4 ms·
> I understand that they’re interested in maintaining a luxurious image They give you a lot of value back compared to other cards I've tried in Europe. I don't
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> I understand that they’re interested in maintaining a luxurious image
They give you a lot of value back compared to other cards I've tried in Europe. I don't know it's something as flippant as 'luxurious image' - people use them because when they are accepted and you're buying something expensive like corporate flights and hotels, you can earn an a significant amount of value back. I flew transatlantic first-class a few times completely free on my AmEx. My Visas give me so little I don't even bother checking what the current total is.
It's free money to you (the actual cost is amortised across all consumers and it's there if you use you card or not) so might as well take as much as they'll give you.
- rco8786 6y agoOP is talking about merchant fees. Amex is the most expensive card for merchants to accept.
- chrisseaton 6y agoYes that's what I'm talking about as well. Merchants don't accept them because of their high merchant fees, but AmEx don't have high merchant fees for some flippant reason like to create a 'luxurious image' - they do it to create value for their card holders.
- bhupy 6y ago“Free money” paid for by merchants is a luxury, not a necessity.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThe consumers overall cover the costs - the merchants don’t just eat the cost.
- bhupy 6y agoYup, point remains. It’s an externality masquerading as a luxury. It’s also arguably regressive, since the beneficiaries of those rewards tend to be overwhelmingly rich, while the inflated prices are paid for by everybody else.
- rvnx 6y agoIt seems like a cashback card then
- bhupy 6y agoYup, point remains. Cash back cards maintain the same characteristics. Traditional cash back cards are arguably less regressive since it isn’t just the wealthy that have cash back cards. In theory, a broader set of people are beneficiaries of a system that a broad set of consumers pay into via higher prices. AmEx cards OTOH are expensive enough to process that there still exists a broad set of merchants who refuse to process them. For those that do process them, it’s harder to say to what degree the costs are passed on to all buyers. And unlike cashback cards, Amex rewards beneficiaries heavily skew rich.
- chinathrow 6y agoThis makes me sad. Card companies create value buy increasing prices to buy the card holders loyalty. I understand that this works but I think it is a form of corruption. Buying your customers loyalty rsp spending...
- wsc981 6y agoI am not sure how well this strategy will work out in the long run. Personally I look forward to replace my Amex card with Apple’s card, once available for me. Here in Thailand many shops, hotels don’t accept Amex, so it’s harder to save up points for benefits, effectively reducing the value of the card.
- paulcole 6y agoNearly every Amex has an annual fee for the card holder. Some are quite substantial. There had better be value.
- vmception 6y agowhich hasn't been true for some time
- rco8786 6y ago? Source for that?
- the-dude 6y agoThe whole idea that a particular card gives you monetary value is completely foreign to most Europeans I know ( I am European myself ). The only value perceived is the ability to pay in the first place. From the perspective in NL, with its ubiquitous PIN and iDeal system ( online PIN ), it seems like a totally unnecessary tax on economic transactions. The rates are not comparable ( a couple to maybe 20 cents per transaction ).
- chrisseaton 6y ago> The only value perceived is the ability to pay in the first place. Right I get that with my (European) AmEx almost all the time... plus free (amortised) first-class flights. Why would a rational person turn that down? I already need to carry a backup card for emergencies so it’s no extra burden.
- the-dude 6y agoI think there is a couple reasons why creditcards are not popular in Europe. They don't like buying on credit ( even less so in DE vs NL I guess ). The cards only got widespread in the 90s. We have our own systems. If I had a physical shop, I would probably decline AmEx purchases. In the shops which do accept them, expect them to hate you for it. I happen to travel very little and know almost all shopkeepers who I buy groceries from / shop with ( including at my supermarket ). I get more value from being loved. edit: Now I think about it, a history with severe inflation might have to do something with the EU attitude too.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIn a society with severe inflation surely the very last thing you want to be holding is cash in your literal pocket like Germans do?
- the-dude 6y agoIf you are an individualist maybe you are right. I think the Germans are more aware of the Tragedy of the Commons. Personally I do not like the hyper-individualist, credit-laden neoliberal economic system which is slowly creeping into the EU. Targetting the individual with ever more convenience and more-for-less. Finally, cash is untraceable and therefore of vital importance to me and free societies.