10 ms·
I would buy a discrete GPU from Intel without seeing any benchmarks. The only system I own in which desktop compositing actually works on Linux is the Intel on
by aidenn0 6y ago
I would buy a discrete GPU from Intel without seeing any benchmarks. The only system I own in which desktop compositing actually works on Linux is the Intel one.
Both AMD and Nvidia drivers are dumpster fires in terms of stability (and for Nvidia, I've tried both nouveau and the binary drivers)
- pengaru 6y ago> Both AMD and Nvidia drivers are dumpster fires in terms of stability (and for Nvidia, I've tried both nouveau and the binary drivers) I've had great experience with the mainline amdgpu driver, and find it ridiculous to group AMD and nvidia together in this context today. With amdgpu AMD has moved much closer to intel on the mainline linux gpu support front.
- the8472 6y agoAfaik AMD is buggy when passed to virtualized guest. nvidia also requires hacks to make it work. Intel is the only party where it's supported out of the box. Edit: incorrect terminology
- formerly_proven 6y agoDoesn't nVidia explicitly disable this feature unless it's a Quadro?
- the8472 6y agoThere are several ways to virtualize a card. Splitting the card into multiple virtual units only works with the pro/datacenter models. Passing through the whole card works if you trick the guest driver by hiding virtualization.
- tjoff 6y agoThat is a wholly different use case though. And I'd rather take AMDs difficulties in that regard over nVidia who are actively fighting it. Don't give money to someone that shits on you.
- pengaru 6y agoJudging from mainline's commit log for linux/drivers/gpu/drm/amd/amdgpu there's been a steady flow of SR-IOV related fixes/updates up to and including v5.8 so it's at least not being ignored. I admit I haven't used amdgpu in this capacity, but just the fact that we can scrutinize amdgpu's history in mainline is a huge improvement over the past.
- zamadatix 6y agoThis comment conflates pretty much everything it mentions: - Intel GPUs support mediated virtualization passthrough through GVT-G not SR-IOV - Nvidia blocks passthrough as a feature gatekeep in the driver. You can work around this block by hiding some info from the guest (the hacks mentioned). Consumer Nvidia cards do not support SR-IOV, special models that do require the proprietary driver and a license to SR-IOV (no hacks to workaround this) - AMD works fine under passthrough but requires specific models for SR-IOV (though this works on the official open driver). SR-IOV is still unstable. - None of this is really relevant to the original topic
- the8472 6y agoThanks for the correction. I only played around with it for a few evenings and intel was the only thing I managed to virtualize. I think they're relevant because being able to virtualize it is an aspect of not being a dumpster fire.
- Namidairo 6y ago> AMD works fine under passthrough but requires specific models for SR-IOV Did they ever ship a fix in mainline for their cards becoming stuck in unusable states without powering off the host? (I believe the fix involved a sequence of commands for a PSP reset) At least I believe AMD engineers were being helpful in giving details on it though.
- zamadatix 6y agoMade in 5.6 earlier this year finally.
- mixedCase 6y agoUsing the 5700XT with amdgpu has been a complete shit show since day one, and you have success depending on your set-up since QA appears to be "if it works on a dev's machine ship it". Mainline (let alone stable kernels) was almost unusable for like 4-5 months after release, you were completely out of luck unless you followed the right incantations and used a precise firmware binary that had been available at some point at an AMD developer's personal repo but you later had to get through someone else's Dropbox. After that period it got stable-ish for me. Occasionally Mesa/kernel updates made some games stop working or freeze the system but workarounds. Yesterday I swapped a monitor for a higher res one, and I triggered a bug where DPM essentially shits its pants and you have to switch to manual power management. Meaning a year after release the card can't handle basic multi-monitor stuff. I've had AMD CPUs exclusively ever since Athlon II, always coupled with Nvidia cards. I wanted to support them also in GPUs given their open source work but for me it's been a complete mess. If Intel GPUs are actually any good and don't shit the bed I'll sell this card for whatever I can get.
