6 ms·
PV: By 2050, 6 million metric tons of pre-vitrified, almost perfectly inert and easily recycled "waste" material that had a 50-year service life. Coal: 140 mil
by jeffbee 6y ago
PV: By 2050, 6 million metric tons of pre-vitrified, almost perfectly inert and easily recycled "waste" material that had a 50-year service life.
Coal: 140 million metric tons of toxic glop, at least 100 parts per million of mercury and 10 ppm of uranium, every year, right now.
- hamilyon2 6y agoComparing the problem at hand to other problems isn't going to make it tiny little bit less. Even coal doesn't necessarily produce waste. It is our choice not to capture waste/harmful byproducts makes it so dangerous and "bad".
- jacoblambda 6y agoI think that is the point they are making though. PV is still harmful to the environment in its current form but it isn't as bad as Coal is in its current form. Both can be clean and zero-impact however in practice neither are. PV is still "cleaner" than coal in its current form but neither are truly clean. It's the significant lesser of two evils until we make the effort to go net-zero.
- jandrese 6y agoNo energy source will ever be purely clean. PV is several orders of magnitude less polluting than Coal.
- syedkarim 6y agoHow much cleaner is solar thermal than PV? I assume that depends on how dirty it is to produce the metal for the turbines (steam or air, in the case of solar towers).
- jeffbee 6y agoAll of these are very clean compared to coal. Solar thermal is vulnerable to attacks from media articles about dead birds and the fact that some of them have to burn natural gas to start the plant in the morning. You can find both varieties of article courtesy of Fox News: https://www.foxnews.com/politics/taxpayer-backed-solar-plant-actually-a-carbon-polluter https://www.foxnews.com/politics/taxpayer-backed-solar-plant... https://www.foxnews.com/science/emerging-solar-plants-scorch-birds-in-mid-air https://www.foxnews.com/science/emerging-solar-plants-scorch... Solar thermal does have one huge advantage over PV: the plants contain their own short-term energy storage and keep running well after dark. Unfortunately due to market forces solar thermal is currently dead in America. All planned plants have been canceled.
- FlyMoreRockets 6y agoSolar thermal has a larger footprint, considering turbines and such, but would tend to be more easily recyclable out of the waste stream.
- jandrese 6y agoNot clean enough to offset the higher cost per kWh currently. The PV price collapse kneecapped several alternative power sources. Plus solar thermal requires big centralized power plants, where PV can be distributed easily.
- petersellers 6y agoNot sure what you mean there. Everything I've read about "clean" coal seemed like greenwashing to me. Is there a working example of any of these perceived waste capture mechanisms? How much more expensive are they to operate?
- jeffbee 6y agoCoal necessarily produces waste. It's an inviolable law of thermodynamics. Burning coal cannot produce enough energy to capture the waste products of burning coal. Solar, on the other hand, can account for its own waste stream, even in energy terms, because the source of its energy comes from outside the system boundary.
- jabirali 6y agoI'm no fan of coal, but to be fair "integrated gasification combined cycle" plants [1] are way cleaner than conventional coal plants without violating laws of thermodynamics. You can drastically reduce emissions of e.g. heavy metals, sulphur oxides, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter, while being amenable to pre-combustion carbon capture. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_gasification_combined_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_gasification_combin...
- dpierce9 6y agoThis is largely theoretical. The Kemper demo plant is a disaster in terms of massive cost overruns, many years of delays, and inconsequential net energy production. They ultimately abandoned the project.
- namibj 6y agoNo, it's very much feasible to cool the CO2 down to ambient temperature and separate it from the nitrogen, in preparation for sequestering it. Now, without setting a net-0 carbon dioxide emissions goal, which isn't feasible without salable atmospheric carbon dioxide capturing, there won't be enough incentives to capture the exhaust co2 from a coal power plant.
- azinman2 6y agoIs it really true that it’s inert? I thought making solar panels was a pretty toxic endeavor, which is in part why so many are made in China. Is it just in the manufacturing or in the final product too?
- agumonkey 6y agoThe silicon purification uses loads of fluor based acid IIRC. But the cell in itself is mostly Si + some minute amount of other metals (layers and pads). Lastly there's the resin and framing.
- pfdietz 6y agoPurification of silicon is by conversion to trichlorosilane, followed by distillation. No fluorine is involved. The side by products of this process are very quickly hydrolyzed to silica and hydrochloric acid, neither of which is something to worry about as a persistent pollutant. The volumes are also small. Just a few hundred thousand tons of silicon are used every year for all electronics (PV and ICs combined).
- unpolloloco 6y agoHF is used in boatloads for silicon wafer manufacturing. Not sure about solar. This might be what they're referring to? But...(at least in the US), wafer manufacturing is highly regulated and focused on safe waste handling...
