3 ms·
I grew up on message boards. In fact, my first experiences with a computer were with message boards. If there's one thing that I dislike about nested comments,
by keiferski 16y ago
I grew up on message boards. In fact, my first experiences with a computer were with message boards.
If there's one thing that I dislike about nested comments, it's that they make the community seem less cohesive. When everyone is commenting in a linear fashion on (roughly) the same topics, it makes for a tighter community. Nested comments, while better organized, just seem like a bunch of people having separate conversations.
Message boards are like a group assembly. One person talks at a time, and everyone listens. Nested comments are like a crowd of people having individual conversations about the guy that just talked.
- jokermatt999 16y agoI think that's a good thing, for larger communities. Threads become unreadable once they're over a certain size, at least with linear comments. With nested comments, you can digest part of a topic and still participate. Also, I think the "fragmented community" also has its advantages. The community can different aspects of the article at the same time, so parts don't get ignored. While one person may want to mention they love the design on the site, another has a minor nitpick, and a third guy has a comment on similar articles, they can all say their piece without dragging the entire discussion off topic. However, I do agree with what you said about everyone being heard and the benefit of a cohesive discussion. The recent topic this really comes to mind for is the one about "How to stop HN's decline". There were a number of good ideas, but they were also repeated numerously, and the same counter points were made. If there was a single linear thread for that topic, while the size would be unwieldy, I think the same points would have been made less.
- keiferski 16y agoPerhaps the question then becomes: how do we make a large community function like a small one? One idea: for every new "comment" on a story (that isn't a response) create a new instance of the story on the news feed. Example: I comment on this story, and you reply. [Newer online forums are worse at conversation] "I grew up on message boards. In fact, my ..." by keiferski | 2 comments Rinse/repeat for every new comment on the story. It would lead to more instances of the same story on the news feed, but would also lead to more in-depth comments. Of course, it would be very easy to organize (and hide) long lists of comments.
- jerf 16y ago"Nested comments, while better organized, just seem like a bunch of people having separate conversations." Why "just"? What's wrong with that? Who says our goal is for online discussions to precisely mimic only that one form of conversation the physically world and constraints of human cognition permit? You and the original article seem to accept this as an unspoken assumption of how to rank conversation quality. I don't. The right way to do digital things is rarely "Exactly like the analog case, but with computers." (See also: newspapers, education.)