, but given that the UK government, industry groups like IATA, and several airlines all admit the issue, let's all take a deep breath.
- sk5t 6y agoA wide diversity of humans can and have learned to speak the pilot/ATC dialect and cadence; and, English is the generally accepted lingua franca for flight. I am not sure how class enters the equation, although it seems to me likely that travelers would prefer to hear neither George Plimpton nor an East-End eelmonger over the intercom.
- thom 6y agoThere are probably thousands of people who would be better pilots than the current average, who have no hope of ever qualifying because of either the cost, or the traditional hiring/training patterns of airlines. Maybe that doesn't bother you as a passenger, but it does seem to bother the airlines themselves, who keep introducing programs to address the issue which everyone here clearly knows better than them about.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoBecause all the pilots on Ethiopian Air are British middle class white people, right?
- dylan604 6y agoJust hand the poor soul a shovel. It'll make the hole he's digging for himself easier.
- thom 6y agoMy point isn’t that planes are racist, as I suspect you know. All I’m saying is the reason most pilots on UK airlines sound the same is because they are the same. Whenever there’s an occupation where we might have a clear cut image of what those people look or sound like (lawyers, doctors, journalists) that’s some small indication that there’s probably a diversity issue at play. You can argue it doesn’t matter, and look, I even said “sub-optimal” up there, I wasn’t trying to call anyone evil. And while race and gender are issues I was also just as much thinking about working class kids’ access to these career paths because of the enormous debts they might have to run up. I share this viewpoint with such radical leftist organisations as the British Airline Pilots’ Association.
- sgt 6y agoWhat if I told you diversity record doesn't matter as much as you think it does? You've been brainwashed by left-wing media.
- thom 6y agoIn classic Hacker News style, you're now being downvoted too. So clearly the truth is somewhere between "diversity matters" and "diversity doesn't matter". Who knows?! Best not talk about it.
- antioink 6y agoFor a site that supposedly prides itself on discussions that gratify one's intellectual curiosity, there certainly are some jarring taboos on acceptable topics to be curious about.
- PhantomGremlin 6y agoI stole this from somewhere, don't recall exactly where. It is a simple one-sentence explanation of HN zeitgeist: HN is open minded about intellectual inquiry as long as that inquiry doesn't challenge anything an average Californian already believes
- hugh-avherald 6y agoAbortions for some, minature American flags for others.
- sgt 6y agoWait. Minature flags are controversial?
- pmoriarty 6y agoFrom the HN guidelines[1]: "Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. "When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "Eschew flamebait. "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. "Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That destroys the curiosity this site exists for." Now please consider how many of these guidelines the "You've been brainwashed by left-wing media" insult violated. The comment was downvoted not because it "told the truth" or talked about a taboo subject, but because it violated the community norms of keeping the site friendly, and making substantial, thoughtful comments. Now if the poster had omitted the insult and actually substantiated their claim about diversity not mattering much instead of making a throwaway comment about it, they probably would have gotten a bunch of upvotes and maybe even sparked a lively debate. [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- netsharc 6y agoGeez, you seem to have a hard-on for this "more diversity!" issue. Does it matter much for piloting? It's quite a mechanical job. I'd argue diversity matters more if you have a team of movie writers (how many movies have terrible female/minority characters because of the diversity problems?) or UX designers, but I don't think your race or gender matters much when piloting a plane... Of course there is probably currently an excess of white male pilots, but that seems cultural and a socio-economic problem, if you fix the culture (e.g. if little girls also get asked equally as often as little boys if they'd like to be a pilot (instead of a nurse; or if the same percentage of black folks can afford pilot school as white folks), shouldn't this problem fix itself? Personally I'd cheer on a pilot scholarship for disadvantaged groups, because it'd be nice to see them having some sort of advantage in reaching their dreams after hundreds of years of disadvantages, but I don't think having more black or female pilots would change the job, since, as I said, it's quite a mechanical job. Whereas having a woman or minority in a movie writing crew would probably make a better story due to a more diverse perspective.
