4 ms·
I find it really surprising that Apple didn't grant the request given the potential outcome, if Apple loses (however unlikely), ranges from Apple's app store fe
by onion2k 6y ago
I find it really surprising that Apple didn't grant the request given the potential outcome, if Apple loses (however unlikely), ranges from Apple's app store fees being capped to Apple losing their store monopoly to even Apple being broken up. Shareholders are going to be coming after Tim Cook with torches and pitchforks if he could have easily avoided that simply by giving Epic special treatment.
- xibalba 6y agoSpecial treatment may have exposed Apple to even worse antitrust liability. It is clear from their messaging that it is critical that they maintain the appearance of treating all developers the same. Tim Cook heavily emphasized this point in his recent Congressional testimony.
- scarface74 6y agoEvery company makes deals with other companies. It’s called business. It amazes me how many lawyers are on HN.
- anoncake 6y agoTIL when I buy groceries no business happens.
- scarface74 6y agoSo you’re saying that businesses don’t make special deals with other large businesses? I bet you also think that Beyoncé and Taylor Swift get the same record deals as the random up and comer a label found singing at the bar.
- anoncake 6y agoNo, you're saying a business that treats everyone equally is a charity.
- microtherion 6y agoI disagree. If Apple were to give in to everybody who declared "we've broken our developer agreement, I can haz side letter?", the flood gates would open pretty quickly. It's one thing to negotiate for preferred treatment, but unilaterally breaking the agreement as an opening move? This aggression will not stand, man. There are, theoretically, the risks you mention, but (and that may be my stock portfolio talking), I don't see it as particularly likely that Epic will win, especially since they've chosen to take Apple and Google on at the same time.
- temac 6y ago> It's one thing to negotiate for preferred treatment, but unilaterally breaking the agreement as an opening move? This aggression will not stand, man. If I understand correctly, I think you are getting the timeline wrong. Unless you don't count prior contact attempts as an "opening move".
- microtherion 6y agoAh, true, I was under the mistaken impression that the letter was sent the day Epic broke their agreement, when in fact it was sent several weeks earlier. Still, this was a unilateral breech of the agreement.
- moogly 6y agoHow I see it, breaching the agreement was really the only way to move forward. Apple is famously good at stonewalling.
- scarface74 6y agoSo when has the government ever told a private company they had to cap fees unless the company was a regulated natural monopoly like a utility company?
- onion2k 6y agoIt happens directly quite often, but it happens indirectly a lot more. Every time the government mandates a company does something simple like improving safety they're essentially telling businesses "make less profit by spending more on this thing instead." All regulation is profit capping (in a good way in my opinion, but plenty of people would argue its a bad thing for the government to do). It would be entirely within the government's regulatory remit to tell Apple (and other companies) that consumers must be allowed to choose which app store they want to use with their devices and Apple would have to make it happen else face significant fines. That's the risk that Apple are taking by not making a deal with Epic.
- scarface74 6y agoOr the business raises costs to pass it on to consumers. The government in that case raises the floor - not lowers the ceiling. If all companies in an industry have to follow the same laws, they all can pass the costs to consumers. It would be entirely within the government's regulatory remit to tell Apple (and other companies) So the government is now going to tell private companies how to design their products? Can you imagine having to have multiple “stores” on a $35 Roku? Should the Samsung smart TV have multiple stores? Nintendo Switch? When has the government ever passed a law with regards to technology that gave consumers more choice? DMCA? SOPA? All of the great laws regarding net neutrality? The government trying to pass laws to make encryption that they can’t bypass illegal? Rulings against municipal broadband? But this time the government is capable of regulating tech.
- graeme 6y agoThe request was that Apple dismantle its app store and security model and allow 3rd party app stores and sideloading. This is in point two of Epic’s email. It would be a completely radical shift. Google declined as well. See letter here. The demands were much more than separate in app payment. https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/1296918541627793411 https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/129691854162779341...