5 ms·
> While the design ... appears anachronistic Nothing anachronistic about it; this is likely an optimal design when considering how to maximise the effective co
by roenxi 6y ago
> While the design ... appears anachronistic
Nothing anachronistic about it; this is likely an optimal design when considering how to maximise the effective coverage of guns. This is good design for a fortification that is meant to be held.
This design is relatively quite modern and is a direct response to the introduction of artillery to warfare. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_gunpowder#Changes_to_fortifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_gunpowder#Changes_t... . It is a difficult fortification to crack. In fact it has a long history of use in colonial expeditions according to Wikipedia.
- masklinn 6y agoIt's anachronistic in the sense that it was largely made obsolete by artillery advances during the 19th century, replaced by polygonal forts (which could even adapt to high-explosive payloads, and actually proved their worth in both world wars), as well as the more modern bunkers & fortified emplacements. It makes a lot of sense when unlikely to face artillery and bombers though, as it's pretty straightforward and cheap to build and operate. But it is a throwback to something which has largely become decorative in the lands or originate from.
- wffurr 6y agoThe decorative aspect is actually a major piece of it's function here. It's intended to be highly visible, and maintaining a highly visible military presence is part of counterinsurgency tactics. It's also a very French thing to do.
- omginternets 6y agoIt’s also in a theater of asymmetric warfare. It’s not like the enemy has (serious) artillery, much less air power.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoYup, this architecture makes sure you have gun coverage for all your walls, in case people try to get close to them / scale the walls.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 6y ago> The decorative aspect is actually a major piece of it's function here. It's intended to be highly visible Decorative doesn't mean highly visible, it means the only value is in the looks. Star forts in europe are purely decorative, they don't have any function aside from looking rather neat (and the historical context /value I guess).
- rumanator 6y ago> Star forts in europe are purely decorative, Your assertion is simply wrong. "Star forts" is what you get when you optimize a defensive structure where you want to maximize line of sight from loop holes, minimize blind spots, and ensure that if the enemy overruns parts of their defensive structure they can't use it to shield themselves from loopholes in other parts of your fortification.
- rumanator 6y agoIt seems you're missing the point. The point is that bastions are prove to be effective as defensive structures (it minimizes blind spots in a battlefield) in scenarios where the enemy carries mostly light weaponry. The design is also effective to conduct psychological warfare for some of the reasons that they become tourist attractions in Europe.
- masklinn 6y agoWhat point did I miss exactly? I explained why the article would call the design anachronistic (which is what GP complained about) as well as — expecting your sort — why it made perfect sense anyway.
- jpollock 6y agoWhy it's anachronistic is interesting. The bastion was dropped because attackers soon learned they could get artillery fire into the bastion, and ricochet shot in there. Newer fort designs seem to be about accepting that explosions will happen inside of the walls, and avoiding reflections? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygonal_fort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygonal_fort
- hnarn 6y ago> Nothing anachronistic about it; this is likely an optimal design when considering how to maximise the effective coverage of guns. I guess what makes it slightly anachronistic is that these "pointy" designs look like they are somehow designed with fluid or aero-dynamics in mind, and back in the days I guess they were when an amassing army would literally try and storm the walls. In that situation, you want the opposing army to be forced against a point rather than a flat wall so that every flat wall they attack, they are flanked by another one right next to it, creating a "kill zone". While I'm sure the design is by no means "useless" by today's standards, I have to wonder if the original intent of the design makes sense in an era of air strikes and tanks. But then again, if you're up against a less advanced adversary, maybe "storming the gates" is literally what they'll be forced to attempt.