- thom 6y agoThese sorts of scholarships increasingly do exist, and I’m confused that you both acknowledge the problem and insult me for raising it. I also think it’s unbelievably patronising if you think the only benefit of diversity is better movie scripts. I support equal rights for mediocre scriptwriters too.
- netsharc 6y agoYou seem keen on finding the ways people are insulting you. Those 2 examples aren't great, but I don't mean I only care about those fields. Different voices in the boardroom? I'd say a good thing. Different voices in the cockpit? What the hell difference is that going to make, will the plane fly better due to diversity? The pilots are presumably trained to fly the planes as optimally as they can, and their gender or race shouldn't make a difference to the way they operate these machines...
- thom 6y ago
- duskwuff 6y agoGiven how much pilots and ATCs talk among each other on the radio, I suppose it isn't all that surprising that they would develop an identifiable accent.
- dylan604 6y agoCalm, level inflection with no emotion. Everyone starts to sound the same.
- bredren 6y agoIt is often said that many pilots emulate Chuck Yeager's voice.[1] Yeager was a US test pilot and jet flying ace. Tom Wolfe has a great novel about Yeager and other test pilots called "The Right Stuff." [1] https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/silky-smooth-chuck-yeager-voice?rebelltitem=3#rebelltitem3 https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/silky-smooth-chuck-ye... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np272lmVRkU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np272lmVRkU
- ojbyrne 6y agoThe Right Stuff is non-fiction, not a novel.
- bredren 6y agoAh, I had remembered it written as a story. Presumed it took some dramatic liberties / based on a true story.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoSome non-fiction books can read very much like novels, even if the term technically doesn't apply to them. These are sometimes called "non-fiction novels". A great example is Endurance by Alfred Lansing, which tells the story of Shackleton's incredible expedition to Antarctica in 1914. It is apparently a very accurate re-telling, and a book that I highly recommend. Even though I knew the outcome of the expedition, the book was suspenseful to the very end, and surprisingly character-driven.
- bredren 6y agoThis reminds me of reading Maya Angelou’s _I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings_ in high school. I asked our teacher (who also made us memorize the opening to beouwouf) how Angelou could remember some of the quotes. I recall the teacher’s response being something like, “this is what she remembers” Looking at that book now in the context of this thread I found this: >Reviewers often categorize Caged Bird as autobiographical fiction because Angelou uses thematic development and other techniques common to fiction, but the prevailing critical view characterizes it as an autobiography, a genre she attempts to critique, change, and expand.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoFrom the blackbird copypasta: Now the thing to understand about Center controllers, was that whether they were talking to a rookie pilot in a Cessna, or to Air Force One, they always spoke in the exact same, calm, deep, professional, tone that made one feel important. I referred to it as the " Houston Center voice." I have always felt that after years of seeing documentaries on this country's space program and listening to the calm and distinct voice of the Houston controllers, that all other controllers since then wanted to sound like that, and that they basically did. And it didn't matter what sector of the country we would be flying in, it always seemed like the same guy was talking. Over the years that tone of voice had become somewhat of a comforting sound to pilots everywhere. Conversely, over the years, pilots always wanted to ensure that, when transmitting, they sounded like Chuck Yeager, or at least like John Wayne. Better to die than sound bad on the radios.
- schoen 6y agoIn case people haven't read the whole original: https://www.thesr71blackbird.com/Aircraft/Stories/sr-71-blackbird-speed-check-story https://www.thesr71blackbird.com/Aircraft/Stories/sr-71-blac...
- bhupy 6y agoI think it’s the subtle audio interference combined with the distinctive commercial pilot vocal fry.
- dylan604 6y agoI enjoyed having Harry Kane flying the plane. Good to see he's got a fall back when his footy career ends.
- sdfhbdf 6y agoI love his reference to feeling the texture of the seat just by looking at it. Pretty relatable
- bjarneh 6y agoThat was unexpectedly interesting.