- vondur 6y agoI've been making sure to run the latest kernels and latest mesa Mesa, and my 5700xt has been great. But, I agree that the 5700 series had some serious issues in its original kernel releases.
- 1_player 6y agoYou don't believe him? https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/929 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/929 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/892 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues/892 I built a PC in June and bought a 5500XT and it's bloody unusable. It hangs if I plug a monitor, it hangs randomly, it hangs when idle, it's not a hardware defect since Windows is fine with it. Sorry but the Linux community has been bashing NVIDIA and praising AMD because "opensource" while there are critical bugs like that one that have been open for a year. It makes my blood boil. My opensource friendly 5500XT is on a shelf and I'm using an NVIDIA card in its place. And you better believe I will not be giving AMD my custom again.
- pjmlp 6y agoKind of, not if you are serious about GPGPU and not stuck with a laptop card. However the 3D programming experience still beats Intel drivers.
- Symmetry 6y agoMy experience has been that recently AMD's open source Linux driver has been quite nice, not always having all the latest features implemented but being very stable and roughly as performant as the closed source driver.
- bayindirh 6y agoAMD has revised its silicon (decoupled HDCP stuff from video encoder/decoder to be able to open source video hardware) to enable unencumbered open source drivers while nVidia obfuscates everything deeper and deeper. It's a big disservice to compare them to nVidia about driver quality at this point.
- vetinari 6y agoAMD has it done in a way that even the open source drivers support HDCP and Trusted Memory Zone. Any attempt of comparison to Nvidia is nonsense, they are different universes.
- bayindirh 6y agoActually, the Intel drivers work really well until they don't. With every new kernel release, my laptop shows more and more visual artifacts god knows why. Hope that their GPU driver quality won't degrade to e1000e levels, where cards freeze randomly or lose links just because they didn't find the passing packets as exciting as I do, get bored and stop working.
- mpol 6y agoCan confirm :) I once bought a pci card with Intel Gigabit. Slashdot comments were very positive about this being the best card with the best drivers. Oh wow, just looking at the kernel dmesg was infuriating. Reset upon reset, where the NIC would just be unavailable for seconds. Even a major update (I don't know, 4x to 5x or something) did not even change anything. Currently my laptop updated to linux kernel 5.7, where Xfce and Xfwm just break down and get stuck. Going back to 5.6 makes everything work. Nope, I don't trust Intel to make good Linux drivers. Will not buy again :( I never had this in 20 years of using AMD/ATI.
- formerly_proven 6y agoIntel drivers seem to go down the drain as soon as the hardware is a few years old.
- bayindirh 6y agoCurrently e1000e is problematic even in relatively new hardware. On Windows, they publish WHQL certified broken drivers.
- boudin 6y agoAMD support is really good, I would put their support on Linux ahead of Intel.
- drewg123 6y agoI'll probably get downvoted for saying this, but the only graphics drivers that have worked reliably for me on Linux (and FreeBSD) are the proprietary Nvidia ones. When I ran Ubuntu, I'd have to blacklist the Nouveau driver to avoid oopses.
- notyourday 6y agoI agree. I'm running prop nVidia driving 4x 4k monitors under X11 and it. just. works. Nouveau driver crashes every few days. Intel has freezes in Mesa. It is a known issue.
- isatty 6y agoSame. I don’t really remember what it was like before the 4xx series but the proprietary driver has worked fine for me on Gentoo. Both for gaming and for passthrough for virtualized envs (although this is recent).
- winter_blue 6y agoWhat problems have you experienced with AMD drivers? I'm asking because Nvidia has been an absolute pain on my laptop (e.g. sleep is terribly broken), and I'm considering a switch over to the Ryzen 4700U, which has pretty powerful integrated Radeon graphics. So I'm trying to decide if I should instead switch to i7-1065G7 instead, which has good integrated (Intel) graphics. This is a really important question to me; I would appreciate any answers.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoI ran into an amdgpu when I built my most recent desktop (the card would randomly lock up and turn its fans on full speed with some combination of OpenGL and power management.). I think it’s been fixed, though, I haven’t had any issues for several months now.
