4 ms·
This seems a bit arbitrary. All our fossil fuel use is effectively non-renewable; so we've effectively exceeded the sustainable capacity of the earth to support
by roenxi 6y ago
This seems a bit arbitrary. All our fossil fuel use is effectively non-renewable; so we've effectively exceeded the sustainable capacity of the earth to support us some time on 1 January.
This 'biocapacity' that has been identified isn't going to be a limit as long as we have cheap energy. The earth can't provide anywhere close to the amount of food we use; we need artificial fertiliser and machines which is, practically, non-renewable after accounting for how we source energy for transport and powering farm equipment.
Synthetic fertiliser alone means I'm not sure I care about 'biocapacity'. See https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-population-with-and-without-fertilizer https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-population-with-and...
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThis seems more than a bit arbitrary. As another commenter said, it's a smart marketing campaign, but there's no way this is more than a very rough approximation. Fixing it to a specific day implies a lot more certainty than I think is warranted.
- donw 6y agoBingo. The Green Revolution massively increased Earth's carrying capacity, but at the cost of total dependence on artificial fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides, and machinery, with the alternative being "half of the human population on Earth starves to death". Fertilizers we can make without fossil fuels -- the Haber process could likely use hydrogen sourced via electrolysis. I don't know about limits on phosphate or potassium (the "PK" in "NPK"). Equipment and farming practices are improving in terms of energy and material efficiency, and I suspect we'll get to the point where we can run everything off of electricity in the next decade, but we still need to generate a lot of that -- which means nuclear, because I don't see renewables getting there any time soon.