- kergonath 6y agoThe best kind of interesting!
- Jerry2 6y agoJust yesterday I watched a few "real X pilot flies X in a simulator" videos. One of my favorites was a real Rafale pilot flying a Mirage 2000C in a dogfight in DCS [1]. Amazing instincts and skill. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlM53d9g9q4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlM53d9g9q4
- pmoriarty 6y agoAre there any good videos like this where the dogfights are many-on-many instead of just one-on-one? I'm not a pilot, and my knowledge of dogfighting is next to non-existent, so please correct me if I'm wrong, but I'd expect that it would be much harder to utterly dominate one's opponents when there are a lot of planes in the air, any one of which could take you out when you think you've got an advantage on someone else. A busy dogfight would probably be more exciting to watch, too.
- Jerry2 6y ago>Are there any good videos like this where the dogfights are many-on-many instead of just one-on-one? Something like this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWa7NrSd55w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWa7NrSd55w
- unoti 6y ago> Are there any good videos like this where the dogfights are many-on-many instead of just one-on-one? Tons, yes, here's one to get your started: Superior Dogfight: 4 x Navy F-18 vs 4 x Air Force F-15 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=80rDX3pANeE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=80rDX3pANeE
- agumonkey 6y agopretty strange slow pace and large landscape with a imposing sense of death coming
- rediguanayum 6y agoThere's a Youtube channel with a former US submarine sonarman. Here's his channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9bMgCQyFNaMPsK9GtzM5dQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9bMgCQyFNaMPsK9GtzM5dQ Watching him play in a submarine video game as an Astute SSN is interesting as he tries to dodge torpedoes using noise makers and obstacles is interesting due his commentary and tactics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHnt_uJqTUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHnt_uJqTUA
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoI can only imagine what the features to implement spec sheet looks like for creating a flight sim.
- ygra 6y agoI certainly didn't think about that they would have to re-implement the entire (or at least most of the) computer system the pilot is interacting with as well.
- ourmandave 6y agoTo compare, here's a real A320 landing in Nice France during the day. It kind of has the same over the water coastline approach. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjWG3WRM5yk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjWG3WRM5yk
- hirundo 6y agoI feel like learning to safely land whatever plane I'm flying in is just due diligence. I wish each seat had a simulator for the current aircraft available as an entertainment option, for me to brush up on in case everyone else who could fly it chooses the wrong entree for dinner. You know the toy steering wheels that children play with in cars? Like that.
- disposedtrolley 6y agoThat would be awesome, but it would also mean that IFE systems would actually need to be made well! The current ones from Panasonic seem to have caught up to the original iPad: https://www.panasonic.aero/our-offerings/systems/x-series-block-version/ https://www.panasonic.aero/our-offerings/systems/x-series-bl...
- niklasrde 6y agoIt’s hard! They’re not slow by choice, they’re slow because of the years it takes for safety approvals, testing, and certification to complete. I’ve met a creative director who’s responsible for Norwegian’s IFE last year, and she was telling me about some of the crazy challenges it is to try and work with the hardware and software constraints they get. The software teams certainly have the resources and knowledge to build a great, modern platform.
- jamiehall 6y ago> Nearly every element [of an airplane seat] undergoes a safety-enhancing process called “delethalization”: seats have to withstand an impact equal to sixteen times the force of gravity [and many other constraints] .... Largely as a result, in-flight entertainment systems are almost unbelievably expensive. The rule of thumb, I was told, is “a thousand dollars an inch”—meaning that the small screen in the back of each economy seat can cost an airline ten thousand dollars, plus a few thousand for its handheld controller. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/04/21/game-of-thrones https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/04/21/game-of-throne...