- Athas 6y agoI have been running open source AMD drivers on my desktop since I got it (early 2018, Vega 64 GPU). They work well, and after so many years, it felt like a revelation to have problem-free high-performance 3D acceleration after a fresh installation of a default Linux kernel. The only place where AMD is still wonky is when you want to do GPGPU, but that is mostly down to AMDs byzantine and schizophrenic software strategy (just try to pin down which parts of ROCm you need, or what they do). You don't have to worry about that for graphics, though, as the amdgpu driver is in the kernel, and the default Mesa OpenGL works perfectly with it.
- cycomanic 6y agoI've been running a rx480 for quite a while and the amdgpu drivers in the kernel are completely without problems (I've recently started gaming a bit again and fallout 4 runs on highest settings under proton without issues) . At some time I tried the pro drivers and performance actually degraded. I can second what somebody else posted, that doing gpugpu is a bit of a pain because it's difficult to figure out what to install. On the other hand Intel isn't really better there.
- aidenn0 6y agoAt work my workstation has a Radeon pro, with Kubuntu 18LTS. The most noticable thing is that the KDE taskbar freezes (interestingly enough, the taskbar is my biggest driver issue, as on Nvidia it will render as garbage, and the garbage changes when I scroll in Firefox. With nouveau, Xorg just crashed about 4x per week). Switching to a text console and back clears up the issues for a few hours to a few days.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoA few weeks ago I put together a gaming system with an RX 5700 XT GPU and X570 motherboard. I've installed both Linux (Pop_OS! 20.04) and Windows 10 on it. With Pop_OS! using the open-source amdgpu driver, everything worked beautifully. The only notable downside (which I don't really care about) was not having polished utilities for tweaking the GPU's behavior, and uncertainty about the status of FreeSync. My experience on Windows 10 has been much worse. There seemed to be a 3-way argument between my monitor, GPU driver, and Windows regarding HDR settings. And unlike on Linux, an apparent bug in AMD's driver causes instability when using HDMI to stream audio to my monitor.
- qchris 6y agoThis is one of the reasons I really enjoy Pop. The GPU support is really at the top of the class for Linux, and it seems like System76 spends a lot of time making sure it stays that way.
- aidenn0 6y agoI could care less about how it works with free-sync HDR gaming, &c. My laptop with 3 year old Intel Pro graphics is fast enough for everything I do on Linux, but my two workstations with an nvidia 1050Ti and A 3 year old Radeon Pro are both unusable for me. If Intel made a 8+ core Xeon with built-in graphics for under $1000 I would buy it over a $300 Ryzen and a $200 discrete GPU just to have stable graphics on Linux because I'm experiencing $500 worth of pain in my graphics not working on a near daily basis.
- pizza234 6y agoI guess YMMV. I use Nvidia with proprietary drivers, and I have only one minor problem (the windows of some open programs get corrupted on resume). I also have Intel on my laptop and have no problems at all (I had an issue in the past, but I've solved it by updating the drivers). Nouveau is definitely a "dumpster fire", if one wants to put it that way, but that's pretty much openly caused by Nvidia. To be clear, I don't use pretty much any 3D though, so I can only speak for "typical office usage".
- aidenn0 6y agoIt was fine when only 3d games could cause crashes, but now that firefox and KDE's window-manager all use hardware-acceleration it's just terrible. The binary drivers are definitely better than nouveau though for stability, except maybe for some older hardware. Most issues fix themselves when I switch to a text console then back to X11, but every now and then I have to restart X11 to fix things.
- pjmlp 6y agoGiven my experience with GL programming across all three, Intel is definitely not the first choice.
- vbezhenar 6y agoThis is new architecture. Whether it’ll have good support or not remains to be seen. That said, generally I agree that Intel provides excellent support for Linux.