4 ms·
Police are not agents of capital. They are agents of the government and nothing more. Police make a modest government salary and do not (at least in the US) hav
by kortilla 6y ago
Police are not agents of capital. They are agents of the government and nothing more. Police make a modest government salary and do not (at least in the US) have a history of reacting well to bribes.
Police meet out punishment all of the time to capitalists (a.k.a people with retirement accounts and savings accounts). I’m not sure why you think otherwise.
- tsimionescu 6y agoAnd since government has always sided with capital against labor, it usually amounts to police serving capital, at least in matters of capital VS labor. Remember that the US has a history of using police and even armed forces to crush unions and strikes.
- kortilla 6y agoThe government does not side with capital. If it did, we wouldn’t have unions at all, minimum wage, etc. Standard Oil would still be dominating and AT&T would never have been broken up. To say the government serves capital, even in the US, is laughably wrong. Look at the mandate of the Federal Reserve, it’s literally designed for maximum employment. The government serves those in power, many of whom are rich. Being rich is not enough to have the government serve you though.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe fact that it's not 100% dedicated to capital's desires does not mean that it doesn't essentially serve it. Sure, if it were a purely capitalist state, we'd all be slaves, bought and sold by corporations, and we're not there of course. But in monetary policy, employee benefits, tax breaks, environmental protection, social securityand virtually any other domain you care to name, government cares about the interests of capital first, and everyone else only a distant second.
- kortilla 6y agoSo you admit it’s not dedicated to capital’s desires. Therefore the police are not there to serve capital, it’s that simple. They are agents of the government and whatever its interests are, which is serving those in power. More refutations of how these are not in the interests of capital. Monetary policy does not serve capital (see employment mandate). Environmental protection does not serve capital (see the very establishment of the EPA). Social security does not serve capital (it’s an unfunded liability that will need funding through further taxation or inflation). The covid bailouts and current policies are destructive to capital. (Real negative interest rates are destroying capital)
- praptak 6y agoThis is merely a technical nitpick. A person with a savings account is technically a capitalist but they typically get most of their income from labor. Their interests are not those of the capital, e.g. they would lose from stricter anti-labour regulations.
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s not a nitpick. Anyone with social security, 401ks, etc are all depending on capital markets to retire. > Their interests are not those of the capital, e.g. they would lose from stricter anti-labour regulations. This is incorrect. They would only lose if they were part of the effected labor pool. Break up the California teachers union and pretty much everyone in California except for the teachers will benefit. Tax revenue shortfalls mean worse services and/or higher taxes for everyone else to pay for fat retirements for incompetent teachers.