3 ms·
Wind turbines kill a negligible number of birds compared to other threats. https://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science/wind-turbine-kill-bird
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Wind turbines kill a negligible number of birds compared to other threats.
https://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science/wind-turbine-kill-birds.htm https://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-scienc...
It's not actually known definitively how many people Fukushima killed, but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap" energy it produced.
https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/8/12/1301/pdf https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/8/12/1301/pdf
Nuclear is not clean. There is still no solution to nuclear waste, which makes it impossible to cost the TOC of nuclear.
And considering the number of accidents to date - and their economic cost - nuclear certainly isn't safe either. Is it really a good idea to create pools of extremely toxic heavy metal waste which is also radioactive?
It also isn't cheap. Renewables have been consistently undercut the cost of nuclear electricity, and that's without any significant push towards an improved smart grid, a combination of centralised and local distribution, and clean pumped storage facilities that would be possible with a Green New Deal.
As you say - these decisions should be left to smart people, and not to an industry which has consistently overpromised and underdelivered.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoRenewables are riding on the shoulders of a gigantic fossil-powered grid that (usually) handles their intermittency for them for free. When you deeply decarbonize with intermittent energy sources you have to add in new costs: storage, new transmission, smart loads. These costs add $40-60/MWh of electricity, which brings the actual system cost right up to the cost of nuclear today. So nuclear is already economic with any other decarbonized grid. Related info in [1]. [1] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2018.08.006 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2018.08.006 "No solution to the waste" is a myth [2]. The waste is stored in dry casks which have never injured a soul. Meanwhile combustion waste from fossil and renewable biofuel kills 8 million/yr [3]. [2] https://whataboutthewaste.com https://whataboutthewaste.com [3] https://www.who.int/health-topics/air-pollution https://www.who.int/health-topics/air-pollution Yes, by those numbers, fossil and biofuel kill the same number of people every single week than have ever been attributed to nuclear accidents in the history of the industry. Plus nuclear solves climate change. If fossil and renewable biofuel had to pay insurance for climate change, we'd be building nuclear like crazy. Also, wind turbines kill large raptors and migratory bats, not songbirds.
- opo 6y ago>..Wind turbines kill a negligible number of birds compared to other threats. The source you list gives an estimate for bird deaths that is an order of magnitude less than the Audubon society or the US Fish and Wildlife service. But the issue isn't so much the number of birds, but the type: >...Although fatality rates for raptors may be lower compared to passerines, raptors are especially vulnerable to collisions due to their flight behaviors. Given the life history traits of raptors (i.e., long-lived and low reproductive rates) their populations are more at risk of decline from the number of different sources of impacts that affect these species on a daily basis. https://www.fws.gov/birds/bird-enthusiasts/threats-to-birds/collisions/wind-turbines.php https://www.fws.gov/birds/bird-enthusiasts/threats-to-birds/... This isn't to say that means we should drop wind, but we shouldn't hand wave away the issue. >...It's not actually known definitively how many people Fukushima killed, but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap" energy it produced. The death rate from Fukishima is far less than the death rate from any properly working fossil fuels source (or wind or rooftop solar for that matter) >...but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap" energy it produced. This is an argument to move away from 50 year old plant designs into something more modern and even safer. >...And considering the number of accidents to date - and their economic cost - nuclear certainly isn't safe either. Is it really a good idea to create pools of extremely toxic heavy metal waste which is also radioactive? In terms of safety, no major power source has as good of a safety record as nuclear. In terms of nuclear waste, as many people have already said in this discussion, it is very low volume, could be recycled right now and eventually most of it can be used as fuel on 4th gen reactors. >...It also isn't cheap. Renewables have been consistently undercut the cost of nuclear electricity, and that's without any significant push towards an improved smart grid, a combination of centralised and local distribution, and clean pumped storage facilities that would be possible with a Green New Deal. It is possible there will be some major advances in grid storage that will allow us to stop using natural gas to cover for the intermittent nature of wind and solar. But what if that doesn't pan out? The dangers we are facing in the coming decades are immense. Is your fear of nuclear power so great that if you had to choose, you would prefer the world to suffer through catastrophic climate change rather than use nuclear power?
- roenxi 6y ago> It's not actually known definitively how many people Fukushima killed, but it is known definitively that the final economic costs wildly outweighed the "cheap" energy it produced... I think they've done their insurance calculations wrong; it seems they've divided (cost of Fukushima cleanup) by (energy produced by Fukushima) and concluded that the insurance cost is ~$3/kWh. That seems to be accidentality assuming both that Fukushima was 100% of the Japanese power industry and also that it is certain all nuclear plants end with a meltdown. Neither of those is true - insurance works by probabilities and spreading the risk. Fukushima specifically was likely a net economic loss; when amortised over the entire Japanese nuclear industry their "insurance" estimates are far too high and nuclear power was probably a net win. Also their cost estimates are from English-language newspapers articles which is reasonable but doesn't scream careful research. They reference an IEEE report (on pg 7) of $0.06/kWh - that is a much more trustworthy figure and roughly in line with Japan's $0.01/kWh actual insurance. Which is pretty reasonable given that probabilistically there wasn't going to be a bad plant meltdown. If Japan had been charging 0.06c/kWh they'd have been being far too conservative from an actuarial standpoint.
- StreamBright 6y ago>> Nuclear is not clean. There is still no solution to nuclear waste, which makes it impossible to cost the TOC of nuclear. Totally. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-radioactive-than-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-... "According to U.S. NCRP reports, population exposure from 1000-MWe power plants amounts to 490 person-rem/year for coal power plants, 100 times as great as nuclear power plants (4.8 person-rem/year). The exposure from the complete nuclear fuel cycle from mining to waste disposal is 136 person-rem/year; the corresponding value for coal use from mining to waste disposal is "probably unknown".[24]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Coal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Coal