2 ms·
Are you accounting for costs of mining the source material? As I understand it the cost to acquire and safely handle the nuclear material is significant.
by paulryanrogers 6y ago
Are you accounting for costs of mining the source material? As I understand it the cost to acquire and safely handle the nuclear material is significant.
- mnemonicsloth 6y agoSignificantly less than digging up millions of tons of coal. Note also that coal is somewhat radioactive too, and there is a lot more of it, so the radiation difference is small and might even favor nuclear
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoCoal is terrible. That doesn't make nuclear power the best option compared to all the others. The radiation difference isn't small if you include accidents. (Are we somehow supposed to pretend they never happened, and no nuclear accident - even if it's "just" a fuel spill, or a small fire - will ever happen again?)
- quickthrowman 6y agoWhich current option is better than nuclear? Please take into account the lack of battery storage capacity and water pumped storage capacity that makes an all solar and wind grid completely impractical, and that adding extensive hydro power would cause further degradation of our rivers. Nuclear power is our best option among coal/oil/natural gas/nuclear, if you believe that reducing carbon/methane emissions to slow or halt global warming is important.
- korantu 6y agoFor nuclear, as it is much denser energy-wise then anything else, you need to do the least amount of digging per MW capacity / let alone overall produced MWh Also one has to consider how much energy needs to be spent to get certain amount of energy generated, so called EROI. Nuclear is orders of magnitude better than other low-co2 options. For example for solar it is about 6, versus 75 for nuclear. [1] Given the investment energy is mostly in shape of fossil fuels, one, for example, cannot fuel carbon capture with anything other than nuclear, as in balance it will not reduce co2. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2015/02/11/eroi-a-tool-to-predict-the-best-energy-mix/#3de9a2a2a027 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2015/02/11/eroi-a-to...