4 ms·
Using the 5700XT with amdgpu has been a complete shit show since day one, and you have success depending on your set-up since QA appears to be "if it works on a
by mixedCase 6y ago
Using the 5700XT with amdgpu has been a complete shit show since day one, and you have success depending on your set-up since QA appears to be "if it works on a dev's machine ship it".
Mainline (let alone stable kernels) was almost unusable for like 4-5 months after release, you were completely out of luck unless you followed the right incantations and used a precise firmware binary that had been available at some point at an AMD developer's personal repo but you later had to get through someone else's Dropbox. After that period it got stable-ish for me. Occasionally Mesa/kernel updates made some games stop working or freeze the system but workarounds. Yesterday I swapped a monitor for a higher res one, and I triggered a bug where DPM essentially shits its pants and you have to switch to manual power management. Meaning a year after release the card can't handle basic multi-monitor stuff.
I've had AMD CPUs exclusively ever since Athlon II, always coupled with Nvidia cards. I wanted to support them also in GPUs given their open source work but for me it's been a complete mess. If Intel GPUs are actually any good and don't shit the bed I'll sell this card for whatever I can get.
- vondur 6y agoI've been making sure to run the latest kernels and latest mesa Mesa, and my 5700xt has been great. But, I agree that the 5700 series had some serious issues in its original kernel releases.
- 1_player 6y agoYou don't believe him? https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/929 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/929 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/892 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/892 I built a PC in June and bought a 5500XT and it's bloody unusable. It hangs if I plug a monitor, it hangs randomly, it hangs when idle, it's not a hardware defect since Windows is fine with it. Sorry but the Linux community has been bashing NVIDIA and praising AMD because "opensource" while there are critical bugs like that one that have been open for a year. It makes my blood boil. My opensource friendly 5500XT is on a shelf and I'm using an NVIDIA card in its place. And you better believe I will not be giving AMD my custom again.