3 ms·
>Straw man. Power is always several amongst elites. The question is one of degree and checks. Xi’s China has no rule of law. In America, no person nor public se
by sudosysgen 6y ago
>Straw man. Power is always several amongst elites. The question is one of degree and checks. Xi’s China has no rule of law. In America, no person nor public servant is reliably above the law.
> Moreover, rulers can be challenged in fair courts. The U.S. government loses in court. Xi never loses in a CCP court.
>>>>>>>>>>>>one person doesn't have total power means nothing
>>>>>>>>>>Straw man
>>>>>>>>>>no person or public servant is reliably above the law
First, I don't think you can call my argument a straw man then restate the argument I was arguing in the very same sentence.
Second, Xi Jinping can easily lose in a CCP court, he just has to go against the will of the party members of the CCP enough. Xi Jinping is below the Politburo as well as the National People's Congress. He simply is kindly advised not to act in ways that would lead to his removal, just as other Chinese presidents often had their hands tied. He is not reliably above the law.
Also, the Department of Justice in the US de facto affirmed that the US president is above federal law.
> Moreover, rulers can be challenged in fair courts. The U.S. government loses in court. Xi never loses in a CCP court.
This absurd conflation. Xi <=!=> the US government. An apt comparison is to claim that the Chinese State never loses in court.
Now, to the core of the claim, the US State cannot lose in courts, because the US State is the courts.
More so, the US government can only ever, ever be sued with its agreement. Indeed, as Wikipedia puts it:
>In the United States, the federal government has sovereign immunity and may not be sued unless it has waived its immunity or consented to suit.[7] The United States as a sovereign is immune from suit unless it unequivocally consents to being sued.[8] The United States Supreme Court in Price v. United States observed: "It is an axiom of our jurisprudence. The government is not liable to suit unless it consents thereto, and its liability in suit cannot be extended beyond the plain language of the statute authorizing it."[9]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...
In conclusion, the U.S. government only ever loses to a non-state entity in court when it consents to, and even then liability is severely restrained.
This is, ironically, exactly the same standard as in China. The Chinese Basic Law forbids the state from legal liability unless it specifically agrees to it and states it's liability, which is stated under the Administative Litigation Law : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_law_in_China#Administrative_litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_law_in_China#Ad...
In practice, this means that you can sue the Chinese State, the CCP, Xi Jinping, or any other administrative body in China, and win, as long as the Chinese State agrees to the litigation. So, yes, Xi Jinping's government can, and does lose in Chinese courts (which technically are not affiliated with the CCP or any party, in theory). In fact, there have been many cases of such loses, which can be easily googled.
However, if the government ever loses, both in China and the US!, under the doctrine of Sovereign Immunity, they can simply change the law and absolve themselves of liability.
>Judges are not loyal to their parties. Almost every nominee has prominent cases where they rule against their party (e.g. Gorsuch on gay rights).
Cases of Federal judges ruling against their parties are few and far between, judges nominated by the same party vote together the vast majority of the time, especially Republican judges. As for the cases where they do, they almost always differ on points of heterogeneity in their party. Which you'd be surprised to hear, is also the case in China - there is massive heterogeneity within the party and judges sometimes go against the dominant position and are protected because are amongst a large faction.
In conclusion, there is still no real difference that can discerned.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> the Department of Justice in the US de facto affirmed that the US president is above federal law Incorrect. DoJ have an administrative rule that a sitting President cannot be charged by them. As for official acts by the government, they’re subject to judicial review. No analogous process exists in China. > the US State cannot lose in courts, because the US State is the courts This betrays ignorance of the American Constitutional system. The U.S. government routinely loses in court. Prior rulings are overturned. The legislature is checked. The President stayed. > under the doctrine of Sovereign Immunity Sovereign immunity is a courtesy granted to other nations under common law. It does not exist per se and makes no sense to be invoked with respect to a state without the rule of law. With respect to American courts, the U.S. government has broadly consented to being sued by virtue of the Constitution. To claim sovereign immunity, a creature of the law, limits the legal system is to misunderstand one of the basic tenets of the system.
- sudosysgen 6y ago>Incorrect. DoJ have an administrative rule that a sitting President cannot be charged by them. As for official acts by the government, they’re subject to judicial review. No analogous process exists in China. Judicial review is simply enforcement of laws that are found to have primacy. Chinese retired officials have been charged, found guilty, and found liable hundreds of times. As for the analogous process of "judicial review" in China, it's called... Judicial Review. It has many flaws in practice due to partisanship of the judges, they are all also present in the US. The procedure for Chinese judicial review is codified under the Administrative Procedure Law I mentioned in my previous comment. The main difference is that Chinese judicial review applies only to acts and not to laws, because the Chinese constitution mandates primacy of the National People's Congress, therefore any power to strike laws would ironically enough be unconstitutional. Moreover, former officials frequently get sued in China for crimes performed during their tenure. >This betrays ignorance of the American Constitutional system. The U.S. government routinely loses in court. Prior rulings are overturned. The legislature is checked. The President stayed. The legislative is checked, but not the State. I don't understand why you keep confusing the U.S. Government sometimes with the US legislative branch and sometimes with the US executive branch. Courts are part of the State. This should be evident after an analysis of the US Constitution, not just a cursory reading, and is indeed the interpretation taken by the Supreme Court as well as the basis for Sovereign immunity. See the last paragraph pf the next quotation of ever-helpful Wikipedia. >Sovereign immunity is a courtesy granted to other nations under common law. It does not exist per se Incorrect : In the United States, the federal government has sovereign immunity and may not be sued unless it has waived its immunity or consented to suit.[7] The United States as a sovereign is immune from suit unless it unequivocally consents to being sued.[8] The United States Supreme Court in Price v. United States observed: "It is an axiom of our jurisprudence. The government is not liable to suit unless it consents thereto, and its liability in suit cannot be extended beyond the plain language of the statute authorizing it."[9] The principle was not mentioned in the original United States Constitution. The courts have recognized it both as a principle that was inherited from English common law, and as a practical, logical inference (that the government cannot be compelled by the courts because it is the power of the government that creates the courts in the first place).[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit... You seem to be confusing Sovereign Immunity, which only applies to the Federal and Local governments of the United States, with State Immunity, which is much weaker than Sovereign Immunity : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_immunity > makes no sense to be invoked with respect to a state without the rule of law This is a circular argument as it the conclusion is also a premise. >With respect to American courts, the U.S. government has broadly consented to being sued by virtue of the Constitution. To claim sovereign immunity, a creature of the law, limits the legal system is to misunderstand one of the basic tenets of the system. Incorrect. See, The Eleventh Amendment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eleventh_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eleventh_Amendment_to_the_Unit...