3 ms·
A huge part of the reason is that the providers had to pay well over 50 billion € for the frequency licensing. Back in the early 2000s finance minister Eichel
by mschuster91 6y ago
A huge part of the reason is that the providers had to pay well over 50 billion € for the frequency licensing.
Back in the early 2000s finance minister Eichel wanted to achieve the "schwarze null" (positive budget), and in attempting so, this idiot fucked up digitalisation in Germany for decades, as the providers had to take out huge loans and had to re-pay them instead of being able to invest in building out the networks or offer affordable services!
The problem is compounded by idiot NIMBYs believing that radiation is harmful and causes cancer - in many of the total blackout regions it is local citizen groups that vocally protest against phone providers putting up masts for years now (and there are no laws that give providers eminent domain rights or other enforcement tools), and the recent 5g conspiracy theories have made the situation even worse. Ironically the same people then complain why young people leave and no one new moves there.
For the historical part, Heise has a decent chronology (that unfortunately lacks any mention of Eichel or political dumbness): https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/15-Jahre-UMTS-Auktion-Nach-dem-grossen-Kater-2778571.html https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/15-Jahre-UMTS-Auktio...
- tormeh 6y ago>the providers had to take out huge loans and had to re-pay them instead of being able to invest in building out the networks or offer affordable services! What's your alternative? Should the licenses have been given away to some blessed companies? I hardly think you can fault the regulator for holding a proper auction. The failing here was clearly on the companies' part as they overestimated the impact UMTS would have. That the companies then have the audacity to try to get the money back from the government is slightly shocking - "plz socialize these losses lol". The problem is clearly solvable. The government could just pay for the coverage to be built out (payment pending operational towers, obviously).
- mschuster91 6y ago> Should the licenses have been given away to some blessed companies? Yes. Give them away for free, limited for a year and under condition of network buildout, and have interested companies submit business plans. The four with the best business plan win the frequencies. If they don't manage the required buildout, the license gets revoked.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoThis is the correct answer, and again and as usual downvoted on HN. The reason we have shitty coverage is due to gasp economical incentives, who would have thought. Same with DSL btw, but thats another story.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoI find it weird how rarely Germany ends up in British/American media, however how many similar issues they have... But frankly not many people speak of 5G nutcases in Britain either.
- mschuster91 6y ago> I find it weird how rarely Germany ends up in British/American media, however how many similar issues they have... The UK has enough shit to deal with on their own plus the five eyes "close friend" network, no surprise that no one bats an eye for the oddities of German politics. The US is, well, the US. They are so big they don't need to care about anyone else, literally. 40% of Americans haven't ever been outside the US, 11% never been out of their state (https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-5259681/Study-40-Americans-never-left-country.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-5259681/Study-40-...) - so why should they care about us Germans? > But frankly not many people speak of 5G nutcases in Britain either. Interestingly, the UK leads the count for 5g towers set ablaze by far: https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/05/18/deep-conspiracy-roots-europe-wave-cell-tower-fires-264997 https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/05/18/deep-consp...
- stkdump 6y ago> the UK leads the count for 5g towers set ablaze by far I think that was the point.