4 ms·
My understanding of this isn’t that Apple is suing anyone, but that they filed a complaint against Prepear’s trademark application - and that’s it. As in, at on
by kstrauser 6y ago
My understanding of this isn’t that Apple is suing anyone, but that they filed a complaint against Prepear’s trademark application - and that’s it. As in, at one point in the process, there’s the equivalent of the copyright office asking “does anyone have a problem with this?” and Apple said “we’d prefer you not”. That doesn’t mean the trademark will be shot down, but that the objection will be evaluated.
Is there more to it than that? If not, this seems far different from how it’s being characterized.
- bcardarella 6y agoDidn't you read the headline? This is a battle to the death.
- boomlinde 6y agoHow is it being characterized? Certainly not as a lawsuit.
- kstrauser 6y agoThe characterization is that Apple is breaking out the big guns to stomp all over a tiny company, as opposed to them filing a routine piece of paperwork and not showing obvious signs of doing anything more. This story is that “they’re taking the fight to Canada”, which begs the question that there’s even a fight. Instead, sounds like Prepear filed for trademarks in both the US and Canada, and Apple filed a similar response in both places.
- rendall 6y agoYes, I thought this was a lawsuit all along. I only realized it was not after reading your reply. Is it normal for companies to file trademark commentary, like Apple is doing? +1 for using "begs the question" properly
- kstrauser 6y agoYeah, it’s really normal. If you were bored enough, you could get a list of current applications and file your own complaints. This is the “Notice of Opposition” that Apple filed in the US: https://www.scribd.com/document/471822364/Apple-s-Notice-of-Opposition-v-Super-Healthy-Kids-Inc https://www.scribd.com/document/471822364/Apple-s-Notice-of-... . That’s it - that’s the only thing I’ve heard that Apple’s actually done. The press makes it sound like they’re trying to have Prepear’s founders keelhauled or something, but to me this looks like like routine paperwork. It’s not even like the USPTO denied Apple’s opposition and they’re appealing it.
- boomlinde 6y ago> That’s it - that’s the only thing I’ve heard that Apple’s actually done. The press makes it sound like they’re trying to have Prepear’s founders keelhauled or something, but to me this looks like routine paperwork Where does the press make it seem like Apple are trying to have Prepear's founders "keelhauled or something"? I understand that you are now not commenting on the article here (which certainly doesn't).
- kstrauser 6y agoI don’t think we read the same article. The one linked here talks a lot about lawyers and fighting and money and layoffs and makes it sound like Apple’s mounting a major offensive. And while I certainly wouldn’t want to be in Prepear’s shoes and having to argue against Apple, literally nothing I’ve seen suggest that Apple is doing anything more than filing one-off trademark opposition letters. For all we know at this time, the whole interaction may end at: USPTO: Does anyone object to this? Apple: We’re not big fans of it. USPTO: Too bad. We’re granting it anyway. Apple: Alright. Sure, they may end up fighting this tooth and nail for a decade to come, but there’s been no evidence at all to suggest that they might.
- tedunangst 6y agoWhy are there so many comments on this page talking about courts and judges and suing?
- kstrauser 6y agoI think because people read the headline and assumed something that’s totally wrong. When the first of these stories came out, people also misread those and got whipped up over a nonexistent lawsuit. Now every subsequent story suffers from the baggage of that first one: “I heard that Apple’s suing someone, and now they’re also fighting in Canada, too? We should break them up.” I’m not even on Apple’s side on this. I think they’ll lose the opposition to Prepear’s trademark applications. But I still think it’s a bad look for us that so many people are protesting what they think Apple has done, even though they haven’t.
- jpalomaki 6y agoTo keep your trademark, you need to defend it. It’s a duty of trademark holder to keep an eye on potentially infringing applications and take action if it notices them. If you don’t take actions it means you have given up your trademark. Not sure how else Apple could proceed here.
- CogitoCogito 6y ago> Not sure how else Apple could proceed here. Apple could simply have looked at it and said "this mark would never be confused with ours" and then been done with it.
- thomaslord 6y agoIf my trademarked logo contains a red circle and you file for a trademark on your logo, which contains a green triangle, will I lose my trademark if I don't oppose yours? No reasonable person of sound mind would ever confuse the two logos in this case.