5 ms·
> If a union is a cartel because its members bargain collectively, so is a corporation. If you want to keep corporations because of the organizational efficienc
by pdonis 6y ago
> If a union is a cartel because its members bargain collectively, so is a corporation. If you want to keep corporations because of the organizational efficiencies that maximize productivity and welfare, then why not unions?
If a union wants the benefits of being a corporation, it should be a corporation. In other words, it should put its money where its mouth is and become a business, selling the service of organized labor in a competitive market. If unions really do know better how to organize labor, how to make sure workers are treated fairly, etc., etc., then they should prove it by making organized labor itself a profitable business.
- wahern 6y agoA corporation is principally designed for passive investment of capital, making it easy to put capital to work as well as easy to take it back and put it to work elsewhere. And because the investor can be passive, that means he can invest in many different ventures at once, which is especially useful in a society where a small number of people have far more assets than they have time to personally manage. The motivation is that by making the deployment of capital more efficient, not only does the capitalist enjoy a higher return than he otherwise would (if he didn't he wouldn't bother, afterall), but it's hypothesized that everybody is made wealthier than they otherwise would be. A corporation doesn't provide such reduced friction for labor. A vehicle designed to make it easier for people to pool and bargain their labor requires a different structure. Labor is an intrinsically different kind of asset than money. In order to provide symmetry in how easy it is to collectively bargain labor as compared to collectively bargain capital, you need a legal vehicle tailored to the characteristics of the asset. That's the answer to the rhetorical question I said I'd pose if anybody wanted to play semantic word games. A "corporation" is not a universal, platonic construct for promoting socially beneficial cooperative behavior. Whether we should want to provide symmetry at all is a different question, an empirical question (is everybody better off on average if labor can organize as efficiently as capital?), not one we can answer based on abstract principles, which is what was implied by characterizing unions as cartels.
- pdonis 6y ago> A corporation is principally designed for passive investment of capital One particular type of corporation is, yes--the type that sells stock to passive investors. But that is not the only type of corporation. See below. > A corporation doesn't provide such reduced friction for labor. What you are calling "labor" is in fact a mixture of actual labor--meaning time that can potentially be devoted to productive work--and capital--the skills, training, and knowledge of the people doing the productive work. For most unionized workers, even the ones that are called "unskilled", most of their wages are actually return on capital. So even by your own logic, a corporation, in the narrow sense you are using the term (something that sells stock to passive investors), should be a fine vehicle for efficiently making use of this capital. However, you seem to have missed the fact that what I was describing--a "union" that was actually a corporation, selling the service of organized labor in a competitive market--is not just theoretical; such entities actually exist. They are usually called "worker cooperatives" or something like that, not "corporations", but that's just a matter of choice of words. The point is that they are a way for workers to organize collectively to properly capture the value that is inherent in their ownership of their own skills, training, and knowledge as capital, by having joint collective ownership of a legal entity that provides that capital as a service. In other words, a corporation, in the general sense of that term--a legal entity jointly owned by multiple people. > Labor is an intrinsically different kind of asset than money. Capital is not the same thing as money. And, as above, what you are calling "labor" is in fact mostly capital--just not capital that exists in tangible form as money. It is true that actual labor--a worker's time--is an intrinsically different kind of asset, not just than money, but than any other kind of asset. But a properly organized corporation owned by workers, selling their services in a competitive market, takes care of that asset too, because such a corporation does not sell the workers' time, it sells services, and it prices those services based on their value to the buyer, not how much time it takes its workers to perform them. And that is a much better way to ensure fair treatment of the workers than what labor unions currently do: allowing employers to treat workers as fungible commodities, hours of labor, and then trying to bargain about specifics of how the commodities are handled. > That's the answer to the rhetorical question I said I'd pose if anybody wanted to play semantic word games. It seems to me that you are the one playing semantic word games, not me.