3 ms·
The CXX Debate
- cratermoon 6y ago"we know that we can pass any u32 to this function, and it's safe" What happens if you pass in 0xFFFFFFFF?
- steveklabnik 6y agoThis is a great point; I was thinking purely of Rust's semantics, where this is safe, and ends up turning into a panic or a zero. I'll add something here, thank you. EDIT: wait, since this is unsigned, it is the same semantics as Rust. Well, it wraps no matter the optimization level, but it's not UB.
- cratermoon 6y agoI haven't quite wrapped my head around Rust but I know that anything that moves the possibility of UB towards 0 is a godsend. Just ask the folks at ESA who worked on the first Ariane 5 launch.
- steveklabnik 6y agoRust's semantics are: * in debug builds, you get a panic on overflow * otherwise, you may choose to panic, but if you do not, it is two's compliment wrapping It is defined this way so that someday if checks get cheap enough we can enable them in release builds too, but at least it's not UB!