- js2 6y agoPassenger[0] lands King Air, with his family aboard, when pilot died shortly after take-off: https://youtu.be/aqPvVxxIDr0 https://youtu.be/aqPvVxxIDr0 The video is a reconstruction from the radio recordings. I learned that air traffic controllers are rarely themselves pilots and that finding someone with King Air experience during an emergency isn't easy. This video is recent, but the incident happened in 2009. News story from that year: https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2009/april/14/unintentional-king-air-pilot-an-interview-with-doug-white https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2009/april/14/u... [0] He'd earned a private pilot's license 18 years prior, but had quit flying shortly after with only 80 hours total time logged.
- Waterluvian 6y ago80 hours decades earlier is probably enough to have the fundamentals down. Even just knowing how to use the radio puts you quite far ahead. It’s kind of the argument for basic first aid training and other things like that.
- js2 6y agoHe only knew how to use the radio because he'd had the pilot show him before take off. He described the King Air as being so different from the plane he'd learned on that it might as well be the space shuttle. One of the controllers who helped get him down realized she had to simplify the plane for him. He had been struggling with the autopilot and she got him to turn it off and fly it manually. He was fortunate to have some great controllers to help him and a clear day with no wind. After the incident, he started flying again and went on to become a rescue pilot.
- myself248 6y agoYoutube's been trying to get me to watch that for eons, and I kept clicking away from it because it's simulator video. I thought it was just someone roleplaying. Now knowing it's an actual event being recreated, I might have to go give it a watch!
- beobab 6y agoI have GamePass, so I thought: "I'll give this a go. How hard can it be? I'm really good in Elite Dangerous." Turns out: Quite hard. I have a newfound respect for airline pilots. On a related note, even my RAF cadet experience 20 years ago counted for naught. Whilst I could keep the plane in the air, landing proved the most difficult, and I crashed and bounced and would not have survived without invulnerability switched on.
- _s 6y agoPrivate pilot here - It’s not that difficult to land; especially in a sim where you can experiment without worry. It’s all in the setup - as you line up on your final approach, make sure you are at a prescribed speed and rate of descent; generally in a small plane (172 etc), you’re aiming for around 300-500ft/m at 70-80kts, and the plane is pointing to hit the runway at the threshold (piano keys / white lines). Counter intuitive: Throttle controls rate of descent, elevators control speed. Mess around until you feel these two things clicking. When you’re around 20-30ft above the threshold, reduce power to idle, keep the aircraft straight and level or the nose just slightly high and just let the plane drop on to the runway! Whatever you do - don’t force it, take your time and you’ll have far more fun actually going to places and stopping there!
- g_p 6y agoThese are good tips for flying GA and getting started in the sim. Older versions of FS used to teach more of the ground school theory than the current version. I did the tutorial just out of curiosity but it didn't really teach enough to have an understanding of flight in the way the FS2004 lessons did. For flying jets though (assuming this is what the GP means when mentioning the respect for airline pilots), you'll have some higher numbers, and you'll use the thrust for speed rather than the "counter intuitive" approach you'd use in a smaller aircraft. The things to remember at first are that you're moving faster than you think in the air, so you need to take a longer final approach than you may think as a newcomer, as you're "consuming" that distance rapidly. You'll also need to get used to lining up with the runway (assuming you're doing VFR approaches, which isn't how airlines do it in reality) and find a reference in the cockpit. And chances are you'll be coming in far too high as well - you will feel lower down when you get the view from up front (compared with a side window) and often end up too high. If this happens, go around and try again - if you dive down to compensate, you'll end up gaining too much speed and miss your touchdown zone on the runway. A good way to learn and practice landings is to wait until ILS and autopilots in FS get their bugs fixed, and learn enough to configure them to fly the landing. If they're accurate replicas, the A320 neo should be able to land itself from ILS. Learn what the approach looks like, and get used to the height and view of the descent. Then try some ILS approaches with flight director on, but autopilot off, so you're flying the approach yourself, but with guidance. This can be tricky if you're not used to the auto throttles on an Airbus though.
- WalterBright 6y agoI usually fail miserably at driving simulators because I drive by the "seat of the pants" feeling, and you get none of that with the driving simulators. It's similar to how badly I do with flight simulators, as I constantly overcontrol it because there's no feedback to my body.
