2 ms·
> It's not actually known definitively how many people Fukushima killed, but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap
by roenxi 6y ago
> It's not actually known definitively how many people Fukushima killed, but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap" energy it produced...
I think they've done their insurance calculations wrong; it seems they've divided (cost of Fukushima cleanup) by (energy produced by Fukushima) and concluded that the insurance cost is ~$3/kWh. That seems to be accidentality assuming both that Fukushima was 100% of the Japanese power industry and also that it is certain all nuclear plants end with a meltdown. Neither of those is true - insurance works by probabilities and spreading the risk.
Fukushima specifically was likely a net economic loss; when amortised over the entire Japanese nuclear industry their "insurance" estimates are far too high and nuclear power was probably a net win. Also their cost estimates are from English-language newspapers articles which is reasonable but doesn't scream careful research.
They reference an IEEE report (on pg 7) of $0.06/kWh - that is a much more trustworthy figure and roughly in line with Japan's $0.01/kWh actual insurance. Which is pretty reasonable given that probabilistically there wasn't going to be a bad plant meltdown. If Japan had been charging 0.06c/kWh they'd have been being far too conservative from an actuarial standpoint.