3 ms·
>The current cameras and lenses on the market work very well, that's not the problem. The problem is that even "small" cameras and lenses are huge in comparison
by sudosysgen 6y ago
>The current cameras and lenses on the market work very well, that's not the problem. The problem is that even "small" cameras and lenses are huge in comparison to what can be integrated into a robot. I use a couple M4/3 cinema/studio cameras for vision projects because they're the smallest affordable cameras with controllable interchangeable lenses, and even with their "small" size they are at the upper limit of anything I could hope to fit in a practical robot.
But this is largely because modern lenses are seriously bloated, with IS for older cameras that have non-stabilized sensors, bloated focusing mechanisms to make floating elements work, bloated zooming mechanisms that make everything so much worse, and so on.
If we want to design a lens for robotics, we really don't need much more than a double-gauss normal lens with a unitary focusing mechanism.
One of the lenses I use when I need to kludge something in a project is exactly that, a 1970s Minolta 55 f/1.7 lens for a full-frame image circle. Despite having a large 32mm aperture, it has a diameter of 56mm and a length of 44mm. I don't know if that's too large for your robotics applications, but it isn't very big and it's much smaller than the LiDAR sensors I've worked with. You could likely make this even smaller with modern techniques. It would also cost about 40$ to build.
>The human eye is vastly more complex and capable than a fixed plane imager and capable of much more complex focus behavior than any existing lenses are. Camera-eye comparisons are appealing, but the focus behavior of them is really very different.
My point was moreso that in pure optical sizes, the human eye is bigger and takes up more volume than the optical system I'm proposing. But as far as focusing behaviours, if you were to mathematically model how the human eye gets depth information to drive the focus cycle its quite similar to a phase detection system, with the phase information being extracted through the parallax.
>Canon has done a very nice job with their autofocus, but I will believe they have solved depth perception with phase detection when they apply it to their industrial cameras. Canon makes very nice RV-series parts recognition cameras that do a very good job with challenging materials, but they use structured light. In theory, phase-detection SfF would be perfect for these cameras but they haven't done it.
I think this can be explained quite simply. In a fully controlled environment, using structured light but cheap lenses and small sensors is much more cost-effective. Why would they use expensive APS-C+ sized sensors, that they don't seem to be all that good at making, when you can get away with very cheap parts?
>The minor problem is that you generally want depth plus RGB, which is obviously solved by adding a second camera but then you face basically the same size and overlap issues that stereo cameras bring. Not entirely a free lunch.
But this is precisely the point of OSPDAF or split-pixel phase detection. You get both depth and RGB at the same time, because the RGB sensor doubles as a phase detection sensor. It's not like old cameras where you had to use a mirror that sent light to the dedicated phase detection sensor.
As for political problems, I agree. Canon won't ever sell you their DPAF sensors. Sony, even though they are really bad at robotics, should in theory be willing to sell anyone their sensors, and it should be possible to make a prototype. Their tech in this would be limited relatively to Canon, though.
But, to the point, a solution to a problem that's proprietary is still a solution to the problem.
- cpgxiii 6y agoThere are a number of quite good modern primes that are tiny with big apertures, especially for smaller sensor sizes. Even then, though, lens plus camera is almost always much bigger than the current crop of depth cameras (K4A, Realsense D400, L500, Lucid Helios). Even those cameras is still too big for some applications, that's where PMD's tiny little cameras have a niche. There's always going to be some room for larger, better sensors, but a lot of applications are in need of more sensors to get better coverage, and size is definitely one of the tightest limitation on where they can be applied. I think this can be explained quite simply. In a fully controlled environment, using structured light but cheap lenses and small sensors is much more cost-effective. Why would they use expensive APS-C+ sized sensors, that they don't seem to be all that good at making, when you can get away with very cheap parts? I mean sure, greed is a plenty good explanation of Canon's behavior. The RV-series are pretty big and plenty expensive, so I don't think using better optics would be an issue. Indeed, if single-frame PDAF depth worked out, it would considerably speed up the parts recognition cycle time, which is actually somewhat slow due to the multiple patterns required by the structured light system. The projector and structured light processing work isn't free, either, so it seems like depth they got for free would be better in every way. Dual Pixel AF II, at least in marketing speak for OSPDAF, has been around for longer than the RV-series, so I can't help but have doubts about the actual practical applicability of PDAF SfF. But this is precisely the point of OSPDAF or split-pixel phase detection. You get both depth and RGB at the same time, because the RGB sensor doubles as a phase detection sensor. Yes, that's true, but the problem of making a good RGBD camera is that you generally want a deeper depth of field in RGB so as much of the image is in focus as possible, while maximizing PDAF SfF depth quality requires as shallow a depth of field as possible. It's not impossible to solve this, but the fundamental optical features you want out of the depth part are the opposite of the features you need from the RGB part. You could address this by changing aperture between each depth/RGB capture, although you'd definitely have to use an electromagnetic aperture to avoid lifetime issues. You'd still end up with a slower framerate taking successive depth/RGB frames, but that's doable for many applications.