2 ms·
Typical "Apple is against freedom" linkbait from someone drenched in the Windows ecosystem. That being said... Lots of links on the web are to other applicatio
by raganwald 18y ago
Typical "Apple is against freedom" linkbait from someone drenched in the Windows ecosystem. That being said...
Lots of links on the web are to other applications.
like links to flash, pdf, office documents, .dmg disk images to download, files to ftp, ...
The iTunes Music/Movie/Application store is just an egregious example of this because it renders a lot of stuff that looks like it could be rendered in a browser, which is why they use a browser under the hood.
But we could make the same argument about PDF, and the defenders would say that PDF can render things with a UI and a rendering model that surpasses HTML in fidelity, and that its users need that.
And that's the reason iTMS isn't a web site. Apple wants an interaction model that is difficult to render with fidelity in browsers.
We can make something almost as good in a browser, but almost as good isn't what Apple does. It's what Microsoft does, and that's why people for whom Windows is good enough don't understand why iTMS isn't a web site.
- Tichy 18y agoThe annoyance is not that "Apple is against freedom", it is that I can not check what is on offer at the store right now. At home I'd have to boot my gaming PC so that I can take a peek at the store (lucky I still have a gaming PC instead of a console). It is simply not user friendly. But I know, Apple is making money with it, so whatever...
- raganwald 18y agoI sympathize with you greatly, and you'll notice that on my own blog I promote Amazon books and music. But you and Jeff are saying very different things: You said iTMS is annoying because you have a use-case it does not support, whereas he said Apple is Anti-Web because they employ a technique--web links to a proprietary desktop application--that supports a different use case. I think I can agree with you while disagreeing with the way he frames his argument.
- Tichy 18y agoOK, let's agree ;-)