4 ms·

For many kids, this kind of toy has a short window of novelty and then waits in a closet until its time comes to go to the landfill. We should be extra skeptica

For many kids, this kind of toy has a short window of novelty and then waits in a closet until its time comes to go to the landfill. We should be extra skeptical of consumerism that targets children. I think that’s what GP was getting at.

bluedevil2k 6y ago
Well GP is wrong. I have a 10 year old girl, I’ve bought a dozen of these, and she loved them each time. Yes, she may play with them only for a few hours each, but if it brings a smile to her face & makes her happy for many hours, then I think most parents agree it’s worth it.
- deepzn 6y ago
  What ever works for you man. That stuff is meth, trash, superficial garbage.
  - kgraves 6y ago
    That kids can grow out of, it's harmless than actual 'meth' and other 'addictions' adults almost never 'grow out of'.
    - TaylorAlexander 6y ago
      Do you know where our plastic ends up? Every documentary I’ve seen on the subject shows that our plastic ends up with no oversight in some poor country while children literally sift through it for pennies a day.
      - drak0n1c 6y ago
        Only due to the recent habit of tossing toys and all kinds of junk in recycling bins, where they don't belong. Over-recycling is worse for the planet than simply throwing away garbage responsibly. Most parts of the US have no shortage of landfill space.
      - brendawalsh 6y ago
        Maybe your plastic. Mine is transported several miles away, where it is buried and can then leech into the river, which is used as our water supply downstream. But, yeah, who decided to put the water treatment plant next to the landfill?
  - smabie 6y ago
    Unlike the cultured and refined stuff you like, I assume?
  - kinghtown 6y ago
    And your kids are watching Godard films?
- powercf 6y ago
  The amount of plastic waste around some of these toys is shocking: https://youtu.be/CZpG032TR5A https://youtu.be/CZpG032TR5A. It reminds me of the packaging around AMD Threadripper and Intel 9900k packaging - both also very wasteful. If they only make a child happy for a few hours then it's probably not worth it.
  - HeWhoLurksLate 6y ago
    One of my friends built a PC into his dad's Threadripper box, inspired by this: https://www.anandtech.com/show/14473/spotted-at-computex-a-ryzen-pc-in-a-threadripper-retail-box https://www.anandtech.com/show/14473/spotted-at-computex-a-r... Remember, these things are targeted at a subset of an enthusiast market (and some HEDT stuff, too) and are mainly Halo products- and for many people, if they're paying $600 for a CPU, a nice box / unboxing experience is a quite nice touch.
- anm89 6y ago
  She may have only played with them for a few hours but the plastic waste will outlive her by 100x. You really can't see anything negative here?
rdtsc 6y ago
> For many kids, this kind of toy has a short window of novelty This one takes it to the next level. It "hacks" that by selling these toys in an opaque plastic container and they have "rare", "ultra-rare" etc types. So kids get hooked on wanting to collect all the dolls looking for a specific ultra-rare one, and having to buy lots of these things including duplicate ones.
- fyfy18 6y ago
  Is that really any different than things like Pokémon or MTG - other than cards have a lower environmental impact when landfilled than toys, due to the smaller volume?
  - c22 6y ago
    No?
puranjay 6y ago
I don't know. I had a bunch of toys growing up that I retained. They're kept in a little glass cupboard in my house. My nephews love playing with them whenever they're over. Something that lasted two generations certainly seems good value to me.
Fricken 6y ago
Regulations restricting advertising at children turned Saturday morning cartoons into unboxing videos. I'm glad I grew up in the 80s.

bluedevil2k 6y ago

Well GP is wrong. I have a 10 year old girl, I’ve bought a dozen of these, and she loved them each time. Yes, she may play with them only for a few hours each, but if it brings a smile to her face & makes her happy for many hours, then I think most parents agree it’s worth it.

deepzn 6y ago
What ever works for you man. That stuff is meth, trash, superficial garbage.
- kgraves 6y ago
  That kids can grow out of, it's harmless than actual 'meth' and other 'addictions' adults almost never 'grow out of'.
  - TaylorAlexander 6y ago
    Do you know where our plastic ends up? Every documentary I’ve seen on the subject shows that our plastic ends up with no oversight in some poor country while children literally sift through it for pennies a day.
    - drak0n1c 6y ago
      Only due to the recent habit of tossing toys and all kinds of junk in recycling bins, where they don't belong. Over-recycling is worse for the planet than simply throwing away garbage responsibly. Most parts of the US have no shortage of landfill space.
    - brendawalsh 6y ago
      Maybe your plastic. Mine is transported several miles away, where it is buried and can then leech into the river, which is used as our water supply downstream. But, yeah, who decided to put the water treatment plant next to the landfill?
- smabie 6y ago
  Unlike the cultured and refined stuff you like, I assume?
- kinghtown 6y ago
  And your kids are watching Godard films?
powercf 6y ago
The amount of plastic waste around some of these toys is shocking: https://youtu.be/CZpG032TR5A https://youtu.be/CZpG032TR5A. It reminds me of the packaging around AMD Threadripper and Intel 9900k packaging - both also very wasteful. If they only make a child happy for a few hours then it's probably not worth it.
- HeWhoLurksLate 6y ago
  One of my friends built a PC into his dad's Threadripper box, inspired by this: https://www.anandtech.com/show/14473/spotted-at-computex-a-ryzen-pc-in-a-threadripper-retail-box https://www.anandtech.com/show/14473/spotted-at-computex-a-r... Remember, these things are targeted at a subset of an enthusiast market (and some HEDT stuff, too) and are mainly Halo products- and for many people, if they're paying $600 for a CPU, a nice box / unboxing experience is a quite nice touch.
anm89 6y ago
She may have only played with them for a few hours but the plastic waste will outlive her by 100x. You really can't see anything negative here?

rdtsc 6y ago

> For many kids, this kind of toy has a short window of novelty This one takes it to the next level. It "hacks" that by selling these toys in an opaque plastic container and they have "rare", "ultra-rare" etc types. So kids get hooked on wanting to collect all the dolls looking for a specific ultra-rare one, and having to buy lots of these things including duplicate ones.

fyfy18 6y ago
Is that really any different than things like Pokémon or MTG - other than cards have a lower environmental impact when landfilled than toys, due to the smaller volume?
- c22 6y ago
  No?

puranjay 6y ago

I don't know. I had a bunch of toys growing up that I retained. They're kept in a little glass cupboard in my house. My nephews love playing with them whenever they're over. Something that lasted two generations certainly seems good value to me.

Fricken 6y ago

Regulations restricting advertising at children turned Saturday morning cartoons into unboxing videos. I'm glad I grew up in the 80s.