5 ms·
> In rural or suburban areas, cost and wait times will explode, Utilization of ridesharing in rural areas is low[1]. It's a mode of transportation mostly used
by Barrin92 6y ago
> In rural or suburban areas, cost and wait times will explode,
Utilization of ridesharing in rural areas is low[1]. It's a mode of transportation mostly used by urban affluent individuals with plenty of expendable income and as far as other reasons are concerned internet and credit card access trump any sort of supply problem.
"Suzanne Ashe was once the only Uber driver in Haines, Alaska — population 1,374 — and said she kept getting kicked off the platform because there weren’t enough people asking for rides. She also found that some places weren’t on Uber’s maps, so clients couldn’t enter their destination, and internet could be spotty.
For these reasons, Ashe quit Uber and started her own ride-hailing business called Red Cab, named for her 2010 Red Chevy HHR, the only car in her “company.” She charges a flat rate of $10 per ride and $30 per hour. “In order to cater to rural areas, especially areas where there isn’t a saturation of network, then a cab company makes a lot more sense,” she told Chilkat Valley News."
It seems to have become fashionable to rush to Ubers defense by framing it as some sort of necessary mode of transportation for the undersupplied when instead every piece of data suggests the opposite. It's luxury transportation for the upper middle-class on the back of disenfranchised metropolitan army of reserve labour.
[1]https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2019/1/11/18179036/uber-lyft-rural-areas-subscription-model https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2019/1/11/18179036/uber-lyft-r...
- ghaff 6y agoThat's mostly true. Around where I live, most people own cars and parking isn't an issue. That said, if you don't own a car/can't drive public transit is essentially non-existent with a small regional bus system that is pretty much the option of last result. Uber's probably nice for the people who need to be transported to medical appointments and the like. On the other hand, there were other options including taxis/helpers of various types/family/etc. before Uber came along and the on-demand/convenient nature of Uber isn't as big a deal under those circumstances.
- mehrdadn 6y agoI don't see Uber as class- or luxury-related at all. They have all kinds of customers. Sure they have affluent customers but e.g. college students actively seek each other to split Uber fares too. Many people would prefer to drive instead of taking an Uber, but they do the latter because often there's something preventing them from so (like lack of parking space, or any car to begin with). Are cars luxury upper middle-class commodities now too? And when utilization is high, ride-sharing is arguably more carbon-friendly too. The same affluent folks you're talking about could be driving a car instead of sharing rides with other people if they were left with that option. Even if you think ride-sharing is somehow a sign of affluence (which it very obviously isn't, if you've lived in other countries where entire cities function on hitching rides with strangers every day), you shouldn't want to discourage it and look on people using it with disdain.
- paulgb 6y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. A lot of the Uber/Lyft users I know were (pre-Covid) Uber Pool/Lift Line users. Cramming into a car with strangers that takes 2-3 diversions on the way to your final destination isn't really luxury; it's a stop-gap for when the trip you're making is underserved by transit. For my lifestyle, owning a car would be the "luxury", not ride sharing.
- undersuit 6y agoYou don't think it's a class thing but you only bring up personal vehicles not public transportation. Maybe it's a class thing.
- mehrdadn 6y agoWhat?
- core-questions 6y agoDid someone forget that you can buy a totally functional used car for like $2000, just about anywhere?
- thebradbain 6y ago$2000 is a prohibitively expensive amount for a nontrivial number of people. Not to mention that doesn’t take into account price of gas, parking, maintenance (for which a $2000 car will most likely need more of than a brand new car), registration, insurance... More than 10% of Americans live below the federal poverty line (individual income of <$12k, family of 4 income less than <$26k) https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759512938/u-s-census-bureau-reports-poverty-rate-down-but-millions-still-poor https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759512938/u-s-census-bureau-r...
- rockinghigh 6y ago> It's luxury transportation for the upper middle-class on the back of disenfranchised metropolitan army of reserve labour. People with more money tend to spend more. It's true for ridesharing but also plane tickets, car rentals, restaurants, grocery stores, hotels... All these businesses tend to be staffed with less wealthy employees to serve a wealthier clientele.