2 ms·
> ownership in a cooperative is not alienable In the sense that such ownership is not represented in shares that can be traded on a market, sure. But there is
by pdonis 6y ago
> ownership in a cooperative is not alienable
In the sense that such ownership is not represented in shares that can be traded on a market, sure. But there is nothing to prevent a particular worker from leaving a cooperative, or a new worker from joining one.
> Labor isn't capital, at least not since we abolished slavery
I didn't say labor was capital. I said the skills, training, and knowledge of a worker are capital. Abolishing slavery just means making it illegal for anyone else other than the worker themselves to own that capital.
However, the worker owning that capital is by no means the same as the worker understanding and making use of all of the advantages of that ownership. Most workers don't, which is why most workers find themselves in a poor bargaining position with respect to people who do understand the advantages of ownership of capital.
> We live in a capitalist society.
We live in a society where capitalism is a significant force, yes. But it's not the only one.
> the narrative of labor-capital tension
Is not vacuous, granted, since there are people who believe in it and act on those beliefs.
However, it is, IMO, a highly misleading and pernicious narrative, because it misleads workers into thinking that they don't own any capital themselves, and that their lack of capital ownership--rather than their failure to understand and take advantage of the capital they do own--is what puts them in a poor bargaining position, which then has to be compensated for somehow.