4 ms·
Police are agents of the state and the state serves nothing but itself.
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Police are agents of the state and the state serves nothing but itself.
- _nalply 6y agoThe state serves entities in power, not itself. To give an example: In Switzerland being a direct democracy many people would say that the state serves the people who vote, but I know someone who says that Switzerland is in reality a plutocracy, so in this case the state would serve the one percent.
- bobthechef 6y agoWell, there’s whom the state is supposed to serve and there’s whom they actually do serve. Any state that serves anything but the common good is a tyranny by definition. The US and most countries are globalist oligarchies and so you might say that the state is serving capital in our day and age. However, there is variation in the degree of oligarchic capture of the state and while it is good to reduce this capture, I am not sure I can name a single state in history that wasn’t a tyranny to one degree of another in practice (again, matters of degree). A good way of limiting the totalizing control of oligarchs is through a subsidiarian dispersal of political power. But direct democracy and mob rule are perhaps the worst options. It’s also an illusion because the mob is always just an instrument of power (communists for example mobilized the mobs by whipping jealousy). I think the best attitude is one which presumes that corruption is an inevitable and endemic feature of all human societies and that while we can deal with some or much of it in small ways as these things occur, there is no solution. The belief in a solution ultimately leads to far worse things. Don’t immanentize the eschaton.
- monadic2 6y agoEvidently not.
- riffic 6y agoThis is such an unenlightened comment, in an era where money buys political power (Lessig's "economy of influence" might be worth looking into).
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe state will about face and serve the people the nanosecond they start looking like they're gonna become a serious problem for the stability of the state. The reason money buys power is because the people are divided or don't care. Money only wins when all else is equal.