7 ms·
Looking at all the comments here I have a single response to most of them: I'll call it a solution when it is implemented. You can talk all you want about solut
by godelski 6y ago
Looking at all the comments here I have a single response to most of them: I'll call it a solution when it is implemented. You can talk all you want about solutions to some of the (minor) problems addressed here (ignoring the rest of the problems) but unless it is in use then the article's commentary still stands. Unless it has a ton of users, the article's commentary still stands. If you really do believe in block chain, prove us all wrong and implement the changes.
- malikNF 6y agoTake a look at cardano. They have implemented a blockchain that is backed by peer reviewed [1] research, the article here talks about how the blockchain takes a huge amount of resources to run. The people at the cardano project has managed to enable people to even run a full block producing node on something as small as a pi[2][3]. So far from all the blockchain projects I am interested in, this is my favorite one so far. If you got a few hours of free time you should really check out this project out.[4] Disclaimer I am a cardano(ada) holder and I actively take part in this project as a pool operator. [1]https://iohk.io/en/research/library/ https://iohk.io/en/research/library/ [2]https://twitter.com/BetterStake/status/1296217244217868289 https://twitter.com/BetterStake/status/1296217244217868289 [3]https://twitter.com/search?q=cardano%20Raspberry&src=typed_query https://twitter.com/search?q=cardano%20Raspberry&src=typed_q... [4]https://github.com/input-output-hk https://github.com/input-output-hk
- fourstar 6y agoWhy is being peer-reviewed what Cardano fans always lede with? That doesn’t automatically make something “better”, IMO. Also, what even uses Cardano? Project has been “in progress” for years and all I’ve seen are photos of Hoskinson with his mouth open taking selfies in various parts of the world. Algorand is probably the best project right now in crypto aside from ZCash that’s an actual contender against ETH (disclaimer: I hold none of either).
- fossuser 6y agoZcash had this which wasn't great: https://bitcoinist.com/zcash-inflation-bug-infinite-tokens/ https://bitcoinist.com/zcash-inflation-bug-infinite-tokens/ You also only get privacy with transactions between two z-addresses, and those require a fair amount of resources to generate (I think HW wallets can't sign those transactions due to computational limitations). Most zcash transactions are between t-addresses which don't have any benefits over BTC (they're public). https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/49115/whats-the-difference-between-z-addr-and-t-addr-type-addresses https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/49115/whats-the-... As far as cardano, I'm skeptical of proof-of-stake compared to proof-of-work (though I might just not understand it fully). Proof-of-work seems like the main BTC innovation against abuse and a lot of the coins that use stake (stellar lumens, tezos) seem like they drop the defining characteristic of BTC decentralization in order to get faster transactions. Without proof of work you don't really get true decentralized protection from the system itself, you have to put trust somewhere. At least the tezos putting coins at risk approach is interesting. The cardano website also really sets off my bullshit alarms: https://cardano.org/ https://cardano.org/
- dlubarov 6y ago> You also only get privacy with transactions between two z-addresses, and those require a fair amount of resources to generate FWIW this is rapidly improving. The main thing we need to implement Zcash-style private payments is a Merkle proof in a zk-SNARK, so that we can prove ownership of an account in the Merkle tree without revealing the account. So the proving cost depends heavily on our choice of hash function. Since most SNARKs operate over large finite fields, traditional bit-oriented hashes are a poor fit, but the designers originally went with SHA-256 anyway to be on the safe side. More recent versions of the Zcash circuit use Pedersen hashes, which are much cheaper and still provably collision-resistant (assuming discrete log hardness). Future versions will probably use more specialized hashes designed to minimize field operations, like Rescue [1]. There's also the idea of using an embedded GKR protocol to verify gMIMC hashes with a very low incremental cost [2], although it might be overkill for Zcash-style circuits. [1] https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/426 https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/426 [2] https://hackmd.io/@uCHu_NMSQ4mIUvA8i4qAyg/rkxBcmvcI https://hackmd.io/@uCHu_NMSQ4mIUvA8i4qAyg/rkxBcmvcI
- dehrmann 6y agoBlockchain is a solution in search of a problem.
- sliken 6y agoFrom what I can tell it's a solution in search of funding. The problem is something they will fix later, often by pivoting away from the blockchain.
- robjan 6y agoWe've already had billions of dollars worth of ICOs. How much more money is needed?
- tim333 6y agoIt was invented as a solution to the problem of making bitcoin and was good for that. Then people saw bitcoin made money so thought if you stick blockchain on something else maybe some of the money dust will rub off. Less good.
- xtracto 6y agoHistorically, bitcoin was inspired by the 2008 crash. Same crash that inspired the 1% matches in the US and other movements over the world. Because of the centralization of wealth and power. Once the next major depression comes in, a form of cryptocurrencies will gain traction again. People are fed up with big banks and centralized power.
