3 ms·
There's a big difference. I'm surprised you don't see it. If a billionaire donates a new building to a college so his dim-witted son can get in, the entire sch
by fortran77 6y ago
There's a big difference. I'm surprised you don't see it.
If a billionaire donates a new building to a college so his dim-witted son can get in, the entire school benefits because they have a new facility. And the school can see to it that nobody gets "displaced" by this dim-witted kid by increasing the class size by 1.
If a wealthy person bribes and athletic coach to get his kid into school, the school gets no money and no benefit, and someone else was actually displaced.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> If a billionaire donates a new building to a college so his dim-witted son can get in, It’s not a donation if they’re getting something in return.
- simonh 6y agoThat’s maybe fair, but just a matter of semantics. It doesn’t change the fact that a $10m endowment can generate enough income to support a handful of full cost academic scholarships in perpetuity. Anyone not seeing the difference between that and a sports coach pocketing a few tens of thousands of dollars is suffering from severe ideological impairment.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt’s not semantics when erroneous terminology nets someone a few million in tax deductions. A donation is eligible for tax deductions. Payment in lieu of acceptance for child or increased probability of acceptance for child is not tax deductible. A sports coach pocketing a few thousand dollars, versus a much wealthier person pocketing a few million from all taxpayers. Where is the ideological impairment?
- dev_tty01 6y agoHmm, I think you have some wrong ideas about our tax system. A tax deduction doesn't make it free money. First, you are giving up $10 million to the school. The tax deduction gets you about $3 million (more or less) in tax savings. The donor still gave up a net of $7 million and the school and students still get tremendous benefit. (The precise amounts will vary with tax rates and state, but the point is that a huge portion of the donation is still out of pocket.) The wealthy person is not "pocketing" anything.
- fortran77 6y agoAsk someone who knows how taxes work what a 'tax deduction' is. You'll be surprised!
- lotsofpulp 6y agoPerhaps you could elucidate me as to how money given to a school to secure a spot for your child should reduce your taxable income by fraudulently categorizing it as a donation. I’m pretty sure if I start deducting expenses from my taxable income that aren’t deductible, I would be accused of tax evasion and therefore stealing from all other taxpayers.
- spaced-out 6y agoIf college admission slots are going to be up for sale, colleges need to be honest about it and post the prices. We have no way of knowing if the rich kid is displacing someone more deserving or not.