- pfdietz 6y agoI'm not sure how much that is, though. On the other hand, manufacture of aluminum from ore requires several kilograms of HF per ton of aluminum. So perhaps the HF usage in PV manufacture is dominated by the production of the aluminum frames for the modules. I think the dominant consumer of HF, industrially, is in petroleum refineries, where HF is used in alkylation units.
- agumonkey 6y ago
- femto113 6y agoCame here to say the same thing. I don't understand why (semi-)reputable outlets are hocking this anti-renewable propaganda. Reminds me of an article[1] earlier this year about the coming "wind turbine waste", which sounds big when you give a number with tons after it but in reality amounts to a small fraction of waste from disposable toothbrushes. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-02-05/wind-turbine-blades-can-t-be-recycled-so-they-re-piling-up-in-landfills https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-02-05/wind-turb...
- epistasis 6y agoI've been seeing an uptick of anti-renewable sentiment, either coal or nuclear is probably doing a media buy at the moment. So much of what we see in news outlets are driven by dedicated PR drives, and these dying industries are trying to hold on, or trying to unload stranded assets on the next biggest fool. (For example BHP announced their exit from coal: https://companysavingexpert.co.uk/2020/08/19/bhp-to-exit-thermal-coal-mining-within-two-years/ https://companysavingexpert.co.uk/2020/08/19/bhp-to-exit-the... )
- acidburnNSA 6y agoNuclear is low-carbon energy being killed in the US by cheap fracked natural gas. It's a low-carbon partner with wind and solar. Wouldn't make sense for the nuclear industry to attack renewables. Attacking fracked gas would make more sense.
- epistasis 6y agoUnfortunately, that is not how the political or lobbying allegiances have played out. Nuclear support is often virulently anti-renewable and anti-efficiency. The divide comes from the 1970s: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_energy_path https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_energy_path
- acidburnNSA 6y agoHuh, that's one way to put it I guess. I always understood this story to be that Amory Lovins was virulently anti-nuclear and invented the Soft Energy Path as a nuclear-free utopia vision to underpin his anti-nuclear activities. One of the biggest actual challenges with Soft Energy is its low EROI. As you have to start buying huge batteries and transmission lines at a certain point, it dips below feasible levels in some studies, like [1]. Because of it's astronomical energy density, nuclear is amazing on EROI (and also effectively carbon-free). [1] Dynamic Energy Return on Energy Investment (EROI) and material requirements in scenarios of global transition to renewable energies (2019) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2019.100399 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2019.100399
- gridlockd 6y agoThis ignores that coal actually contributes a meaningful amount of electricity around the clock. By the way, 100ppm of mercury or 10ppm of uranium aren't that high, you can find that in nature as well.
- ben_w 6y agoFun fact: renewables produce more electricity than coal in the UK, even though the UK is worse for solar than anywhere in the contiguous USA. https://amp.ft.com/content/a05d1dd4-dddd-11e9-9743-db5a370481bc https://amp.ft.com/content/a05d1dd4-dddd-11e9-9743-db5a37048... https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/1355/measuring-solar-insolation https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/1355/measuring-sola...
- clusterfish 6y agojeffbee's unsourced numbers are probably not for UK. Worldwide coal provides a lot more power than wind [1], although of course it still produces more waste and pollution and everything per TWh than renewables. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-source-and-region https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou...
- jeffbee 6y agoIndeed, my figure is for the US. It's been coming down in recent years though. https://www.acaa-usa.org/Portals/9/Files/PDFs/2018-Charts.pdf https://www.acaa-usa.org/Portals/9/Files/PDFs/2018-Charts.pd...
- ben_w 6y agoMy point is more of: if even the UK can make coal less relevant than renewables, almost everyone can. The exceptions are practically rounding errors, even though Siberia is one of those regions that is worse than the UK and has 33 million people in it.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoNote also the switch from fossil coal to fossil natural gas. Coal dying because of gas is not even remotely a climate win. It's like going from astoundingly awful to terrible.
- WWLink 6y ago"We've ended the war on beautiful, clean coal. and it's just been announced that a second, brand new coal mine where they're going to take out clean coal — meaning they're taking out coal, they're going to clean it — is opening in the state of Pennsylvania," Trump said.
- paul_f 6y agoYes, there is still quite a bit of coal generation, but for the most part, electric utilities in the US have moved off coal to a much higher reliance on natural gas for base generation. This seems an inappropriate comparison?
- drukenemo 6y agoIt depends on how it’s disposed, doesn’t it? Uranium and mercury are naturally occurring elements.
- jhayward 6y agoHave you ever wondered why you can't eat fish caught in wilderness lakes over much of the American west? Because of mercury levels, courtesy of coal-burning power plants. It goes up the smokestack and lands in the food chain. This is also why people are advised to limit consumption of ocean-caught salmon, tuna, etc. - they have high mercury content, almost entirely thanks to coal plant smokestack emissions.
- CamperBob2 6y agoNot in the air and water, they're not.
- downrightmike 6y agoWired probably took money to write this smear campaign. They haven't been a credible source for a very long time.