- tim333 6y agoI think you may find the inspiration predates 2008 a fair bit. For instance there was the similar bitgold in 1998 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Szabo#Bit_gold https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Szabo#Bit_gold
- andreskytt 6y agoNumber mobility between Indian telecoms runs on private blockchain. AFAIK it is live and actively used. BC solves a problem there because operating a database for that scale would be very complicated. So every telco has their own copy that get synced via a consensus mechanism and signed transactions
- joosters 6y agoYou know that a private, or permissioned, blockchain is pointless, right? If some entity controls the blockchain, you might as well just use a standard database.
- ric2b 6y agoIt's not pointless, it's just yet another way "noSQL" database. It certainly doesn't give you the same benefits of a public blockchain. But if the code is already written, meets the project requirements and is easy to deploy, why not?
- kls 6y agoBecause it is a really inefficient way to store what amounts to an immutable ledger in a traditional database. While I don't agree with a lot of the consensus that blockchain is completely useless. I pretty much agree that it is useless if it is owned by a private entity. That was one of the main points of the blockchain, how can we create a public datastore that is not owned by anyone and it tamperproof. I see public blockchain as valuable to freedoms in a libertarian sense but see no value in companies adopting the core blockchain techs. Tooling around public blockchains sure or API's available on things like D'APPS make sense, but private ledgers make absolutely no sense to me. Just use a traditional database and implement all the data storage as a ledger pattern and you get the same effect with out all the energy consumption.
- ric2b 6y agoAFAIK private blockchains usually don't rely on proof of work so there's no large energy usage. I agree that if they're private they're equivalent to a customized database system, private blockchains aren't interesting but it doesn't make them useless, it's simply another way to solve problems that could already be solved before.
- ahdeanz 6y agoThe shifting goalposts of this argument have been interesting to watch over the last 3-4 years. Stablecoins: I remember plenty of commenters being quite certain that volatility made cryptocurrency unusable. And yet a short time later we have successful decentralized stable coins. DeFi: Just in the past months Uniswap has rivaled centralized exchange volume as a decentralized exchange. It's permissionless composability appears to be spinning off an interesting group of experimental financial instruments. These are a couple huge concrete examples of successes that make the ~show me something real~ argument difficult for me to accept. Nobody has built skyscrapers yet, but skyscrapers aren't built in a day. We have some pretty solid architecture going up it seems. And if you've been following the space long enough most of this article is tedious and inconsequential: 1) "For instance, hundreds of links to child pornography and revenge porn were placed in the bitcoin blockchain by malicious users." This is a tired argument from 2013 which nobody cares about: https://www.wired.com/story/why-porn-on-the-blockchain-wont-doom-bitcoin/ https://www.wired.com/story/why-porn-on-the-blockchain-wont-... 2) "Also, in a blockchain you aren’t anonymous, but “pseudonymous”: your identity is linked to a number, and if someone can link your name to that number, you’re screwed. Everything you got up to on that blockchain is visible to everyone." Blockchains have many different properties. Some have more stringent privacy measures than others. Many HN readers are likely familiar with privacy coins employing things like zero-knowledge proofs or ring signatures. Not to mention the burgeoning research into the implementations of homomorphic encryption. How about Harvard putting your genome on the blockchain in such a way where you retain full control over it's rights? Doesn't sound completely useless to me: https://nebula.org/whole-genome-sequencing/ https://nebula.org/whole-genome-sequencing/ 3) "The fact that no one is in charge and nothing can be modified also means that mistakes cannot be corrected. A bank can reverse a payment request. This is impossible for bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. So anything that has been stolen will stay stolen." First of all huge amounts of digital theft occurs today that goes unreversed. Also infrastructure reducing errors in cryptocurrency is being improved all the time. Transaction finality has cons but also pros and can be modified. And one can also imagine insurance for these types of losses becoming commonplace. 4) "And then there’s the environmental problem." This is probably the most legitimate concern so far. All I can say is I hope we get serious about investing in clean energy production as a country/globe. Many things use energy, including cryptocurrency, and that isn't stopping anytime soon whether we like it or not. 5) His complaint that a specific project is not using the blockchain correctly and individuals couldn't explain the blockchain well isn't very convincing. Of course lots of experimentation will fail. Pets.com didn't make the internet wrong. And even the experts have trouble describing possibilities that don't exist yet. If that isn't reminiscent of the early days of the internet then I don't know what is. If you've seen Bill Gates get mocked by Letterman while trying to describe the early internet then you understand this difficulty. It's worth remembering that this area is still incredibly young. If you can't at least see the potential then maybe you aren't looking in the right places. Like here: https://a16z.com/2018/02/10/crypto-readings-resources/ https://a16z.com/2018/02/10/crypto-readings-resources/