3 ms·
The oxygen claim doesn't inspire confidence. Plants don't produce any useful amount of oxygen, and real scientists know that.
by BurningFrog 6y ago
The oxygen claim doesn't inspire confidence.
Plants don't produce any useful amount of oxygen, and real scientists know that.
- atoav 6y agoA thing that they are good at however, is lowering temperatures in cities (compared to e.g. stone surfaces which store the warmth of the sun) – this alone might be a good reason to look into green roofs, given that we just passed the point of no return for Greenland's ice sheet recently. It takes the same amount of energy to melt 1kg of 0°C ice into 0°C water as it takes to heat 1kg of 0°C water to 80°C.
- gus_massa 6y agoYou probably need to have a irrigation keep the plants alive. Probably spraying the concrete surface has the same effect.
- flukus 6y agoYou would have to spray the surface every day, plants need watering much less, close to never if they're native to the region.
- gus_massa 6y ago>>> A thing that they are good at however, is lowering temperatures in cities Plants are not magical, so if they get the same solar light influx then: (choose at least one) a) They are actually not good keeping the temperature down? b) The have more reflectivity, i.e. they are more white? (but I think they are darker) c) The complex structure provides some air flow that keep the plant and soil cooler? (like the isolation of fur in animals, but in the other direction) d) The specific heat of plants is greater than concrete? (plants have more water, and water has a big heat capacity) e) The big heat capacity is due not to the water in the plant, but to the water in the soil? f) The difference of temperature is caused by transpiration of the plant? (water has a huge heat of vaporization, plants try not to loos too much water in transpiration anyway) g) Most of the evaporation is water that was in the soil? For f) and g) two you need irrigation. Perhaps not daily because plants and soil are better storing water than concrete, but it is the same amount of water. For d) and e), you need less irrigation, but perhaps it is better to have some kind of water tank of pipes, to avoid water lose. For c) you can try with artificial grass. Does it work? Is it easier to maintain? For b) it is probably better to use and aluminium foil cover (they are popular here it rooftop to avoid rain leaks)
- BurningFrog 6y agoI wonder how that compares to white painted or even reflective roofs? The paint solutions don't require a gardener at least.
- rini17 6y agoUsual white painted surfaces get hot too. And if you use some superhigh-reflectivity surface, you have to keep it clean.
- hutzlibu 6y agoSo what on this earth is producing useful amounts of oxygen then?
- tsimionescu 6y agoAlgae in the ocean, mostly. But also, any growing plants - you could compute for every kg of dry plant matter, how much oxygen is released, as the dry plant matter is almost entirely carbon produced from breaking up CO2. So unless you're collecting tens or hundreds of kilograms of dead plants from your roof every year, it isn't producing much oxygen.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoThis is why we won't solve climate change by simply planting trees. Planting trees is good but once the land is covered in trees like it was you can't go further. You have to start actively putting carbon underground so it doesn't end up in the air again.
- lxmorj 6y agoWell, you can build shit with the wood that's going to last a long time and plant a new tree. Though I'm not sure the lumber processing & construction isn't producing more carbon than the tree sequesters...
- hutzlibu 6y agoAnd algae are plants last time I checked. Because op said "Plants don't produce any useful amount of oxygen" And I am aware, that room plants do not really add meaningful O2 to the room, their value is in humidifying.
- BurningFrog 6y agoGoogling "are algae plants?", gives this as the first answer: > Algae are in the plant kingdom, but technically they are not plants. ... Algae range in size from microscopic to meters long and from single-celled to complex organisms that rival large plants. These organisms may look like true plants, but unlike plants, algae do not have roots or true stems and leaves. Either way, I wasn't thinking of algae or aware that they might be net oxygen producers for the atmosphere.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoUmm ... You may be confusing net production with actual production (ie plants produce pretty much all the O2 but they then reabsorb it) I suspect it is also worth differentiating between production as has been going on for millions of years and industrial production - there is really no way to collect or harvest the oxygen made by plants - but that is kinda implied by the GP statement (that they wanted to cool the roof make electricity and Oxygen production (the implication being something useful to a business based on that roof) So I can see your point. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_cycle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_cycle
- felipemnoa 6y ago>>Plants don't produce any useful amount of oxygen, and real scientists know that. Could you please add some context to this statement. It is hard to believe that the oxygen produced by plants is so negligible as to be useless. Why?
- chongli 6y agoBecause plants use up oxygen when they decay, or when they’re digested by herbivores, and release CO2 in the process. Plants are carbon neutral for this reason. Oxygen comes from algae in the ocean. The reason the ocean carbon cycle isn’t carbon neutral is because the carbon is fixed into calcium carbonate by zooplankton that feed on the algae. When these tiny animals die their calcium carbonate based exoskeletons sink and accumulate on the ocean floor, sequestering the carbon there. Carbon sequestration used to take place on land as well (that’s where all fossil fuels originate) but now we have fungi and animals like beetles that can break down lignin and cellulose instead of allowing it to accumulate.
- titzer 6y agolmgfy https://www.thoughtco.com/how-much-oxygen-does-one-tree-produce-606785 https://www.thoughtco.com/how-much-oxygen-does-one-tree-prod... A fully mature tree produces anywhere from 2 to 10 persons-worth of oxygen. I too am skeptical about the amount of oxygen that can be usefully produced by rooftop plants. Yet I still think it is a good idea.