- dmd 6y agoI'm guessing you're not a pilot, then, because the first thing you learn is to absolutely NOT trust your body (by which I mean your vestibular system) - you have to rely on your instruments - your body will always lie to you and get you killed.
- WalterBright 6y agoI presume you're right about that, but up to a point. My father was a fighter pilot, and he said you live and die by how tight you can turn without stalling out ('cuz then you'll fly right into the crosshairs of the guy behind you trying to line up on you). This is done by feeling in your seat and the control column the minute trembling of the wings as they reach the stall point, and that's exactly where you need to place the airplane. I took a class in performance driving once. They say to cinch the belt down as tight as you can so that your seat feels every nuance of the road. And it does, and it works. With some practice you can feel when the tires are right at the limit of their grip. It's just like reaching the stall point in an airplane when the wings lose their grip. Also, airplanes have a "feel" in the control column, and they definitely fly by that pushback. It's so essential that Boeing jets have a "feel computer" to push back on the stick to simulate what the pilot would feel if he were directly controlling the surfaces. There's none of that in the flight simulator games.
- nitrogen 6y agoThere's none of that in the flight simulator games. Are there haptic chairs or force feedback joysticks or yokes on the market?
- meheleventyone 6y ago
- Nition 6y agoImagine putting this much work into every detail of your simulation, and then getting negative reviews on Steam because there's background music during the initial download.
- gambiting 6y agotbf, the initial download screen is so bad I can't believe it was actually coded by a microsoft studio. It's a 120GB download, so I thought ok, I'll just play some other game in the meantime, right? Nope, they forgot to check if the application is in the foreground and check for button presses even when the download window is minimized, meaning that when I play something else pressing "A" on the controller presses the "help" link on the download screen, opening a new browser window and microsoft help page. So....nope, I can't play something else while Flight Simulator is downloading its data, because whoever coded it doesn't know basic principles of input capture on MS platforms.
- Nition 6y agoYeah, it's bad, and it's the first thing you see as well. But it's not "negative review for the whole game" bad. I just muted it in Windows in the volume mixer (although I bet a lot of people don't know you can mute individual apps). I didn't notice your input problem but that sounds pretty annoying.
- gambiting 6y agoNo, of course, I wouldn't go an review the entire game based on that one screen, but yeah, it's a pretty stupid thing to have right at the beginning as every single player will see it before trying the game.
- Nition 6y agoYeah for sure, even just having a download inside the game after downloading the "game" is pretty strange. When you uninstall it via Steam, those files don't go away automatically either, so now you mysteriously have 90GB less hard drive space. Gives me the feeling that things were pretty rushed up to release.
- galkk 6y agoThere was a similar recording 2 years ago: retired soviet military pilot (no piloting experience in 20yrs) is trying simulator of MiG 29 (with VR helmet). He did some maneuvers and even land the plane. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEGH965Dvp8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEGH965Dvp8, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjDhZ2Qx2bw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjDhZ2Qx2bw
- Jerry2 6y agoDon't speak Russian but this was awesome to watch. I guess like driving a bicycle, you don't forget how to fly a plane.
- shayankh 6y agomade my day really
- dom96 6y agoWow, after playing Microsoft Flight Simulator and flying the Airbus myself this was incredibly informative. A lot of crucial things outlined here, like for example I didn't know you could control the autopilot like that.
- dylan604 6y ago:50 into the video. "I don't think this word means what you think it means."
- alphagrep12345 6y agoWhat's the use case of Flight Simulator? If it's meant to be a practice testbed for pilots, how does using (playing) it on laptop/xbox give you the real flight experience?
- aschobel 6y agoI use it to do a practice flight before I do a real world trip to a new airport. That gives me a much better idea of terrain and what to expect than just looking at charts. It’s also a huge amount fun and let’s you do things that would be unsafe in IRL.